4 Best Ice Cream Shops near Amagansett

“We had stopped in for a quick slice. The pizza was delicious and fresh. The staff was super friendly. I enjoyed the canned lemonade. Great pick if you want something that isn't too sweet.I especially loved the green signs all over the wall.“

“Incredible vegan pasta salad, and the best black bean burger, and the coffee was fabulous!“

“A solid option for serve yourself froyo. Lots of tasty flavors and they let you know which ones are free of gluten dairy etc. Cups are a generous size and there are a good amount of topping options. There's also a selection of other desserts like cakes and brownie bars and a large center table of decadent candies. Marking one star off because it's very cold inside (the air vents are in the floor and blow on your ankles if you're trying to sit at the bar) and while there are some benches outside and a counter inside the seating fills up quickly and doesn't offer a lot of options. The toppings could have also had a few more options, like mochi and some more fruits. A little expensive but not bad and definitely a fun experience.“

“A La Mode Shoppe offer ice cream in both dairy and non-dairy flavors. Try the Carmel or Sprinkle. Also partly cloudy was really good. Service is top notch. The spoons for the ice cream are color changing which is cool. The store is nice and very clean.“