50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Rutherford

“Best Grapefruit ice cream ♥️“

“Try their Milk Teas served hot! They also have alternative milk options, oat/almond, etc so be sure to ask for your dietary needs. The red velvet cookie was amazing, their was an Oreo baked inside?!

I had Thai Pink Milk tea served Hot! Definitely coming back when I'm in the area, eager to try Rolled Ice cream & their basil chicken. Lunch Specials available 11:30AM-3:30PM, only $12“

“what do I recommend? The ice cream....“

“Wednesday at 2pm sooo happy they were open January 7th, anyways, had gone to take Luke to get blood work and told him, I'll take him to Dairy Queen, wow great spot ended up getting a Small peanut butter and Luke had his favorite favorite cone with rainbow sprinkles yummy , the girl was really nice in they're, def coming again soon“

“A few years ago, I was hired to write a series of articles about regional Italian cuisine. Since then, I have been looking for traditional Italian gelato. Until yesterday, I have been consistently disappointed. But this? It was absolutely EVERYTHING I had dreamed about. The prices weren't ridiculous, the bathroom was PRISTINE, the staff were helpful and friendly and it was incredibly, amazingly delicious. My only complaint is that I live too far away from your stores to get it very often. But about that? My hips are less upset about the distance. :) I will definitely be back, though!“

“You don’t have to travel to Italy 🇮🇹 to taste the best and authentic Italian gelato in the city. Venchi is my favorite place if I’m craving for something sweet. Great service with friendly staff. Highly recommended.“

“Todo lo que halla jajajaja muy rico“

“Excellent ice cream in a wide array flavors from the most conventional to surprising new ideas. Sparkling clean shop with professionally servers. Couldn’t have been more delighted with our visit.“

“Finally trying their hot chocolate. It’s amazing if you like straight up melted chocolate in a cup. It’s bittersweet and warm. If you have strawberries, you can dip them in and have DIY chocolate dipped strawberries with great quality chocolate. Grab a cup to-go and don’t waste the beautiful views of Central Park just ahead of it.“

“This place is fantastic! Real quality gelato. My favorite flavor is the dark chocolate. Mariana and Selena working behind the counter are superstars! Very friendly and personable and they really get you excited about the gelato they are preparing for you. Excellent service! Thank you Mariana and Selena! We will be back!“

“Place is awesome, and love their gelatos and sorbets. My mom loves the Fuji Apple flavored sorbet“

“Excellent gelato, which at first seemed pricey, but hey, it’s NYC, and they certainly gave a generous helping!
Spotlessly clean, with a large selection of chocolates as well; fast, friendly service.
The gelato hit the spot, and little cookie on top was a nice touch too.“

“An nicely provocation for the healthy people. Not fear! Dark chocolate, with your property Triptophane, serotonyn, fire on the metabolism to the perfect working process. I'm a vegan and my opinion on the actually assessment market is that already fitted for the vegan customers. The ice cream is wonderful.“

“It was a pleasure to work with Benjah Raphael. He was responsive to all questions, dependable and reliable in accomplishing the task at hand. I was most impressed with the turnaround and how quickly the settlement. I highly recommend him. He guarantees daily profit mining and trading for more information contact him via Financial Analyst-Benjah Raphael Email: benjahraphael293@gm Financial Analyst-Benjah Raphael“

“All of the soft serve is amazing but i hella enjoyed their Woodside today! Ube with mochi and toasted coconut flakes was perfection!“

“Love it the area is so welcoming and we didn’t have to wait long they recommended items and helped us pick our options scratchatela was very good. Would definitely recommend“

“Really neat little place, friendly people, delicious treats!“

“delicioso helado para adultos, el local, muy bueno.“

“This place offers around nine types of vegan gelati, including water-based (sorbets) and almond milk-based gelati. The gelati is excellent and very tasty. My one complaint is that they don't allow you to have just one scoop: two scoops is the minimum (for around $9); since the gelato was very filling, one scoop would actually do fine.“

“Excellent quality Italian gelato, rich flavors and smooth texture rarely found outside of Italy. Place is very cute like eating in a story book hut. Got the large size ($12) very disappointed finding a sizable air pocket at bottom of the gelato cup. 1 star taken off because feeling ripped off.“

“After a day spent on an event, I was craving for some soft cone icecream. I got lucky and found this place .

Tried their vanilla & chocolate cone and it was yummy . Customer service is great.

It's also connected to aunt Jenny's pretzels inside the store . They incorporated for better business, good idea .“

“Caramel miso gelato is outstanding. Beautifully balanced flavours with gentle umami from the miso and a smooth, sweet caramel finish. Rich but not overwhelming, very well executed.
Service is friendly and pleasant, adding to the overall experience. A great spot for interesting, well thought out gelato flavours.“

“Have been wanting to stop for the longest time. Finally did tonight. The food was fantastic! We were lucky enough to sit in the booth reserved for The Soprano Family!! Made the experience that much better. Nice to see the spot were the final episode was filmed but if we lived closer we would come back for the food!! So glad David Chase picked Holsten’s!!“

“This is immediately my new favorite dessert place. The flavors are very unique and actually all so good. Right amount of sweetness and great texture bc they all have a crunch or some type of added element. The sesame drizzle was so delicious I’m going to buy the bottle next time. Got the banana pudding and the toasted rice. So good that I bought a pint of it. The pint was like $14 which is a bit expensive but so worth it imo cause wow so good. The ice cream is $9 ish for 2 scoops and comes with free topping and free drizzle. A really good hefty sized scoops. Also the lady was such a vibe she was so friendly and had great recs. I will be a regular for sure“

