44 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark

“Today at Blaze I experienced the best customer service , Herberto immediately jumped in and took action when observed a 2 customers were undecided , while his team mate help assisted the 2 ladies , he showed great team work taking the next customer , keeping the line moving. Such small gestures can make a huge difference . GREAT JOB .“

“I had a great experience at Pizza Hut thanks to Kero. From the moment I walked in, he greeted me with a friendly attitude and made me feel genuinely welcome. While taking my order, he took the time to explain the current deals and promotions, making sure I got the best value for my money. He also suggested some better options based on what I was ordering, which helped me make a better choice and save a little extra. His knowledge of the menu, professionalism, and willingness to help really stood out. It's not often you receive customer service that feels this personal and attentive. Kero made the whole experience enjoyable, and I appreciate the excellent service he provided. I'll definitely be returning because of the positive impression he made.“

“I love a good double Italian hotdog and the best place to get one is here! They have the freshest bread and the food just tastes incredible! They are reasonably priced and give you good portions. The only bad thing is that it's a cash only kind of place, so make sure to bring cash. The next time I near this area, I will definitely be back. Highly recommend!“

“Small little pizza joint we stopped at on vacation. We were there from Florida for the World Cup game. It was very difficult to get parking but that was an issue all over really. So glad we snagged a spot and were able to go in and enjoy. We had a few different slices, I had the chicken caesar and it was DELICIOUS. We had buffalo chicken, cheese and a broccoli one at the table too and all were great! From a Florida traveler it was one of the best pizzas I've had and my favorite of my travels around. Staff was super nice 👍🏻“

“I've only had delivery, but the food is delicious, and the portions ample.“

“It was around 9:25 am and wanted some substance, I got the Stromboli the one that comes with chimichuri sauce. the food Tasted wonderful and the service was wonderful as well with a smile.
The young man making the pizza made wonderful, looking pizzas and the lady that warmed up the Stromboli and took my payment was wonderful as well. I will definitely recommend this place.“

“I made an order.. their delivery personnel which happens to be an outside contractor, was doordash.. and u guessed right. Doordash did not deliver my food. I called and the rep that was at the store was so kind and understanding....i picked my food up instead.. he had a whole new order hot and ready for me... such a nice young man. He even apologized sincerely.. PH you got a good employee and a new customer to this location! My pizza did not disappoint!!!“

“Best pizza ever and the staff is great too! Love it!“

“The Food is Fantastic and creative.“

“Had some errands to do in Newark, me and friend stopped in for a cocktail and lunch 10/10. great atmosphere, awesome staff. If I didn't live so far I would be a regular“

“Thier Veggie 🍕Pizza is the best hands down.“

“EXQUISITO 🍕😋👏🏻MÍ PIZZERÍA PREFERIDA EN IRONBOUND.“

“the best pizza in the world“

“Wonderful, quaint pizza shop! I had been dying to try a Brazilian pizza restaurant, but my hometown doesn’t have too many, so I spotted this one, and was not at all disappointed!!

Our pizza was INCREDIBLE! Just thinking about it right now makes me want more! Too bad I’m a plane ride away :(. I had the best flan/pudim I have ever had in my entire life here. I can’t stop thinking about it!

The owner was very sweet, seems to have a desire to server the community as well, as I saw him giving pizza to a woman in need for incredibly cheap.“

“Great taste clean place great service Recommended it“

“Best pizza in Newark!!! Been eating this pizza for over 30 years!“

“I have no problems whatsoever when I go to Golden Pizzeria. Food is awesome, always hot and fresh. Everyone loves their food. Staff is awesome very polite friendly and professional. If you're from the neighborhood then you know about Golden Pizzeria. They are 🔥.“

“I was skeptical because I had seen people going into the diner close by and not this one. The server was friendly and got my order correct. I ordered a bacon egg and pepper jack cheese, with onion , mayo, and lettuce sandwich. The pork bacon was crispy even the fat ? and you could smell the maple . Definitely will be back for another tummy happy ?“

