50 Best Italian Restaurants near Bayville

1 Piccolo Cantina Bay

4.5 Superb 88 Reviews

2 Bayville Avenue, Bayville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Feeling like home! I went for dinner at Piccolo Cantina Bay with a friend! We felt like home. The food is delicious and the margaritas 🍹 are simply the best! Generous portions, great and attentive service, fair prices! I'm definitely going back to create more memories at Piccolo Cantina Bay! ❤ Thank You So Much! See You All Soon!”

2 Ralph's Pizza

4.0 Good 195 Reviews

16 Bayville Avenue, Bayville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Absolutely excellent pizza!! Food is amazing as well!!”

3 Il Pastaficio

4.9 Superb 315 Reviews

213 East Putnam Avenue, Cos Cob · 9 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We visited the Greenwich location for the first time and we’re definitely going back!! Good was amazing! Service was excellent.. I would definitely recommend it!”

4 Anna

5.0 Superb 75 Reviews

141 Woodbury Rd, Woodbury · 7.62 miles

“pass it every night on my way home from work. and decided to meet a friend there sat night. my parents come from Italy and I spent all my summers there as a kid. it is the closes I have ever had to pizza in Italy, my only very small complain is. I wish maybe a few more choices for apps.”

5 La Spezia

4.8 Superb 208 Reviews

400 Glen Cove Avenue, Sea Cliff · 6.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“By far one of the best Italian restaurants I have been to! Excellent service- food made to order. Chicken Scarpiello was so flavorful with a lot of garlic, herbs and a touch of lemon. Penne Ala Vodka one of the best I have ever tasted! Chicken Verde was so tender it melted in your mouth!!”

6 Chris & Tony’s

4.7 Superb 378 Reviews

352 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset · 7.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had an incredible dinner. The service was impeccable and the food delicious.”

7 Angelo's Italian Restaurant

4.8 Superb 197 Reviews

9 Union Place, Huntington · 7.55 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“What a great restaurant! Angelo and Oscar run a tight ship. Can’t wait to revisit.”

8 Sergio's Saw Pit

4.5 Superb 264 Reviews

25 South Regent Street, Port Chester · 8.82 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“After living out of state for the past 5 years, we needed to find a local place to have a private family luncheon after funeral services for my father-in-law. We met with Sergio on Wednesday and he completely accommodated all of our wishes for that upcoming Saturday in his beautifully appointed private room. We couldn’t have asked for a better four-course meal and the staff provided service that was top notch and utmost respectful under the circumstances. We enjoyed a memorable celebration of life! Thank you Sergio & Staff for making a very difficult day, end with warm hearts and happy bellies 🖤 Until we visit again...”

9 Cafe Silvium

4.7 Superb 306 Reviews

371 Shippan Avenue, Stamford · 9.55 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This wonderful dinner was incredible!!!! absolutely 💯 delicious and way above other Italian restaurants in the area. They make food with love!!! Everything from beginning ✨️ to end was perfect 🥰 Thank you so very much for the hard work that you put into this! The food is fresh, hot and delicious! Loved the full glasses 🥂 of wine 🍷 too!!!”

10 Felice Port Chester

4.6 Superb 147 Reviews

55 Abendroth Ave, Port Chester · 8.24 miles

• Delivery

“Have been to Felice many times and never disappoints. Ambiance is really relax. The food, drinks and people are amazing. Fabio the manager is an excellent host and extremely friendly. Elvis was extremely knowledgeable about the food/drinks options. His choices of entrees were incredible.”

11 Joanina

4.7 Superb 274 Reviews

35a Gerard Street, Huntington · 7.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Attended a baby shower this afternoon...food was delicious... lovely venue...would love to return for dinner! Wonderful place for a private party, too!”

13 Angelina's Italian Restaurant

4.8 Superb 156 Reviews

1017 Oyster Bay Road, East Norwich · 4.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Might be the BEST Italian food I’ve had in a long time. Absolutely delicious! Service was excellent also. Highly recommend!”

14 Villa Milano

4.7 Superb 213 Reviews

168 Plandome Road, Manhasset · 10.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I ran into a small hiccup during my visit here and the staff handled it with so much kindness and understanding. They went out of their way to make sure I wasn’t left without what I needed. I cannot express how much I appreciated the gesture. It truly says a lot about the people running this establishment, and that alone gives me enough reason to continue to support and recommend Villa Milano and its staff!”

