10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Cape May

“We mostly go for the ice cream!! Large portions And lots of toppings, friendly staff And most of all yummy“

“Where do I start … at the beginning … Mr softee has always held a special place in my heart since childhood memories recall the days when my friends and I would get so excited to hear music coming from the truck as it made its way down our street … to my visit tonight at the brick and mortar location in CMCH NJ. This location is clean on the inside and has a drive thru.

The other thing I love is that while I enjoy soft serve I also enjoy hard ice cream and this location offers both. Although their hard ice cream flavor offering is limited but covers your basic chocolate strawberry vanilla along with a couple of other flavors.

Tonight we wanted milkshakes and they were delicious!

But what really stood out was the young boy who served me at the drive thru window. His customer service was EXEMPLARY. He was articulate, helpful, patient and sociable. I hope his parents see this review so that they know that they are knocking the parenting thing out of the park!

My only regret is that I didn’t get his name!

We will certainly return and hope that the “boss” gives that boy a generous bonus or raise.

Ps I always beep and wave at your Mr softee mascot when I see them on Main Street.“

“These are the best things ever!! In the summer you can’t get near the place because it’s so busy. The like is worth the wait! They have mail order and we have ordered three times! The more u order the better the price. This last time we ordered 24! The owner of this store is super nice and treats his employees so good! Def MUST HAVE!!“

“Very good ice cream/frozen custard. Apparently, they pioneered its making, coining the term. I wish Kohr Brothers would list the ingredients in their ice cream/frozen custard somewhere; they do use whole eggs. It may be a known fact, but it would be nice for those who don't know.“

“The staff was wonderful! They were incredibly friendly and were quick with my ice cream. The cherry flavor wasn't as sweet as I expected but I shouldn't have expected it to be exactly like other cherry flavors I have had before 😅 would gladly go again“

“I live in OCNJ and usually travel to Lancaster PA for my favorite ice cream, now I only have to go to Cape May! This place is unbelievably good! These other people not giving 5 stars definitely don’t know good ice cream! We will be back often! Probably more often then we should lol“

“Our favorite place to get ice cream! Great staff, great vibes and great ice cream💖“

“After a week long stay in July in Cape May we were basically on the hunt for a new ice cream spot nightly, it's hot & all you do in CM is walk everywhere! Entire Kohr Bros & you bet it hit the spot. Yummy frozen custard & since I'm a sucker for history knowing they've been around for over 100 yrs made me enjoy it all the more!“

“Stunning decoration that transport you to the vibes of a 1950s ice cream parlor. The ice cream was fantastic! I tried the matcha infused soft serve with honey and it was perfectly sweetened! They have a variety of flavors and ice cream options. They also had vegan and GF options! The parking was tricky so its probably easier to walk, but would be the perfect way to end a fantastic day at the beach!“

“We went early and enjoyed the peaceful atmosphere. The food was delicious. We had the seafood pasta. The broth was perfect for dipping the bread. The serving size was generous. The staff were friendly and attentive. We will definitely return!“