9 Best Italian Restaurants in Rutherford

Fiorentini Restaurant Italian • $$$
98 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Handmade Short Ribs Agnolotti
Cacio E Pepe with Mussels
Octopus Appetizer
Gnocchi Stuffed
Grilled Octopus
Salami Board
Risotto
Truffle
Tiramisu

“Food was pretty good. I wouldn't say it was the best food we've had but definitely far from the worst. Maybe it was because we came in pretty late in the evening but we enjoyed the food. Would definitely come back and give it another shot. Our waiter was very kind and patient and was good with giving recommendations.“

4.5 Superb102 Reviews
Ferazzoli's italian kitchen Pizza • $
317 Union Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Buffalo Wings
Cheese Pizza
Grandma Pie
Sandwiches
Italian
Salad
Sauce

“To start off, the Atmosphere is really nice. The service is amazing as well. Whatever I asked, for it is brought to me. The pizza is really delightful. There are also deserts like ice cream Sweet pizzas. I think you should really come to this place you will not regret it!!“

4.5 Superb75 Reviews
Suprema Italian • $$
92 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Vodka Chicken Parm
Arancini Rice Balls
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Sandwich
Milano Sandwich
Veal Parmigiana
Artichoke Salad
Caprese
Tiramisu

“I truly love this place, their sandwiches and artichoke salad are so good. Unfortunately their prices continually go up, and it’s become hard to justify $25 for a salad, I will still get it every once in awhile as a treat, but my once $13 go to sandwich is now up to $18 ?“

4.4 Superb73 Reviews
Steven's Cafe Cafe • $
106 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Ham Cheese Croissant
Almond Croissant
Garden Omelette
Avocado Toast
Rutherford
New Yorker
Avocado

“I've gotten pastries many times from Steven's and they are always great. Bagels are pretty good too. The coffee is the only reason for not giving five stars; it's fine but not why I go there. Service is always really good and the staff very nice.“

4.2 Good88 Reviews
Song E Napule - Rutherford Pizza • $$
106 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Calzone Song'e Napule
Polpo Alla Luciana
Margherita Pizza
Polpette Al Sugo
Delizia Al Limone
Calamari Fritti
Fried Calzone
Italian Bread
Napoletana
Tiramisu

“Food is fresh and incredible. The quality is 10/10, between the decor of maradona and the pizza, you feel (and taste) like you are in Napoli and southern Italy. The gnocchi is delicious too! It is small inside so I suggest making reservations.“

4.1 Good176 Reviews
Volares Italian • $$
7 Station Square, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Carpaccio Di Manzo with Arugula Capers Sliced Provolone Lemon Evvo with a Touch of Truffle
Breaded Veal with Truffle Cream Sauce
Tortellini in a White Vodka Sauce
Mussels in Garlic Wine Sauce
Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare
Hot Antipasto Misto for Two
Mussels Bianco O Rosso
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Mussels in White Sauce
Linguine with Clams

“I don’t write reviews but I had to take the time and write how amazing Volares restaurant is! love this place so much. Every food item I have tried has exceeded my expectations greatly. The food is amazing, and even the place itself. It’s very clean, it’s super authentic and very pleasant staff.I will be returning for sure!“

4.1 Good53 Reviews
The Risotto House Italian • $$
88 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Asparagus Risotto
Risotto Primavera
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Francese
Fried Calamari
Burrata Salad
Seafood Salad
Chicken Parm
Cesar Salad
Bruschetta

“Hello my foodies. I went here with my coworkers to celebrate our company Xmas dinner in Jan! Better late than never. My friend recommended this place and it was a good place. It's small, but well lit and very friendly atmosphere. The owners daughter was our host and server along with some other very nice staff. It was a Wednesday so it was very quiet in the restaurant. Probably one of their slower days, but we were fine without the crowds. Everything we ordered was great, except the pasta fagoli soup I had. It wasn't terrible, but the broth had no flavor. I still ate it, though, because my Dr. says to cut back on the salt anyway. It was still passable! Everything else was great, and they even let you BYOB, and they let us bring in a small cake. My friends wanted to re-do my birthday cake since the last place I went to was awful! I'll update you on that place in a moment! I had the penne vodka with chicken. I love penne vodka, but I find it hard to find a place that makes it good. This place made it very well. Delicious! I recommend this place as they have a great variety of items to choose from, true Italian style dishes. We had a wonderful time here. And it's not bad on your pocketbook either. If you're in the area, stop by and check it out. Parking is on the street. Meters are done by 7pm.“

3.7 Good35 Reviews
Paisano's Italian • $$
132 Park Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Malafemina Entrée
Pappardelle Bolognese
Oxtail Ragu & Burrata
Braised Beef Ravioli
Chocolate Lava Cake
Spaghetti Carbonara
Pappadelle Paisano
Crabmeat Ravioli
Stuffed Pork Chop
Lobster Ravioli

“Paisano’s is amazing Italian food. I travel to NJ several times per year and I’ll easily go 2 or three times in a week if I can. The food is so consistently good that I can get the same dish months apart.I’ve always brought my own wine like others but now they have a drink menu as well. ($15 cork fee for BYO wine)I usually get the pear raviolis and if you love balsamic it’s perfect. For dinner the Oxtail Ragu is the perfect mix of homemade pasta, meat and a tasty burrata on top. I ordered it two nights in a row recently and I’d do it again if I was still there.The staff is professional and many of them have been working there for years. I’ve never had a bad experience. I’ll be back as often as I can.“

3.7 Good108 Reviews
Mama Rosa Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
332 Union Ave, Rutherford

Customers` Favorites

Mama Rosa Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Calamari
Personal Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sauce

“BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! Huge portions & great service. I had family visiting and they wanted to try good pizza so who better than Mama Rosa. They were very impressed and understood why it was the best in town. Their specialty slices are top tier and penne vodka with chicken dinner, excellent. I think they’re the only ones that would go above and beyond if you asked them to customize a pizza/meal that’s not on the menu. Very reasonable pricing for the huge portions they give. Friendly staff, cool and clean atmosphere, they never disappoint!“

3.5 Good41 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In Rutherford

map Map