15 Butera's - Woodbury

4.4 Superb 407 Reviews

7903 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury · 7.86 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food and the service was awesome. Reasonably priced. Relaxing atmosphere. Highly recommend.”

16 DiMaggio's Trattoria

4.7 Superb 204 Reviews

706 Port Washington Boulevard, Port Washington · 8.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great Italian recipes, with wonderful Desserts. The Service is good, and the Restaurant is kept clean. Have eaten at DiMaggios numbers times. Never disappointed!! Recommended Highly.”

17 Alto

4.8 Superb 64 Reviews

1424 Old Northern Boulevard, Roslyn · 8.72 miles

“Amazing experience at Alto Enoteca! The food and was outstanding, and the ambiance is warm, stylish, and inviting, perfect for a date night. Service was attentive without being intrusive. We can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend 10/10!!!”

18 Ficarra Ristorante

4.9 Superb 87 Reviews

400 South Oyster Bay Road, Hicksville · 9.32 miles

“Ficarra really blew me away. The place is stylish, classy, and has such a great atmosphere. I’m a huge Italian food lover, but I rarely write restaurant reviews. I’ve been to plenty of Italian restaurants, including places with thousands of reviews, and usually leave feeling like something was missing. But here, everything was just right. The food was perfect, and the service was absolutely fantastic. It’s rare to find an Italian restaurant this good on Long Island. Highly recommend!”

19 Flora’s Wine Bar & Restaurant

4.7 Superb 75 Reviews

172 Main Street, Port Washington · 8.82 miles

• Delivery

“First time here. Sat at the bar. Sebastian was amazing. Drinks were amazing and the food was Exceptional. Klement the manager went out of his way to make our experience memorable. So nice to have this gem in town! Will definitely be coming back soon!”

20 Tre Sorelle Ristorante

4.8 Superb 103 Reviews

347 Glen Cove Avenue, Sea Cliff · 6.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Every menu item we purchased is delicious. The finest ingredients!”

21 George White Restaurant

4.6 Superb 319 Reviews

33 Berry Hill Road, Syosset · 6.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had a fantastic dinner here! Every dish we ordered came out fresh, well-seasoned, and full of flavor. The staff was welcoming, attentive, and kept everything running smoothly throughout the night. It made for a genuinely great overall experience—I’ll definitely be coming back.”

22 Villa Italia Restaurant

4.6 Superb 283 Reviews

26 Mill River Street, Stamford · 9.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love Villa Italia! The food is always delicious. Highly recommend the chicken milanese and sitting outdoors when the weather permits.”

23 La Famiglia Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.6 Superb 241 Reviews

5 School Street, Glen Cove · 4.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food!! Nice staff!! Nice place”

24 Constantino's Pasta Bowls

4.7 Superb 120 Reviews

160 Hamilton Avenue, Greenwich · 8.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’m absolutely obsessed with Constantino’s Pasta Bowls! I’ve been there a bunch of times and each one did not disappoint. Yesterday I had one of my favorites Chicken Scarp and it was amazing. Service was impeccable and owners were delightful and kind people. I felt like I was with family.”

25 Columbus Park Trattoria

4.6 Superb 217 Reviews

205 Main Street, Stamford · 9.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This restaurant is fabulous! Well worth stopping in. Every meal i have had there has been superb. Service is impeccable. I has a definite feel of a very hospitable local family restaurant like those we have enjoyed many times in Italy.”

26 Stresa Restaurant

4.6 Superb 197 Reviews

1524 Northern Boulevard, Manhasset · 10.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was delicious and the service was great!!! Will definitely return.”

27 Marianacci's

4.6 Superb 183 Reviews

24 Sherman Street, Port Chester · 8.53 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Classic Italian prepared fresh daily.”

28 Carlo’s pizza of Port Washington

4.6 Superb 179 Reviews

109 Main Street, Port Washington · 8.68 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza in Port Washington.”

29 Toscanini

4.8 Superb 64 Reviews

179 Main Street, Port Washington · 8.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The meal was delicious. my son and I had the Penne Diane and asked for the chicken to be blackened which was perfect. my daughter had the Pesto Sole and said it was the best and my husband had the Snapper which was perfection.”

