15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Canandaigua

“Great staff, fair pricing, and arguably the best pizza around! Love everything about their pizza! 🍕“

“June 2025 Update

The pizza and staff are very good and that continued.
No improvements to the interior were made; the same torn shredded carpeting is present with no upgrade.

Previous Visits 2025 and 2024
The pizza is very good and the staff are nice and friendly. The dining rooms would be much nicer if they replaced the old worn-out, torn, stained carpeting. This presents trip hazards for customers. This drags down your dining experience and makes the place look really bad. The mens room door needs a cleaning.“

“We had 8 of us show up and we were served outside with our two dogs while they were also hosting a huge indoor event! Food was delicious, drinks were right on and sitting outside with our dogs was lovely! I thought it would be a much longer wait for everything since they were so busy but it was not at all! They are also offering some kickball league, cornhole, and so much more! There’s live music every weekend and just an overall wonderful place to go.“

“Excellent meal at Il Posto tonight! We highly recommend the restaurant for your next cultural experience! Delicious!“

“My new husband and I came to the Finger Lakes on our honeymoon. We were in Canandaigua and were recommended Wally's by a local for a late-night dinner. What a fantastic experience! We had the wings and the Wally's plate, and we’ll be thinking of both for a long time!“

“Thank you so much for the outstanding job on the cold cut tray we ordered for a birthday celebration. Everything from the meats, cheeses, toppings, condiments and rolls were fresh and delicious. Everyone enjoyed it and was a hit with our guests. The service was also appreciated as the young man insisted on helping me load everything into the car. Really appreciate the job you do and having you close by. Thanks!“

“Love it at Coho. I don’t go all the time. More like a treat when I’m in there area. When Caleb is there he runs a tight ship. Talks with customers. All the bartenders are great too. It all ties in to help your experience be epic! ML&R to the crew up front and behind the scenes - 🤘🏼🤘🏼“

“Like a zoo fast service !“

“Great atmosphere, Great food,Great people...“

“The pizza, Parmesan bites was Absolutely delicious 😋“

“I stopped by at 1030 AM to inquire if they could help me with a special order. I am completing cancer treatments at The Sands Cancer center and wanted to treat the staff. I inquired if they could have 7 -1 topping large pizzas ready by 1130. They said it would not be and issue and gave me a nice discount. I returned 1 hour later and they loaded the pizzas into my car for me. The medical staff were very surprised and said the pizzas were excellent. Thank you so much for helping to make my cancer recovery so much more meaningful.“

“My Server was very kind, respectful, and polite!“

“My Server was very kind, respectful, and polite!“

“I love going to Salvatore's. It started years ago when our father would take us for sub night. After working at his shop when we were little. I go there now for their Calzones and subs the food is great and you can't beat their daily deals!! I can make those 2 meals last me most of the week for work or at home. I'll have to take some more pics to show everyone the food. Now I take my own son to grab food weekly. Nothing bad to say about the establishment. The staff is friendly and on the spot.“

“Crazy Tuesday Special $14.99 for a large with a topping is a pretty good deal! I can’t tell you the last time I was at the Canandaigua location because it was pretty awful the last time I was there. Iffy pizza and rude employees. Totally different story this time around. Not sure if they got a new manager or what but not only was the pizza pretty good and much better than before but the environment was totally different in a good way.
I did order “thin” crust and it wasn’t what I would consider thin but it was fine. Cup char pepperoni and as great. Good amount of cheese. Pretty solid and the price was right. Not a fan of the small slices though. I’ll request a 8 sliced pie next time and see if they do it.“