50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brooklyn

“I recommend the restaurant“

“This is the best pizza I have ever had, nice crisp, light crust with just the right amount of toppings, no grease at all. I live in CT and thought no pizza was better than our New Haven ones, boy was I wrong!!! Looking forward to returning……soon!“

“Best Italian food & pizza in Brooklyn“

“Love this place: amazing food, nice atmosphere and friendly service!“

“seriously, one of the best, if not the best. I have tried in other states, and still exploring. This is definitely close to making the cut.“

“Had a pasta and pizza and they were both amazing. We are from Australia and found it hard to find a good restaurant in the Marina bay sands area and this did not disappoint. 5 stars“

“We dropped by Ace's Pizza around 3pm., Brooklyn, 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 5th Ave NYC and it was such a great experience! The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating—amazing service all around. We ordered the Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Caesar Salad, and a 14-inch Pepperoni Pizza. Every single item was delicious! The quality of the food was outstanding. The pepperoni pizza especially stood out—crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. We really enjoyed everything we ordered, and the overall vibe of the place made the experience even better. Highly recommended if you’re in the area and craving great pizza!“

“One word DIABLO !!!🙏❤️ Frost Beer was ice cold !!!“

“Delicious wood fired pizza with amazing toppings including vegan options. Wonderful, cozy environment and eclectic playlist. You won’t be disappointed!!“

“Yesterday there was a situation that should have put an end to our orders in this pizzeria! But!!!! The owner of this establishment called personally and we settled all the issues!! Thank you very much! It's insanely pleasant!!! I wish sincere prosperity and success to your business!

And yes, the pizza here is the most delicious in the whole neighborhood!!!!“

“The BEST Sicilian square sourdough pizza on the planet 🌎 their sauce is organic and phenomenal, the cheese is wonderful, olives and if you feel like it Add some sausage, and the yummiest pecorino Romano shreds just topped it off. The crispiest crust and So incredibly digestible, because it’s sourdough. Sourdough is fermented and your gut loves fermented food… Love their little gem lettuce salad with their homemade dressing. Very simple here I think we ordered 3 square pies and of course brought some home The Sicilian squares heats up beautifully Just love OPS on Himrod Bushwick Brooklyn!!!! We brought our son who lives in Louisville and this time brought our daughter and boyfriend who live in San Diego and their rock star Pal who is on a tour with THE WHO. All give the square pizza A+ Excellent! The staff is warm and friendly!!!“

“This spot is phenomenal Thor pizza is out of this world with outstanding selection of specialty slices

The staff is very outgoing and engaging

You would be hard pressed to find a better slice and atmosphere“

“It's a very cozy place. Good music, first class kindness and service. The food...well...wonderful, magical. Thanks a lot guys.😊“

“Stumbled into this spot in Williamsburg and honestly, it’s the best pizza I’ve had since moving to New York. Properly crisp base, great toppings, and you can’t beat the price for the quality you’re getting. The staff were genuinely friendly as well — not just polite, but actually welcoming. Definitely my new go-to pizza place!“

“Great pizza and atmosphere!“

“I recommend the restaurant“

“Pizza was perfectly cooked“

“The crust has this paper thin texture but the charred edges have this nice hint of sour that complements the rich luscious and tangy tomato sauce and the cheese ties it all together. Really really phenomenal pizza. The stuff of legends. I also got the fennel salad in opposition to my friend’s pleas to not “waste” money on a salad 😒. Was 100% the right move. Will be coming back very soon.“

“An awesome experience coming to this pizza shop.
Yigal the the owner greeted me cheerfully and was an excellent host
Everything was so fresh and flavorful and light!!
I got a spinach calzone and salmon avocado roll.

Both were fantastic 😍“

“I love this Slice Shop! So tasty! I love the regular, the sausage, the pepperoni, the Mootz, Jake's, Freddy Prinze, Hellboy.“

“Delicious authentic pizza!“

“I went into this expecting to give this review a 3/5. The pizza didn’t look super appetizing, but I was pleasantly surprised! The sauce is great. I was a little disappointed with the different slice options— I personally would have liked more variety, particularly a Sicilian slice with meat on it. The service was quick. I had the option to eat in but I chose to take my slices to-go“

“Great pizza. Didn’t like the white pizza but that is just my personal taste. The cheese slice and pepperoni slice were excellent. Loved the sausage. Spicy just like I like it.“

“The pizza is aaaaammmaaaazzziiinnnggg!“

“Been there couple of times and burger is mind-blowing. Pizza also ok.“

“Good pizza and a good atmosphere in a good spot“

“Mancini Wood Fired Pizza is a true gem in Bay Ridge! Their wood-fired pizza is unmatched. Owner Frank is incredible, always welcoming you with a smile and making sure everything is just right. Whether you're stopping in for a slice or planning a big event, this spot delivers every time. If you're searching for the best pizza in Bay Ridge, Mancini's is the place to be!“

“They have pretty amazing slices, open late til midnight. $5 for a quality slice, round pies, and also square pies. Can also get a cold Brooklyn beer to enjoy with the pizza. Small spot but perfect for the neighborhood without the high prices. If youre staying at the Sheraton Brooklyn or Aloft Brooklyn, or anywhere near Dumbo or Metrotech, you have to check out this place“

“Helped my mom out today and did military discount. #ThankYou“

“really excellent pizza and dessert“

“Update: changing this to 5 stars since it is more than deserved. Thank you Salsa for a memorable night ❤️

I had my 40th birthday at Salsa Greenpoint and it was the perfect place for a pizza party :). The layout of the space was great, with plenty to seat and our own bathroom to access. The team was very accommodating with accepting deliveries and giving us time to decorate for the night.

