37 Best Pizza Restaurants in Toms River

“Really great pizza and nice staff/owner. We highly recommend! 🍕“

“Five stars all around well clean food is amazing staff is wonderful. And they’re catering they have is five stars all around very good. Anything they make is excellent. I love pondrellis pizza“

“We just tried Giddy’s Toms River last night and to quote my son the pizza was “NEXT LEVEL”. Couldn’t have said it better! These guys know what they are doing and don’t play games! Pizza was incredible! Just had to share so others can be in the know! Enjoy!“

“Verace is my go to frequently, their wraps are delicious, I recommend the buffalo chicken wrap with your choice of fries or onion rings, and a MUST try is their Grandma thin crust Sicilian square cooked to a perfect golden crust, topped with plum sauce, fresh mozzarella and torn basil. You will love this one! Owners and employees are great, you can't go wrong with anything off their menu. Give them a try!“

“Wow! What a nice surprise! Great food and hospitality that's rare today. Authentic delicious made-to-order food and exceptional service. As first-timers, we were treated to a taste of their outstanding penne vodka and a creme-filled zepole. Wowee! We'll be back for sure. BYOB ???“

“We had the pizza today it was excellent, great crust, very good sauce and lots of cheese. The warm and toasted bread was awesome!!!😋 We’ll be back again and will try the dinners. Highly recommend“

“Just stopped in for a cheese steak. 5 stars. see ya soon“

“Excellent food, huge portions and reasonably priced. I highly recommend Maria's. You will not be disappointed!“

“Highly recommended! This place is great!“

“We love Villaggio’s pizzeria. It’s our go to for subs, Italian hot dogs, fresh salads and pizza. Their four cheese pizza is amazing!! Have always used delivery and the service is top notch!!! Friendly drivers and super fast delivery of always Hot and Fresh delicious food. Our son loves it so much he and his friends go there for lunch on their bicycles often! Keep up the great job everyone!!!“

“Pretty sure we’ll never get pizza anywhere. So amazing to see a restaurant take “gluten free” seriously. Their gluten free pizza came on its own baking sheet to avoid cross contamination in the oven. They also didn’t cut it but instead delivered w w a plastic pizza cutter. Best part was the taste 💕. Kid approved. Thank you so much. Ordering again tonight !“

“We have ordered some del6food for dinner, chk marsala, chk parm hero/sub, balsamic chk salad. We lived in ny until recently & we have tried other pizzeria/ italian cooking here we never had a bad meal or service. I highly recommend Schianos.“

“If you are in the Toms River area this is a hidden gem. Real NYC style pie! Food is great and very authentic Italian feel especially the dinners. Pictures of Venice posted all over which is a nice touch. The dinning area has arches and beautiful photos of famous actors and famous Italian stars. In fact the owner is Italian and born in Italy. Apparently the owner Vinnie was the original owner of Cafe' Napoli in Shoprite Plaza in Manchester & La Gondola in Lakehurst making pies for over 20 years! In fusing years of experience "That's Amore'' is his best version of a Pizza Trattoria Italiana. Every time, you come in the owner Vinnie is so welcoming and such a nice guy! Always asking you how you are? Or how's the family? Did I mention Vennie is straight Italy? You can always here Italian spoken here. My Phil brother worked as a delivery driver a few years ago during college and said its like a family when working there. Your always welcomed back. All the staff is super nice never had a problem in the going there for more then a 2 and a half years now. Not an overly expensive place and not cheap food at all. Great to book for the holidays like Christmas, Easter, Thanksgiving, New Years, or a personal occasion you wont be disappointed. Even if they make a mistake, they are always pretty good & willing to make it correct for you. Usually giving you a free pie or order, if they mess it up. Great Quality pies! Give them try!“

“First time here in the never ending quest to find the best Italian food. Mia’s did not disappoint. Pictured is the baked ziti Siciliano. Eggplant really made this dish perfect.

Place looks like it was recently renovated as the booths and tables are all pretty new. Very clean dining area.

