26 Best Bakeries near Brewster

“I’ve been going here since late last year, and I haven’t had anything they’ve made that I didn’t love. If I had to choose, the Paris-Brest pastries are ridiculously good and the carrot cake is the best one I’ve ever had, hands down.“

“Good service nice food friendly service“

“Brewster Pastry is an absolute gem! I always purchase their bread, cookies, and pastries, and they never disappoint. I’ve also used them for special occasions, including our grand opening party and my daughter’s college graduation, and the feedback was unanimous—everyone raved about how fresh and delicious everything was!

Even though they aren’t local to me, I gladly make the hour-long drive because their quality is simply unmatched. Every bite is worth it! On top of their incredible baked goods, the staff is absolutely wonderful—always friendly, welcoming, and accommodating.

If you’re looking for top-tier pastries and excellent service, Brewster Pastry is 100% worth the trip. Highly recommend!“

“This area is seriously lacking in vegan options, so this deli is our go-to. We often get bagels with vegan cream cheese for breakfast or the vegan sandwiches for lunch. They're not the best I've ever had, but they're certainly not bad! The portobello burger or the Philly Cheese steak are my defaults. They also have great juices -- and alt milks for lattes. (Don't order the matcha though, it just tastes like whatever milk base is used without even a hint of matcha flavor).“

“Food is delicious, service is a bit slow but it’s worth the wait I promise. Lots of yummy opinions and prices are good. They also have a buffet style service if you are in a hurry on you want something quick to go. Bread is yummy, they have conchas and a lot of sweet bread that you can get. Love that this is local and I can have a yummy cheap meal anytime.“

“Thank you Tim and Sydney! For the bests pies ! From students Boces Yorktown.“

“Taste, texture, and health in the finest breads I've ever eaten. The quality of ingredients is incredible. And the pastries! Astonishing flavor combinations that are beyond divine. Do not miss this extraordinary place. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“You’ve tried the rest Now try the best The absolute best bakery Putnam County has ever had !!!“

“They make wonderful cakes“

“Highly recommend! Marc and staff are fantastic, and everything is great.“

“amazing, friendly and super delicious !!!!“

“A friend gave me some of the delicious cookies, they were amazing. You could taste the quality ingredients, so fresh. My favorite cookie is the very large oatmeal cookie with chocolate chips🥰yum!!“

“the stuffed cookies are amazing“

“Had a birthday cake done for my daughter’s birthday and Luigi (baker) made it to Perfection. Red Velvet cake. Delicious and gorgeous looking cake. He also made me chocolate covered strawberries and never tasted such delicious chocolate before. Highly recommend and cannot wait to go back.“

“Love there bagels! Breakfast sandwiches and lunch grinders are the best!“

“My family loves The Cake Box! My son has a peanut allergy and it is so nice that they don't use any peanut products at all! He can have any cupcake his heart desires and I don't have to worry about his allergy. The cupcakes are soft, fluffy and delicious.“

“Absolutely delicious concha’s (?) I may be misspelling !!! Can’t wait to get Christmas cakes from here Friendly , like being home“

“Thank you for the most delicate yet rich Mille Feuille Dessert. It was very much enjoyed by my family! Thank you for the delicious macaroons and cookies as well! We will be ordering again soon!“

“Caffeine and a geekiness, a marriage made a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away. Super friendly staff, outstanding coffee, yummy baked goods and some awesome and rare sci fi treasures displayed around the cafe. The Eagle 1 from Space 1999 is museum worthy Sláinte!!!“

“Meant to post this earlier but a big thank you to Elizabeth for the most beautiful and delicious Sweet 16 cupcakes ever! They were a huge success and thank you for making Gigi’s birthday so memorable!!!!“

“We have two birthdays during the already busy holiday season. Amazing cakes from Nicole once again. My daughter knew exactly what she wanted for her sweet 16 cake and Nicole was able to deliver it exactly to her specifications. And my son was turning 21 so we wanted something special and fun. Spot on delivery! Both were absolutely delicious!!! Many asking for second slices“

“They no longer appear to be doing their food menu, which is a real bummer! I’m sure certain business decisions justify their choice. The food did differentiate them a bit, and while it is still a bit beyond “just another coffee shop” the loss of food still stings in a town with already limited quick bite casual options.“

“A great little gem in town!! The iced lattes and iced matcha are both incredible. They offer a nice little selection of gluten free goodies, the lemon scone is my favorite.“

“This is a very wonderful cafe + community space to have breakfast and lunch from! It is very charming and family owned. You can also work out of here from out of your laptop and the walls are decorated with beautiful art by local artists. ?‍? ☕️ ? ? ? ?️“

“There’s no where else I’d rather go for a great chicken cutlet sandwich while in town ! Great food, friendly people and fresh pastries 👍🏻“