10 Best Italian Restaurants in East Rutherford

Annabella's House of Mozzarella Italian • $$
900 Paterson Plank Rd, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Annabella’S World Famous Cheesecake
Mozzarella & Tomato Platter
Italian Antipasto Platter
Gourmet Sandwich Luncheon
Heavenly Cheesecake Slice
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Platter
Chicken Parmesan
Penne Alla Vodka

“Four of us went to dinner here and the food was excellent. Rice balls were perfect, two types of chicken parm were very good. Relaxing, chill atmosphere, did not feel rushed at all. Terrific wait staff! Look forward to visiting again soon.“

4.4 Superb148 Reviews
Vesta Wood-Fired Italian • $$
64 Hoboken Rd, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pappardelle Bolognese
Grilled Artichokes
Arancini Riceballs
Italian Meat Board
Eggplant Rollatini
Mozzarella Sticks
Margherita Pizza
Wood-Fired Pizza
Large Margherita

“Excelente atención ala persona 👍“

4.3 Superb270 Reviews
Dominick's Restaurant & Bar - Al Di La Caterers Italian • $$
1 Hoboken Rd, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Our Famous Rigatoni Vodka Sauce
Baby Artichokes Alla Francese
Angus Rib-Eye Steak Giambotta
Rigatoni Zingara Gypsy-Style
Grandma’S Homemade Lasagna
Homemade Lasagne with Meat
Mussels Mulberry Street
Original Chicken Savoy
Spicy Garlic Shrimp

“He is the King of Vodka Sauce! Place is always spotless and well cared for with a lively staff and the best vodka sauce“

4.2 Good105 Reviews
Ralph’s Italian • $
230 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Roast Beef Cold Sandwich
Cheese Pizza by the Slice
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Roast Beef Sandwich
Chicken Parmigiana
Plain Pizza Slice
Mozzarella Sticks
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Meatball Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza

“Every year visit. Always amazing“

3.9 Good96 Reviews
Carpaccio Italian • $$$
1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail and Pasta Fagioli
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Pappardelle Lamb Ragu
Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti Bolognese
Mozzarella Caprese
Tiramisu Dessert
Chicken Francese
Chicken Marsala
Calamari Fritti

“Great food - very good serving and delicious deserts“

3.9 Good169 Reviews
Vinoteca Wine Bar • $$
Recommended
1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Pesto Mozzarella Flatbread
Cheese \u0026 Meat Board
Bruschetta Al Pomodoro
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Truffle Flatbread
Charcuterie Board
Portobello Panino
Cheese Board
Meatballs
Burrata

“My friends & I went to Vinoteca last week and had such a wonderful time. The wine is very refreshing & delicious!! I love the fact that it’s self-served. To top it off, the food was out of this world!!! The staff was very kind & attentive and I would recommend Vinoteca to all, but, most importantly to all the wine lovers. You would soon make this your to go to place. We had such a great time last week, we will be doing it again this weekend. Come along, hopefully I’ll see you there!!“

4.5 Superb114 Reviews
Gusto WoodFired Pizza Pizza • $$
119 Park Ave, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Egg Rolls
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
Pear & Gorgonzola Pizza
Fried Rainbow Cookies
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fuhgettaboutit Pizza
Limoncello Macarpone
Mediterranean Salad
Chicken Parmigianas
BBQ Chicken Pizza

“We went to Gusto on Monday October 11 around 6pm. The waitress was very nice and friendly. All of our questions were answered politely. We received our drinks within 5 minutes of ordering them. We quickly received a basket of warm bread and a dish of high quality olive oil with olives. Our appetizers arrived shortly after. The crispy mozzarella triangles are HUGE! and delicious. The marinara dipping sauce was also very good. We were a party of 5 and everyone loved the food. Steamed clams were flavorful. The fried calamari was perfectly crispy. The pizza was delicious with a nice thin and crispy crust. Prices are reasonable considering the serving sizes are pretty big. The restaurant is very clean and nicely decorated. I especially love the beautiful flower wall which would make a great photo op background for a special occasion. My only suggestion is to add some more non carbonated options to the drinks, à nice lemonade would be delightful.“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
The New Park Tavern Bar • $$
250 Park Ave, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana w Spaghetti
Drunken Chicken Parm Dinner
Sausage and Cheese Calzone
Pint of Guinness Stout
Deluxe Cheeseburger
Corn Beef Sandwich
Plain Cheese Pizza
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Meatball Pizza

“An awesome family run business with excellent staff!!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
Al Di La Italian Bistro Bar • $$
1 Hoboken Rd, East Rutherford

“My husband and I enjoyed two delicious meals on Nov 8, 2025. The clams casino were out of this world, as were the veal osso buco and the chicken and shrimp. You know your entree will be great when the vegetables are delicious!!
Our waitress, Carol, was a delight and very attentive.
We were visiting from RI and wish they’d move!“

3.5 Good10 Reviews
Mozzarella Bar Italian • $$
One American Dream Wy A390, East Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Rosemary Flatbread and Foccia with Bruschetta
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Farfalle with Salmon
Spaghetti Carbonara
Chicken Parmesan
Bread Appetizer
Pizza Pepperoni
Tiramisu
Ravioli
Burrata

“Food is amazing! Been here 2 years in a row when visiting the American dream mall and the raviolis as well as the fettuccine Alfredo were phenomenal! Best Alfredo I’ve had by far, and the chicken in it was soooo flavorful!!! So good, I recommend . Reasonable prices“

3.2 Average166 Reviews

You May Also Like