The food was delicious and the unlimited food option for group parties was perfect! Everyone enjoyed the appetizers and pizzas, as well as the cannoli :)

Thanks again to Salsa for helping us make it a special night for friends & family, and myself. We all had a great time!“

“Pizza was delicious! Service was good“

“I dined in with a group of friends for a friend’s birthday celebration tonight and received amazing service from our waiter, Nikita. He was very pleasant and accommodating. The next time I visit here, I would love to have him as my waiter again.

Thank you!“

“My family and I went here for some delicious pizza. The arancini were delicious! Really flavorful and a good portion to split amongst us. The drinks are also great, and they have an excellent selection of wine. Anything with the fior de latte cheese is actually amazing, so I definitely recommend any pizza with that.“

“This restaurant is a very clean friendly neighborhood place, where everyone feels welcome and the food is good and the prices are reasonable.“

“10/10 - absolutely recommend.

Classic pizza spot; always fresh. Pep, plain cheese, doesn't matter, I've yet to have a bad slice. Flavorful, perfect texture - chewy with that perfect initial crunch. Only thing I'd add to the menu? Pinwheels, maybe. Sometimes I have to walk on the other side of the street to avoid being tempted to grab a slice.

Staff is friendly, great to chat with, & we often run into them on our morning walks. Prices are great. Great spot to stop in, especially on a nice day when they pop the windows out.“

“The best pizza ever. My 13 year old begs to get it every time we are in Brooklyn and we oblige. Perfect crispy dough, amazing sauce and cheese.“

“A little gem. This small spot with a beautiful back patio squeezed in a group of 10 or so. The mushroom pizza was all we had but was 5/5 and worth a trip. Their dough is so light and pillowy but with crisp edges and a fantastic bite. The toppings on the mushroom pizza were perfectly seasoned and a very nice ratio (not overpowering the cheese or dough). Honestly though, the dough was special and is worth the trip to explore their other pizzas. Next time we come we will absolutely get a few pies and take home whatever is left. But if everything is as good as that mushroom pizza, there's small chance of leftovers.“

“Peppino's Bay Ridge has the most authentic red sauce in New York. Try the calamari in red sauce over spaghetti. Delicious!“

“I come here every Friday for the best pizza and pasta IN NEW YORK!!! This place is soo underrated I recommend anyone around the neighborhood or that live in ny to STOP BY AND TRY THEY FOOD!! They won’t disappoint. And the staff here ARE GOOD VIBES AND COOL PEOPLES I APPRECIATE THEY SERVICE AND IF ANYONE SAY ANYTHING BAD TO BE HONEST THEY HAVE TO A BE A “KAREN” !“

“The crust is edible. Slight crunch but mostly soft. The pizza is thin. I got the 2 pizza for $5 deal it came to $5.52 with tax. It was done extremely quick. They keep fresh hot pizzas coming out frequently. The area is heavily populated so they go quickly. Its the best deal on food all around. Their soda/water comes to $1.82 without tax. There is a good selection of the 2 freezers. I would go again. Nothing about the pizza was overly greasy, the bottom was not burned, there was a good cheese to sauce ratio, it was enjoyable.“

“Fresh pie all day everyday Love it 😍“

“Loved my meal here last week. They have real deal homemade Italian food from the burrata to the pizza and pastas.

Great spot for your next Italian date night or even a nice little event in their beautiful space I can see a nice work party or maybe a birthday party here, they have the best local prices for events with full bar and food options.

highly recommend getting those oysters and their Tre Pizzette appetizers, must try the penne a la vodka as well for sure“

“pretty much had the perfect experience. came in on a saturday night and even though it was extremely crowded, service was really quick, friendly and attentive (by both FoH staff). pizza was absolutely delicious and rivals the best pizzas in the city with the crust being the foundation and the sesame crisp being both original and transformative. the food was coming out quickly too so BoH was clearly firing on all cylinders.

front of house went above and beyond to make sure the experience was good not only for me but for all the customers. very impressive stuff.“

“Major shoutout to how great Smith Street Pizza is. The pizza is truly great and definitely a step above the regular by the slice places. Really love coming here. Got 10 pies for my daughters birthday party the other week and they also had those ready and perfect when we needed.“

“Absolutely delicious, homemade pizza with care taken at every step. Crust is unbelievable, cheese delicious. My.... what more can a man say?

You buy the pizza, you eat it. You feel good. Everybody happy. Buon appetito.

Vodka slice & Margherita slice are both fire.“

“I cannot give this restaurant enough stars! Carmine is AMAZING amd so is his food, staff, and atmosphere! I would choose this place over and over again to eat and celebrate whether im by myself orhaving a party of 25 people with me. Impeccable food, wine, pizza, pasta, service....all of it! Thank you for making our 10 year wedding anniversary party a night to never forget!!!!!“

“Fun indoor/outdoor dining environment and delicious food make for a nice night out!“

“eally enjoyed the pizza and it was just as good the next morning with the slices we took home!“

“Wonderful small neighborhood Italian restaurant. Great Neapolitan pizza, pasta, salads and other food at an amazing price point for 2025 ($18 for margherita). Cocktails $13, $11 during happy hour (M-Th 5 to 7 or 7:30). Beer well priced and also a dollar off at happy hour. Maybe 10 indoor tables but not crowded. Great service. A neighborhood gem.“