5 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cayuta

“Prices are good. Ice cream selection isn't the biggest but enough to find something you'll like. There was only two people working at the time we where there. It was pretty busy and a good size line. However it did move at a good pace. Lots of seating. I got the Caribbean Sunday. Pretty good.“

“I love it when places go through the effort of making their own brownies, it sets them apart and this place's brownies are really good. Combined with the great ice cream and toppings, I'd say this place is the best in an area where there's lots of competition!“

“Every time we come to NY to visit, we always make a stop at Big Top. Best ice cream around. My size in the pic is a kiddie (great sized portions) for only 1.95, reasonable prices overall, friendly staff. Love the soft serve flavor options here, can’t find them in Virginia.“

“I never seem to get there before the good flavors are gone. I love the RootBeer and I got there this time just in time to see the last order sold. But they have good customer service and the custard is always tasty. Hopefully soon I will be able to get the flavors we like.Parking: Approximately 15 or so spots to park. Sometimes it takes a few minutes to find a spot but slways worth the wait“

“The food and drinks here are delicious! The setup inside is a little weird and can be confusing on which way to go when they're busy. The staff has always been very friendly and helpful. They do have seating inside at a counter, but it can get very cramped. They also have outdoor seating at picnic tables. If busy, parking can be hard to find.Parking: Can be hard to find a spot when it's busy.“