8 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cato

“The cauliflour pizza blew my freakin mind. It was the first time since being cursed with a gluten intolerance that I've actually had pizza that tasted like pizza. This place is awesome - the staff is always havin' a good time! No wonder it's the most popular spot in town.“

“Rinaldo’s in Elbridge, NY, is more than just a small casual pizzeria; it's a hidden gem offering both fantastic pizza and delicious Italian cuisine at unbeatable prices.During my visit, I indulged in the Upside Pizza lunch special, which included two monster slices and a drink for just $7! The pizza was outstanding, It was an incredible value, and the portions were extremely generous. After enjoying the pizza, we had the pleasure of speaking with the chef, who recommended trying several amazing dishes and I settled on ordering Nonna’s Eggplant and Chicken Parmesan for dinner. The food was so flavorful and plentiful that we couldn't help but rave about it. Rinaldo’s exceeded our expectations, proving to be more than just a pizzeria; it's a fantastic Italian eatery that I highly recommend to anyone looking for great food and amazing value.“

“Totally AWESOME place. Owners and wait staff were fantastic even though it was packed . Every one was friendly and helpful.The scallops were sweet as they should be,hubby's 2 pc fried fish was really great and plenty,he ended up taking it home and air fried it the next day, potatoes were real mashed potatoes. They also use real butter. We will be going back real soon. I already love that place.❤️?Parking: Handicap parking and ramp“

“Came to Port Byron for just a quick 24 hours and then back to Indiana . Super excited to have pizza in New York . The pizza was amazing and you were all so kinds . Would 100% recommend. Thank you for your patience and hospitality with tourist? ??“

“They are always fast and have your order exactly how you want it. We order from here at least once a week as a family .. even the picky little ones like it so we decided that's what we order for family night ... They even know you by name .it makes for a personal experience. I wish I had a photo to share .they have way more than just pizza ... Great food Pleasant people and local“

“This is your friendly, neighborhood quality pizza shop. Good food, great people -- nothing fancy, and supports local schools and teams.Wheelchair accessibility: No obstacles between the parking lot on the side of the building and the front door. Large open space upon entering and no restricting cordoned areas. In winter, the parking lot was plowed, and the sidewalk was cleared of snow.“

“As a truck driver I drive the Thruway a lot and with coffee shops not being open late this is one of my go-to stops. Mainly because they actually have cookies there that they bake .in house. If you're looking for a coffee and a treat fix definitely want to make a stop here. It is inside the pit stop gas station. And they also have food that is made to order. I will say I do wish they had some pizza out late at night but otherwise good service good coffee and good cookies“

“I’m so glad we have this pizza shop in Jordan! If I could give 10/10 stars I would. I have never had a bad experience here, the staff is super friendly and food always shows up sooner than anticipated. Some of the absolute best pizza and subs I have ever had! I don’t understand the 1 star reviews, are you dealing with the same place that I am or do you just like to complain??“