Custom Cakes near Babylon, NY

Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
255 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
Mix and Go Create Your Own Creation
Cookie Dough Delirium - Ready Now
Cake Batter Confetti - Ready Now
Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake
Pineapple Blueberry Smoothie
Strawberry Banana Rendezvous
The Way the Cookie Crumbles
Don't Cry over Spilled Silk
Mango Pineapple Smoothie

“They keep a pretty large staff on hand. And they still get busy with a line to or past the door. Come at a smart time and your in and out. The ice cream is great and the workers put the effort in. All the cold stones are good but I keep coming to this one“

3.7 Good162 Reviews
Pure Sugar, Inc Patisserie/Cake Shop • $$
5 Broadway, Amityville - 4.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Unicorn Cake

“Amazing cakes, and it’s not just about looks, the cake tasted amazing!!! Will def use again and already have him booked for my sons birthday party. 10 STARS“

4.9 Superb68 Reviews
Baked by Emily Rose Bakery •
518 Broadway Ste B, Massapequa - 6.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gift Basket

“I highly recommend Baked by Emily Rose! They made a beautiful cake for my mom’s special birthday. Mom loved it. Very delicious!“

5 Superb35 Reviews
Vin’s Bake House Bakery • $
1030 Park Boulevard, Massapequa Park - 6.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black and White Cookie
Italian Cookies
Birthday Cake
Cookie House
Wedding Cake
Cupcake
Cakes

“Ashley and her team created the cakes for both my gender reveal and baby shower, and they exceeded all of my expectations! Not only were the cakes absolutely delicious, but the designs were so beautiful. Ashley was wonderful to work with, and the quality and attention to detail were exceptional. I'll definitely be using Vin's Bake House again for future events and highly recommend them to anyone looking for custom cakes!“

4.8 Superb70 Reviews
Old Fashioned Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1025 Straight Path, West Babylon - 5.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Soft Serve with Wet Walnuts
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Single Scoop
Holy Cannoli w Blueberry Soft Serve
Fudge & Biscotti Ice Cream Pie
Golden Oreo Ice Cream Pie
Ice Cream Filled Donut
Small Ice Cream Cones
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream
Gourmet Ice Cream

“This place is amazing been going here since I was a kid I'm 50 now wouldn't get ice cream any other place got to check this place out“

4.7 Superb132 Reviews
Dulce de Leche Cake Shop Custom Cakes • $
346 N Windsor Ave, Brightwaters - 6.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Empanadas

“Delicious and beautiful tres leches cake for an office birthday party“

4.7 Superb70 Reviews
Moscato Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $$
546 Stewart Avenue, Bethpage - 9.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Lobster Tails
Cheesecake
Cupcake
Cannoli

“Delicious sfogliatelle, cannolis, napoleons, and Italian bread 🥖“

4.6 Superb132 Reviews
Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
75 Howells Road, Bay Shore - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Fudge Chunk
Waffle Bowl Sundae
Mint Oreo Cookie
Monster Crunch
Whipped Cream
Banana Oreo
Toppings
Sundaes

“Best ice cream I ever had visited from NC!“

4.4 Superb124 Reviews
9

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
188 Howells Road, Bay Shore - 7.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Serve Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sundae
Birthday Cake

“Went to get some ice-cream after dinner. The staff greeted us as we walked in the door. They were quick and efficient. They double checked that certain ice-cream were okay to have with my food allergy. They have a freezer full of premade ice-creams and cakes or you can pick from different size cones or cups. They have different flavors of soft serve or hard ice-cream and many different toppings to choose from. They don't have any seating so we had to take it to go. I was so intent on eating my ice-cream I forgot to take pictures.“

4.3 Superb83 Reviews
Coyles Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
539 East Main Street, Islip - 9.18 miles

“Best ice cream I ever had visited from NC!“

4.3 Superb93 Reviews
The Chocolate Duck Custom Cakes • $$
310 Main St, Farmingdale - 8.02 miles

“Great Kids Party… Highly recommend for children,“

3.9 Good18 Reviews
The Ultimate Bakery (A&G) Bakery • $
1350 Deer Park Avenue Suite 26, North Babylon - 7.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Red Velvet Square
Chocolate Cake
Eclairs Pastry
Wedding Cake
Birthday Cake
New Cake
Cupcake

“My family and I have been frequenting A&G for about 20 years at this point because they have some of the most decadent and moist brownies you’ll ever come across! Over time, we’ve purchased and grew to love their cheesecakes, rainbow cookie cakes, apple turnovers, etc.

The “icing on the cake” for me (pun intended) was Diane’s customer service and personability! I needed a personalized cake made for a coworker’s birthday and Diane and her team were able to fashion together this cake that not only went beyond my wildest imagination but tasted great! Everyone there is so helpful, creative and efficient! Thank you so much Diane for making this moment as special as it was!!“

4.2 Good84 Reviews
Sweet Karma Desserts Custom Cakes • $
136 Manetto Hill Road, Plainview - 11.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Funfetti Cupcakes
GF Funfetti Cupcakes
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
GF Tiramisu
Bakery

“Brian designed our dream cake for our October Friday the 13th wedding. We went in with some ideas, bits and pieces from multiple photos and what was created blew our minds. Everyone was speechless when it came out. Aside from the delicious taste of the cake itself the details and time that was poured into it is one that we truly appreciate and love. We been to the shop multiple times before the wedding just to grab some goodies because everything is tasty and above the typical/traditional desserts you’d expect. Highly recommended bakery for sure.“

4.1 Good59 Reviews
Josie's Cakes Custom Cakes
1635 Great Neck Road Ste 2, Copiague - 3.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baby Shower Cake
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“I had the pleasure of working with Josie’s Cakes for my law school graduation party. From the first conversation I had with them, I knew I was in for something special. Having had my aunt use them for many birthday celebrations, I knew the cakes were amazing. They made sure I received exactly what I wanted. Not only was the cake perfectly crafted, it tasted INCREDIBLE. My guests were satisfied with it and have been inquiring. I thoroughly enjoyed working with them and will continue to do so in the future. Thank you so much for everything! May God continue to bless your business!“

3.7 Good102 Reviews

Babylon’s related cuisines