30 Cafe Continental

4.6 Superb 162 Reviews

1538 Northern Boulevard, Manhasset · 10.49 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It is a small white-cloth old school italian restaurant located in what is essentially a strip mall. Atmosphere is cosy. It was half-full when I was there, and the noise levels were fine. Food is standard Italian fare that you would expect to find. They give you free bread with olive oil, along with parmesan cheese, olives, salami, and peppers. I had the veal parmigiana which was great. Crab-stuffed mushroom is a great appetizer as well, probably my favorite dish I had there. Waiters are excellent, friendly and professional, have all been working there for many years.”

31 Franina

4.6 Superb 142 Reviews

58 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset · 7.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We lucked upon this lovely place when staying in a nearby hotel due to a canceled flight. I highly recommend the burrata appetizer; our other dishes were great too but came from the specials menu so you may not be able to get them consistently. Soft shell crabs, veal osso buco... but I think anything you get there will be fresh and of the highest quality. Good wine list too. If we ever find ourselves in the neighborhood again we will make a point of returning to Franina.”

32 Matteo's of Roslyn

4.5 Superb 423 Reviews

88 Mineola Avenue, Roslyn Heights · 9.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food, great service! Will be back for sure!”

33 Volpe Restaurant

4.5 Superb 418 Reviews

7725 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury · 7.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Such a beautiful venue. Our dinner was excellent from service to food. I highly recommend.”

34 La Parma II Italian Restaurant

4.5 Superb 315 Reviews

452 West Jericho Turnpike, Huntington · 8.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We moved off Long Island over 8 years ago and always loved la Parma when we lived here even though it was an hour drive for us to enjoy the amazing food. This time when we came up to visit for Christmas we knew we had to get there for a great dinner. I can easily say it still is one of the best places to get amazing Italian food around. The Chicken Napoli was phenomenal and there is nothing like their penne à la vodka! The drinks were great and service was top notch. We also happened to go the day after Christmas when we got lots of snow and the car valet even brushed off our car! We were so happy to not feel rushed because we were there with great friends and just really enjoying ourselves! We can’t wait to come back and visit from Georgia to have their food again!”

35 Bar Rosina's

4.2 Good 85 Reviews

230 Mill Street, Greenwich · 8.1 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Service is friendly and attentive. Food is good, but expect to pay premium. Look ahead at the menu so you know what to expect. Parking lot accessible via William Street. Far walk for anyone with any impairment. There is a cut-through walkway from the lot to the restaurant but you still have to walk all the way to the front to gain access. Outdoor seating is lovely. Music is played at at level where it's easy to hold conversation and you don't have to talk above it. Always a good idea to phone ahead for a reservation. Overall I liked this restaurant and the ambiance, and I've been to similar restaurants, but felt this was a bit expensive for my taste. Personal Pizza was $19 and honestly nothing special in my opinion. The Chicken cutlet was delicious but didn't come with anything, no sauce/side, so that's all it was (just to give you some points of reference).”

36 Valbella

4.5 Superb 293 Reviews

1309 East Putnam Avenue, Riverside · 9.18 miles

“I was there as a wedding photographer and liked their service.”

37 Piccolo

4.5 Superb 279 Reviews

215 Wall Street, Huntington · 7.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“While we don't make it to Piccolo all that often it never fails to excel. Everyone is made to feel like a regular and the wait staff is exceptional. Food is always outstanding, timing is impeccable and one never feels rushed. Tight quarters, but it all runs like a well oiled machine. Varied menu, lots of specials- I recommend the soft shell crab francese.”

38 Gemelli Gourmet Market North

4.6 Superb 96 Reviews

716 Glen Cove Avenue, Glen Head · 6.54 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Gemelli challenge! Catering for 140 people on a 96 degree day and with the humidity feeling around 100 degrees. Perfect day for a big bbq........ well Gemelli’s made this hot day even “hotter” in a good way! Everyone left full and enjoyed everything from the salads to the perfectly cooked burgers, hotdogs, filet mignon , shrimp kabobs and amazing ribs with the secret Gemelli bbq sauce! Gemelli’s authentic pizza man Raffaele bared the heat and made pizza’s in our brick oven to everyone’s delight! A special shoutout to the staff who performed under these conditions with a smile and great attitude! Thank you Gemelli for exceeding our expectations and not only rising to the challenge but making our day extra special! Most of all Adriana and her family were super easy to work with and really care !!! I highly recommend them for your next party, you won’t be disappointed. Like us they will make you feel like part of the Gemelli family !”