“Healthy food, healthy environment Taste great!“

“Excellent food. Ordered Chicken burger, fries and friend chicken. Food was fresh, tasty and warm. More than everything, had a great conversation with Mr. Javed while waiting for my food to get ready, who is the owner of the restaurant and a thorough gentleman. Will highly recommend.“

“I've been going ther for a while now and was very satisfied with their food and service until today. 9/28/16. I ordered a Ham n Turkey Sub. Well the meat on my sandwich is soooo thick! What the hell, it ripped the bread in half. I took of the thick meat and the edges of both meats were hard as a rock. Then they charged me 2.50 more on the regular price. What a ugly sandwich. Sad to say I won't be back. Because overall my previous experiences there have been good. P.S . I have pic of my sandwich, just don't know how to put them up? Very Disappointed.“

“This spot makes the best cheese steak in the area. Their pizza is also top notch. When you get a sandwich from here, I recommend the potato fries. His fries are natural and delicious-tasting. It's right next to a fire station where you can't miss the colorful awning. Again, their pizza is amazing!“

“First time visiting! Got a 3 piece chicken with fries and roll. Pretty tasty really! Chicken fried well and seasoned . Bread was so fresh and so was my chocolate cake dessert. Big slice of cake too for serving. I used the drive thru which was really slow but I heard high compliments so I waited. They take all form of payments which is great! They have plenty condiments in my bag with utensils and napkins. Price was reasonable for this economy shockingly . Young man server was nice and remembered my order by heart.

Food was fresh, hot and delicious.“

“Decided to check this place out for karaoke while in town and, man, what a little gem this was! The owner and manager were so welcoming! The vibe was so positive and everyone seemed rather friendly! ✨️ We are in town for another week and we will be back!
Heads up: they are cash only!“

“I love this place the service was amazing both the people in the food and the people in the register were all so nice and let’s talk about the pricing it’s amazing for a pizzeria store and not only do they have pizza and hot food they have sandwiches hot subs breakfast platter cookies all kinds of stuff. But what I love the most was the fact that the slides and the pizzas are very affordable. I once asked the cook if he could make me something that was not in the menu and they accepted and did it gracefully.“

“Great tasty pizza! If you need 75 pies for a last minutes party they can handle it ! They can make up to 75 pies an hour! Great oven system! Check them out! 🇮🇹✝️ 🍕“

“I am from Montclair but travel to Newark often for their chicken, mac and cheese, onion rings, pizza and shrimp. Yum. Their employees are wonderful. The restaurant is busy because their food is worth it. It is inappropriate for anyone to suggest that their location means they should sell their good food for cheap.“

“I’m obsessed with &pizza! I love being able to build my own pizza with all the toppings I like. The ingredients always taste fresh, and their pepperoni and bacon combo is delicious. The ginger berry lemonade is also a must-try. It’s fast, modern, and the vibe is cool – perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner.“

“I celebrated my nomination this evening in this excellent restaurant. Well it was a enjoyable evening and the restaurant was unquestionably the reason for this successful meeting. The crew contributed in a gorgeous way, the cooking was very good and my buddies were very glad. We shall absolutely come back again for more joyful events. thanks very much.“

“We Love Love Love this Pizzería! We ordered 4 meat and cheese Calzones and a large pie! Ingredients are fresh, It’s seasoned to PERFECTION do you hear me PERFECTION! Piping hottttttt!!! The Customer Service is amazingly awesome! We are proud to be new customers! Thank You for the wonderful service and Delicious food! God Bless the hands that prepare the food Amen 🙏🏼“

“Thank you to Steve and staff for hosting our corporate holiday luncheon!“

“We went for my birthday and everything was great, the food,the service. Totally recommend.“

“Fantastic pizza and a great place for a vegan in a rush! They provide vegan cheese and a variety of healthy vegan friendly toppings. The service is so fast and your pizza is cooked within minutes of ordering. So tasty and the servers provide a glove change so that there is no cross contamination.“