“Stopped by and had a strawberry green tea. Best of luck, guys.“

“Tried the new Woodbridge location twice now and WOW! The Rocky Road and Chocolate were out of this world. We will definitely be repeat customers.“

“This place has long lines on sunny weekends, so I decided to try it on a weekday night. I was pleasantly surprised by the variety of flavors. I tried the coconut and the pineapple. Both were good.“

“We had a great experience here. The ice cream was delicious, the service was excellent, and there was a great variety of flavors to choose from. I had a cup with coconut and tiramisu flavors, and the combination was amazing. Some people in our group ordered the flower-shaped cones, which were beautiful and made the experience even more fun. Someone else ordered a coffee before our Broadway show, and it was exactly what they needed, the coffee was very good too.

I brought my family, and we had a lovely time stopping by after dinner in the area and before heading to a Broadway show. We were able to sit for a bit and enjoy our desserts together. I definitely recommend it as a sweet stop in the theater district.“

“My only complaint is that the lone worker today, when I was paying with a credit card (without tap) took my card and tried to use tap. Before she took my card I was going to put it into the card processor. When I pointed out that it doesn’t have tap, she (2x’s) typed my card information into the register screen and it was declined (plenty of credit was available because I got gas with it shortly after). I then used my debit card which she just took from me and again tried to use tap (again not a feature on that card either). She was finally able to put my card information for the debit card and it went through. If she had let me put my card in in the first place there would have been no problem with the original transaction attempt. I feel some of the staff might need better/more training on using the register.“

“I first discovered Van Leeuwen Ice Cream while exploring Hudson Yards 🍦✨ — one taste and I was instantly hooked. Creamy, indulgent, and creative with flavors that balance classic comfort and playful twists. It quickly became one of my favorite sweet stops in the city. 🌆💖

Their recent pink ice cream collab with Ed Sheeran was such a fun touch 🎶🍓💗 — proof that they’re not afraid to innovate while keeping quality top-notch. For anyone with a sweet tooth, Van Leeuwen is a must-try New York treat that never disappoints. 🙌🌸“

“Best ice cream in New Jersey highly recommended .. try the Dubai chocolate its addicting 🥰“

“This is the only reason I visit Chelsea Market when I am in town.“

“Amazing and delicious - you need to go here as soon as possible!!! Best ice cream!!“

“The ice cream at Tipsy Scoop is amazing. Great flavors. I bought a flight and got to try 4 flavors all delicious. my favorite was the mango margarita sorbet. I definitely plan to go back.“

“Never been before today but so happy we stopped by! Kids were thrilled with the flavor choices and I really liked there was a vegan option! We’ll definitely be stopping in again. 😃“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“Always a must whenever visiting the city! A person with a peanut allergies dream! Today we stopped by but the shop was closed for a private event, no worries tho because they served us our ice cream right outside in our car!! Felt so special and the kids were super excited!“

“Thank you for having cruelty free ice cream options.“

“Best in NJ! The number one spot of choice to satisfy my sweet tooth and get my daily dose of caffeine with either an Espresso or Latte before starting my work day. Many ice cream flavors to choose from , high quality and tastes great! Best waffles I’ve ever had. Place is meticulously maintained ,which is crucial for me, I noticed how attentive the employee’s were to the tables, counter and floor. Spotless! Very warm and welcoming environment! Sal is the man!“

“very clean, easy flow for checkout“

“D’era House is such a hidden gem in Clifton, NJ. We came in for a custom cake and left completely impressed. The cake was fresh, creamy, and absolutely delicious.The space is cozy, clean, and welcoming, and their desserts and coffee are top tier. You can feel the passion behind everything they make.If you’re searching for a great bakery near me or need cakes for special occasions, this is the place to go. Highly recommended!“

“We really enjoyed the ice cream — the flavors were delicious and super fresh. The guy working there was very friendly and helped us choose the right flavors, which made the experience even better. There’s also plenty of space inside, with tables where you can sit and enjoy your treat. A cozy spot for a sweet break! 🍦✨“

“Great ice cream and a great eating experience“

“The Best burguer i tasted 😍“

“This store is sooo cute and the chocolate is amazing. I like chocolate with nocciolo and it is very good there. Easy to get gifts, and staff super friendly and helpful.“

“I was entering the amorino when the ceiling started to fall. I saw my life flash before my eyes, but before I reached the end of the tunnel, Jayla and Mia lifted the ceiling to save me. Without them, I could’ve died. Now everytime I return to Amorino I remember the heroic ice cream workers that saved my life“

“I first found this place through their stall at the Bergen Town Center, and I've been a customer ever since. They have so much sweets-wise from fruity drinks, sundays and so many fresh baked ube treats that are worth picking up. Personal favorite is their ube tres leches but anyone visiting should come back and work their way through their menu.“

“Yum yum yum got the hazelnut ice cream sundae. Was one of the best sundaes i have ever had. The restaurant was super clean and the staff were super friendly. Reasonably priced especially being in the heart of time square. I will be going back on this trip. Five stars all round even in this cold January weather.“

“Always a Sunday treat for me. A nice addition having the kiosks. Friend team and environment.“

“We had the pistachio and blueberry cheesecake flavors, which were really good. We also tried the dulce de leche one, but it barely had any flavor and wasn’t even close to the Argentinian version (where dulce de leche originally comes from), so I wouldn’t recommend ordering it.“