Will definitely go back and see if the pizza is as good…“

“I have recently been ordering from here, and let me tell you, high-quality food, has not disappoint... the shrimp scampi is 5 star restaurant quality, Bacon Cheese burger and Fries better than Dare I say burger 25.... fries fried to perfection.. Chicken Fran, omg that sauce could have drank it... Keep up the great meals... and less not forget delivery on point...“

“Capones definitely family friendly!! Top tier White Pizza anything on the menu is the best at the shore“

“food is great! when my food is delivered it arrives hot!!🔥Great people and delivery drivers are always polite. 5 stars for sure“

“I ordered a sandwich and wings yesterday and unfortunately by a pure accident my sandwich had the wrong peppers on it. I called just to let them know and with no hesitation they offered to make me a new sandwich. I wasn’t able to go back yesterday because of the time but they honored it today. I am so grateful and my sandwich is delicious. Friendly staff and great food. Definitely recommend!“

“Very friendly employees and very nice to talk to. The person who took my order, his name was José, was very nice and understanding. I had a meat lovers pizza and it was on point ong. I'm from North Jersey so it was a culture shock 👍“

“Food is always delicious and recipes are authentic. Portions are large (always end up taking some home). The Staff is always courteous and friendly. Would highly recommend“

“Horrible experience this is the second time that I have ordered using the Grubhub app and somebody in the store has canceled the app and I did not find out until I got there and they said sorry we cannot fulfill your order horrible way to run a business. Now I have to go back and forth with grub hub for my refund. Will never go back“

“Ordered food late. 1 entree could feed 4 people Very yummy“

“Papa john my favorite pizza 🍕“

“Absolutely the BEST penne vodka sauce in NJ. fantastic food, service and entertainment in Toms River!“

“Have had pizza here several times while visiting family. Always consist and very good. Varieties are great and the toppings on pies and slices are generous.“

“Only with new ownership, best pizza spot on this side of TR. Literally everything is amazing from this place.“

“I only got pizza here but now it's the only pizza place I want to go to. This pizza is pricey but it is super good. I find myself constantly wanting to go back. And I do go there but not as often as I would like lol. I wish it was a little cheaper but you get what you pay for. It is great pizza.“

“Johnny G’s just catered our sons birthday party and it was AMAZING. Definitely recommend to anyone. Mike was awesome and very helpful. 11 out of 10 for sure!!!“

“Chicken cheese steak Large was great. I ordered the Large chicken cheese steak sandwich w fried onions. The onions appeared to be boiled, but sandwich was EXCELLENT 👍. BUT WOULD be better with sauteed in olive oil and browned onions Anyway, . Great sandwich.“

“First time ordering tonight. Food is excellent. Definitely will order again!!!“

“Thanks to Charlie’s Pizza for providing Pizza to the 2025 Seaside Heights polar plunge! It was fantastic!“

“ALWAYS an enjoyable dinner! It’s one of our favorite places in Toms River. The food is DELICIOUS and the staff is always pleasant especially Christine… she’s been our server several times. I would recommend Tony’s Pasta House 💯“

“Always a fun atmosphere! I enjoy going and my husband and I are there 2 or three times a week! The employees are also very nice!“

“We recently visited Pizza Hut and realized they no longer offer waiter service. However, you can still order takeout and enjoy your meal inside the restaurant. Despite the change, the experience was quite pleasant.

Employee Chuck was incredibly helpful and kind, making sure we had everything we needed. The pizza was good, and the breadsticks were absolutely amazing.

Overall, even with the new setup, Pizza Hut continues to deliver a satisfying dining experience thanks to their great staff and delicious food.“

“Nice place , good pizza ✌🏻“

“The atmosphere Is Beautiful and the food was amazing I got the special which was ribs with mac & cheese and they were so tender, and the mac & cheese was delicious our waiter was friendly (young man with curly hair) and it felt very homey in there on a rainy day drinks were very good too“