15 Best Italian Restaurants in Lyndhurst

“The BEST mozzarella around. I now compare every mozzarella to Vinnie Mootz! Their pizza is to die for. They sandwiches are delectable! He does mozzarella making classes that are not just informative but fun. Vinnie has a great spirit and sense of humor along with the passion he has for making the best product he can. I recommend Vinnie Mootz for all your party needs, and just stop in and pick up some Mozzarella, you will not be disappointed. Love You Vinnie's Mootz! From: The Bike Girl“

“excellent, outstanding food and very nice atmosphere.“

“Delicious food. Great birthday celebration.“

“We had my daughter's graduation party here, and plan on having my Son's party this year. Very reasonable prices. The atmosphere is great, staff very professional and the food is delicious! Could not have asked for anything better.“

“Celebrating my retirement party with family and friends this Sunday afternoon, everybody was talking about great food and taste of everything that was delivered to the table..Service was great, total attention to my guest and great children for few hours that we were there...5 stars definitely.....“

“All the food is fresh and the pastries are amazing...“

“This is our 2nd time there and the food is great i enjoyed eating there, great vibe staff awesome and the price hands up.“

“Picked up 10 pies last night for a party. Pies were ready on time hot and delicious. First time ordering from here and highly recommend! Thank you!“

“One of the bedrock establishments in local food lore - Angelo’s manicotti is ethereal - light and delicious, totally hand made from bottom up

Everything is incredible and the service is of a level you’ll be hard pressed to find elsewhere

Glass never empires

Thank you for a great lunch Angelo’s“

“Best choice I have made since I started using the Slice app. Good food, prompt delivery, huge selection and the people doing the deliveries are great. Have tried numerous menu items without any disappointment. Happy to support a great local business!“

“I had to order last minute for my daughter's St. Marys high school teachers appreciation week. The owner was amazing. Not only did he take my huge order last minute...he delivered it in time for lunch for the teachers and staff!!! They loved it. Fresh and delicious....the turkey and provolone ...and Spicy Italian were a crowd pleaser!!! Will definitely order again...and highly recommend ? ? ?“

“Everything!!! Very pleasant workers. Always welcomed with a smile. All around great place.“

“I work at the urgent care in town and this is our go to pizza spot. Food is delicious and always arrives at a speedy rate. However, today the delivery woman was very rude and condescending. She wasn't aware that I paid for my order online, no big deal. I attempted to tip her but she didn't have change. I then noticed that my drink was missing. When I mentioned it to her, she said "you did not order a drink. Call the store yourself" & got in her car and drove away. I was shocked because I've personally never had a bad experience with anyone in the food industry and I'm always nice and respectful. When she came back with my beverage, she handed it to me and said "here you go" and walked off. Not sure why the attirude was necessary. However, when I called the store to let them know about the missing item the man who answered was kind and accomodating. Overall, I love this place but just disappointed with the delivery service.“

“After many, many recommendations finally tried Gencarelli’s. So good!! Starting with fabulous service, delicious food, very generous portions, everything was really good. Chicken franchise and chicken piccata were delicious, side of pasta with vodka sauce was some of the best sauce I’ve had in a long time. I’ll definitely be back soon.“

“The food is fantastic, the portions are very generous and the service is great!“