“Only came to pick up their version of smash burgers and was pleasantly surprised to find out how popular their pizza is. (Yes it's a pizza shop, but not MY pizza shop) The homemade cookies are worth coming in for but don't be surprised if they're gone.“

“was the most flavorful pizza I've ever eaten. grandmother pizza is the name“

“Delicioso😋“

“I love Nicosia pizza and I will forever love it however the new 2 workers provided wrong pricing trying to swindle me and the pizza they have made is nasty it would never compare to the way the old owners made it ..it literally was the worst pizza ive ever tasted“

“<Please read the entire review or you'll likely be confused about my stance. Thank you!><Out of consideration of those afflicted with ADHD & the easily distracted, please ignore the main review and accept in it's place a <tldr> you've wasted too much time already, order yourself a pie now (may I recommend you get fresh garlic as a topping?), food is great, a bit expensive and can be a longer wait than advertised but more than worth it!</tldr>For the rest of you, let me start by mentioning the food is a bit on the expensive side when compared to other pizza places. It was about $24 for a large pizza with one topping. I know you can easily get a couple top pizzas and a 2 liter elsewhere for slightly less than that but don't do that unless you are on a fixed income and in that case, what are you doing ordering out? Cook dinner at home... Every penny counts! But assuming you can swing $25 for a single pie, then read on.... I ordered online using the slice app which you supposedly get a 10% discount for doing. I don't know if it actually is much of a discount as the menu at the place has significantly lower prices listed in it though there is a sign next to the menus stating the menus prices are no longer correct and that the prices have gone up so its quite possible the slice app does indeed reflect the accurate pricing, I have not tried ordering in person or over the phone so I am unable to advise you on this though it's possible it might be cheaper in person. I can however say that based on my experience, the slice app is not the most accurate source of info as it stated that my food would be ready to pickup about 15-20min after I placed it and so I arrived about 22 minutes after I ordered, 2 minutes after the app informed me that the food was cooked and ready for pickup but when I spoke to the guy behind the counter, he informed me it was going to be right out but needed a couple more minutes which as I wasn't in a rush I said no problem and began to wait. I understand things happen, especially around dinner time when restaurant can be slammed with orders but that didn't seem to factor in that day as surprisingly despite it being dinner time, the place was basically dead that day. There was one table dining in and a minute or two before my food was ready, another customer walked in to place an order, that was it, that was everybody I saw the entire time I was there and so far as I could tell there wasn't anything else cooking in the oven or waiting for delivery, perhaps I had just missed it beat the rush? so it's hard to say why the delay and even stranger why the app claimed it was ready when clearly it wasn't but after having to wait another 5-10min past when the app informed me it was done, it finally actually became ready. Now normally given the wait and high prices, this would be the end of my review and I'd advise against the place but... (I know this is long but you have just made it to the surprise twist hooray! ?) not this place, not today! Despite the issues I have mentioned there is something that absolutely trumps all of that... the service? Heck no! It's the food! It was absolutely delicious! The fresh garlic (IMHO, the perfect pizza topping when made correctly and correctly it was made here!) was fresh, fell chopped and plentiful in proportion but not excessive. Had it been priced in the $15-19 range I would have said that the pie was a good size being large enough to easily feed 3 or 4 people. Were it a lesser pizza, I'd have declared $24 highway robbery, especially when you factor in the delays and the price but I'm telling you, that factoring all that in, it is still easily $24 delicious... I mean don't let this declaration of deliciousness give the owner of Pizza Town a swollen head or anything, it's definitely not $25+ delicious but it is just within the upper limit of what I might occasionally spend on a pizza (0k you win, I'd even pay $25! Hope they have fin“

“awesome food, great service!“

“I've been to the all-you-can-eat restaurant a few times and really liked it. But today I was disappointed because I really wanted to eat a pizza with catupiry, so I called and ordered a pizza with catupiry and they sent it to me with cream cheese. They didn't tell me that it didn't have catupiry... It only had cream cheese. Otherwise, the pizza is delicious, just be careful with catupiry if you like it...“