29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Baldwinsville

“This was my first time ordering here & I am amazed by how nice the young man was that delivered our dinner. I’m not big on pizza - (I did take a bite of the kids & actually liked it) I ordered an antipasto with onions for myself and it was bigger and better than expected. Joe called to let me know that he forgot the onions ( I didn’t even realize 😂 it was so so good) & refunded the $1. We found our new favorite pizza place & can not wait to try the wings!!!!“

“Delicious food, great family!!! had our business for decades!“

“My wife and I use to eat here a lot when we lived in Baldwinsville, NY. My wife has been eating cheese pizza with medium wing sauce on the side here since she was 14. Wings were perfectly cooked! Crispy but not too well done. The service is excellent. Everyone is friendly and helpful. I’ve never had a bad experience. It could use a deep cleaning in the dine in area. When ordering takeout in bville, Gino and joes will always be my first choice.“

“love their pizza. great staff and very kind, great customer service. the best fish. I have tried Atlantic, fish cove, and even the new place in big m mall no place beats twin trees fish for me“

“Crispy crust yet just the right thickness and soft in the middle. Really great pizza. First time we had it. The buffalo chicken wings were absolutely perfect too. Great service and they brought these great big delicious garlic rolls out at the beginning lol. We left stuffed and happy with leftovers for tomorrow. Thank you.“

“Bryce, the district manager made this experience phenomenal! Had placed an order online for this location through google maps and the online order went to Liverpools. Upon being informed at this location, Bryce overheard and stepped up to personally take care of the issue by canceling, reordering and fastracking my order for a quick, satisfying experience. Highly recommend Bryce and his team they all did an amazing job. 🤙🏼🏆👏🏼“

“🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 5-Star Experience! A massive thank you to Average Joe's Beernasium for making our surprise Bachelorette Party truly unforgettable! From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was electric. Food: Absolutely delicious and budget-friendly! Every bite was a delight. Drinks: Crafted to perfection—each one better than the last. Live Band: Phenomenal performance that had us dancing non-stop for three hours! It felt like we were reliving our college days. We genuinely didn't want the night to end. The combination of great food, fantastic music, and an incredible atmosphere made it a night to remember. We'll definitely be returning—for the vibes, the tunes, and especially the food. Already planning our next pizza night with takeout from here!“

“I had Pasta’s cater a luncheon for my son’s graduation from the police academy and the food was absolutely delicious…. The chicken parm was amazing. I will definitely order from them again! Thank you!“

“I just want to shout out my friends At Amore who never dissapoint we come every week every Friday. Their pizza wings so delicious Esp their chicken wing pizza I never go anywhere else 10/10 thank you guys you rock!!🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“Very Friendly people real clean place. And the owner is awesome.. The best food in Elbridge ny New York.“

“I can't say enough about how much we enjoy this restaurant.“

“Easily the best pizza in the Camillus/Fairmount area.“

“Missed having Johnny Mac’s when I moved from the area. Went back tonight after several years and it still holds its rank as my favorite pizza!“

“We had my husbands 36th birthday here on 11/8. We rented out a portion of the party room and got it catered. We had about 25-30 people show up. Food was excellent and fresh, and loved that we had a little window to order drinks at. Andrea was very apologetic that some people took one of our tables but we didn’t really care, we had more than enough. My dad has celiac and we were able to get him a GF personal pizza and some owings, he didn’t end up getting sick from cross contamination so we were thankful for that! It’s always a risk when we eat somewhere new. We will be back for regular dinners, we had never been before!“

“This place is a little hidden gem in Elbridge, NY. If you are a local, I am sure you have tried it and already know how awesome their food is! If you're traveling, make sure to venture over and check them out; you won't be disappointed. Fast, friendly service,, and they prepare some awesome food! The chicken parm is my "go to". Prices are very reasonable, portions are HUGE, all home- made ingredients. You can't go wrong! Delicious!!“

“Great Subs!!! Great Service, and well worth the price!!! 10/10 rating 100%!!! Thank you“

“Ordered a sheet pizza and 3 or 4 other pizzas for a party and the customer service was awesome! They were delivered on time and were hot and delicious! The veggie sheet pizza is so good. New favorite. Thanks guys! Just ordered dinner for our family tonight too and remembered i wanted to leave a review! Great food, super friendly employees and overall great experiences!“

“We absolutely love Toss and Fire Camillus…we love it so much that it is our Friday dinner weekly!! Although their pizzas are delicious, it is the staff that really keeps us coming back. Specifically, there is an employee named Echo who takes the time to know the regular customers and greets them by name when they enter the restaurant. This type of customer service is what makes them special! They are often busy because everyone knows how good their food is!! I highly recommend them to anyone!! You will not be disappointed by the food or the employees who greet you!!“

“This is my go to late night place. The owner is such a nice man and their food is always incredible. I always get chicken over rice with extra meet and white sauce and an order of Falafel and I can feed myself for 24 hours. I hope they never close this place. <3“

“I’ve been a loyal customer of Independent for several years, ordering for both parties and the occasional pizza night. I’ve tried many other places in the area, but nothing compares. The team consistently goes above and beyond, especially when I call to pre-order before opening hours, they always make it work. The pizza is, without a doubt, some of the best in the area. Prices are fair and reasonable, unlike many other places, and the staff and delivery drivers are always friendly and professional. I highly recommend them and will continue to be a regular customer.“

“We used Bianchi's Catering for our Holiday Party and we couldn't have asked for anything more. Everything was hot and delicious or cold and delicious. Our menu was varied and everyone was happy. We would recommend Bianchi's Catering to anyone who'll listen!“

“I sometimes have difficulty standing/walking so I frequently use the curbside pickup for my groceries. Staff are super fast, friendly, and knowledgeable.“

“Spent 3o.oo for pizza and wings.The pizza bottom was burnt to the point that it couldn't be eaten The wings were also so well done couldn't eat them.It was like some one forgot about them.Last chance for this place been burned too many times.“

“Friends...Fun.....Feasting...Za!!!“

“So I decided to order from champs pizza and fish fry on door dash and I'm so glad I did cause the garlic pizza was one of the most flavorful garlic pizza I've ever had and the charred sweet chili wings were the best wings were the best I've had in a long time I am hooked, I would ignore the negative reviews and give them a try I will order from them weekly if the food is delicious like that every time“

“Ordered a sheet pizza for a huge party I was throwing. I had called it in several hours early for a specific time pick up. they had 30 slices in the sheet and it was huge! It was the best sheet pizza I have gotten locally; crust was not too thick and it was cooked perfect. Plus, the pizza was ready right on time. I will be ordering from them again. Thanks!“

“The pizza is great but there’s this guy Mike there that I just go to stare at. He’s fine af.“

“This place is amazing, highly recommend, A+ for everything 🥰💕“

“Excellent food and service was top notch ,on a busy Saturday night. From start to finish 5 stars and our waiter Anthony was awesome!“