6 Best Seafood Restaurants near Bayville

Schultzy's Restaurant Seafood • $$$
265 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Fire Island Oysters and Little Neck Clams
Fresh North Shore Littleneck Clams Casino
Fresh North Shore Fire Roasted Oysters
Pan Seared Halibut with Spinach
Classic Cheeseburger & Fries
Homemade Lobster Bisque
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
Seared Tuna Special
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Calamari Arrabiata

“You won't find a better seafood restaurant on Long Island and you can include the Jersey Shore. Just go down the menu ..... All Fantastic!!! Don't forget to hear the Specials for the Evening. "Over the Top" Dining Experience. You're will LOVE IT !!“

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
Hidden Harbor Restaurant and Bar Seafood • $$
341 Bayville Ave, Bayville

“This place was AMAZING! I never came here before they renovated, but the interior is so beautiful and well thought out, so great job to them! The environment, the staff, the FOOD! Absolutely no notes.

We had a variety of amazing apps (not pictured). Started with the tuna tartar, meatballs (10/10 wish I had a second order of them), and the garlic bread sticks. Everything was cooked so well, while presentation was just as great.

Next the dinner. We had a steak, the pork shank, a salad, and a surf and turf (off menu) that was a full steak with clam stuffed shrimp. Steaks were perfectly medium rare and tender, the pork shank was so tender it was falling off the bone (in the best way), and even the simple salad was fresh and tasty.

Now the dessert. Everything is made by either the head chef, the soup chef, or the waitress. Each one is better than the next. Personal favorite: the dark chocolate cake. My girlfriend, who hates coconut, tried the coconut cream pie and said "wow. I might like coconut now". Her personal favorite is the bread pudding bites.

After dinner we sat at the bar and had a couple drinks while chatting with the bartender, who is so attentive and friendly! Lots of regulars and locals here, but it's part of what made the whole evening so lovely! We will DEFINITELY be back!“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Mill Creek Tavern American • $$
275 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana & Ricotta Cheese Ravioli
Skirt Steak with Mushroom Rigatoni
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Angus Cheeseburger Sliders
Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Jumbo Shrimp Française
Country Chicken Pot Pie
Kung Pao Cauliflower

“The food was delicious and many entrees to choose from we were a group of six“

4.6 Superb235 Reviews
Mill Creek Catering & Events Caterers • $$$
275 A Bayville Ave, Bayville

“This restaurant NEVER disappoints. Such a cozy, warm atmosphere. Wide selection of food and ALL of it delicious. Large portions with very fair prices. The staff is always warm and welcoming. One of my favorite “go to” spots with friends or family.“

4.7 Superb85 Reviews
Ralph's Pizza Pizza • $
16 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Linguine Alla Vongole Aka Linguine with Clam Sauce
Spaghetti Noodles with Linguini Claim Sauce
Ziti Pizza and Other Daily Pizza Specials
Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
Rustic and Sicilian Slices
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Clams on Half Shell
Pasta Dish and Wter
Chicken Bruschetta
Ziti Pizza Special

“Absolutely excellent pizza!! Food is amazing as well!!“

4.1 Good50 Reviews
Wall's Wharf Seafood • $$$
18 Greenwich Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Fried Calamari
Oysters on Half Shell
Mussels in Wine Sauce
Watermelon Beet Salad
Mussels Red or White
Mussels Fra Diavolo
Firecracker Shrimp
Seafood Mix Broil
Sesame Tuna Salad
Fried Shrimp blt

“Great place to get some beach time and have a great meal with an awesome view“

3.3 Good122 Reviews

You May Also Like