39 La Bussola Restaurant

4.5 Superb 272 Reviews

40 School Street, Glen Cove · 4.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ho mangiato bene! Che bella musica direttament Di Modena Claudio Mattioli e Massimiliano Barbolimi. BRAVO 👏🏻 BRAVO 👏🏻”

40 La Bottega East Norwich

4.8 Superb 40 Reviews

6245 Northern Blvd, East Norwich · 4.85 miles

• Delivery

“Delicious paninis, wait times were a bit long for take out the few times I've been. The food is always fresh. Parking can be difficult but u can park along the road & walk over if the lot is full. U can also order ahead online for pick up. The tortellini is also really tasty & my sons favorite.”

41 T&J

4.5 Superb 248 Reviews

10 Pearl Street, Port Chester · 8.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Highly recommend this place! Food, not the best, but not the worst. Nice portions, clean, needs a bit of touch up, but it's a pizza joint food. Service, it was friendly and nice. Atmosphere, no complaints. Furniture all good condition. It's a nice family type of place that's comfortable, it's not gourmet but I'd return repeatedlyyself and friends and family. Compared to what's all out their and the price and food B.S., this place is a keeper. As long as they don't change for the worst.”

42 Pellicci's

4.5 Superb 242 Reviews

96 Stillwater Avenue, Stamford · 9.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food with wonderful service!”

43 388

4.5 Superb 214 Reviews

388 Willis Avenue, Roslyn Heights · 10.19 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Order # 6760 on 7/14/22 was cooked to perfection. Order was ready when i arrived. It was excellent t!!!”

44 Sotto Luna

4.5 Superb 206 Reviews

875 Willis Avenue, Albertson · 10.85 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have been here numerous times and have always had the best experience.All waiters and helpers pitch in to make the service fantastic and have recommended it to all my friends.”

45 Panini Café at Diane's

4.6 Superb 72 Reviews

23 Bryant Avenue, Roslyn · 8.6 miles

“I go to Diane’s all the time for coffee and baked goods, at least once a week. I invited new moms and dads from the Roslyn school today for a gathering at Diane’s this morning to support local business. We had about 12 people. Sat outside at the patio where the shaded area was. Everybody all bought coffee and pastries. We arranged the tables and chairs in a long row so we could see each other. Later we were told by Diane, the owner, that she wasn’t happy that we rearranged her tables and sat together in a row. Why? The place wasn’t crowded with other guests. We all bought and paid for goods. I couldn’t help but thinking that because we were all Asians?! She could ask us kindly to put the tables and chairs back once we finish, which we did without being asked at the end. But with the unwelcoming remarks I will never come to support this business again. I don’t say this lightly but I felt it was discrimination in every way. I’m truly disappointed. I love Diane’s and the yummy treats but the owner was truly unkind. I share this post here because I don’t think this business supports diversity, which is a shame because this community is becoming more and more diversified.”

46 Frankie & Louie's

4.5 Superb 136 Reviews

414 Willett Avenue, Port Chester · 8.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great little Italian place! Perfect to stop in for a slice of pizza or a more substantial sit-down meal. Great location for takeout, too. Staff are always polite and on the ball. One of the Port Chester neighborhood gems for sure”

47 Portofino

4.5 Superb 132 Reviews

395 New York Avenue, Huntington · 7.65 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had my daughter’s communion here with 20 people and it surpassed our expectations. All of the food was delicious, our waitress was terrific and everyone had a great time. The family style food was perfect and we had a wide selection to choose from. I would definitely recommend Porto Fino for a party.”

48 Al Dente Pizzeria

4.5 Superb 116 Reviews

7 Elm Place, Rye · 8.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“High quality food. Everything I’ve eaten is so good. Friendly staff and environment. I highly recommend anyone to stop by and grab a bite!”

49 Al Dente of Oyster Bay

4.8 Superb 23 Reviews

62 South Street, Oyster Bay · 3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had a party of 14 and everyone loved their meal! Food was delicious and service was fantastic. We will absolutely go back soon!”

50 Sal D's

4.5 Superb 65 Reviews

208 Wall Street, Halesite · 7.5 miles

• Take-Out

“Delicious food, fresh seafood, and quality ingredients! Fast, friendly service and a wonderful dinner together at a round table which was perfect for our family to enjoy the food and visit while all being able to see each other! Highly recommend Sal D's in Huntington NY!”