16 Best American Restaurants near Cazenovia

“My daughter and I stayed overnight for her 13th birthday. We, but she most importantly had an amazing time. The food, the accommodations, and the ghost tour was so wonderful. Everyone was friendly, we felt at home and properly spooked. Thank you to Terry for your stories and extra attention for Fiona's birthday. Thank you to our server Jonny for taking good care of us as well. We will definitely be back, the 4+hour drive was well worth it.“

“This is in my top Three favorite restaurants! The workers are always friendly, the atmosphere is cozy and the food is amazing! I would recommend the Chicken Riggies or Cowboy Mac & Cheese. The popovers that the bring out are amazing as well. I would 100% recommend eating here!“

“Very fun bowling alley, with a small arcade inside as well.“

“So delicious. I love the riggies and the turkey cranberry panini. I’d order DoorDash from them all the time if they’d make it so there wasn’t a delivery fee for DashPass members. I’m sure a lot more people would too! But it doubles the price of the order so I can’t justify it. So for now I’ll just enjoy the great food when I can stop by in person!“

“Friendly staff. Great food. It’s worth the price. Highly recommended for anyone.“

“We had the best burger in a long time. You can't go wrong.“

“We love going here! Stopping by the Drift-In throughout the summer is a highlight for our family during the warmer months. They have the best ice cream in the area in my opinion. Make sure and stop by when you’re craving some ice cream in the summer time!“

“This is my second time coming to Craftsman and I can’t wait for number three. Last time I was with my father who doesn’t drink but we came in on a whim and sat at the bar for dinner. We had burgers, they were good, and I was very happy with the draft beer selection. Now I’m back, staying at the Craftsman Inn next door again but with a new group. Myself, my wife, my 2 year old, and 2 month old came in for dinner on a Saturday night. We were seated a few minutes earlier than our reservation and immediately greeted by our server. We fired a kids pizza for my big guy and it was out within 5 minutes and it was absolutely delicious. Everyone was so nice and helpful, they gave my big guy crayons which was a huge hit. The wife had the salmon, I ordered the steak flight, we shared a hot honey and pepperoni pizza while waiting for our main course. We’re from Long Island, we eat a lot of pizza, this thing was top notch. Main courses came, we were both extremely happy with our choices. The steak flight comes with 2 sides and I chose Brussel sprouts and the fingerling potatoes. The sprouts were unreal, the potatoes were good but I’d probably select something else next time. No complaints, just a preference. Drinks were and always are top notch, very happy!!!! Just wish it wasn’t 5 hours from home.“

“Wonderful Bar & Restaurant right on the Lake. Great views from the bar, dining room and deck.
Food is excellent and service always pleasant and friendly.
(Shout out to Vanessa, my favorite New York Bartender for providing great service and maintaining a really enjoyable atmosphere). An outstanding professionally run estabishment
offering quality dining in a beautiful relaxing environment.
A GEM!“

“Great food, friendly service, soothing atmosphere. Will definitely return.“

“Full full full full full full“

“We had an issue recently with the take out service at Tullys in Fairmount which was a rare occurrence. The food is always consistent and service prompt. I felt it was important to share my experience with management as I knew it was not typical of this location. I was called by Allen the manager who had been a friendly face for years. He was very apologetic of the situation and appreciative of my feedback, he wanted to make it right and advised me to ask for him when we decided to dine in again. We went on a typical busy Friday night. We’ were greeted and almost immediately sat. Before our meals touched the table he came over to advise me that one of our meals was on him as a courtesy. Allen is an important part of the Tullys family and the Fairmount location. He is always friendly and cares that his customers leave satisfied. The food was nothing less than delicious, tenders and fries came out cooked perfectly and within 10 minutes of ordering. Great Job Allen and Fairmount Tullys team!“

“good food and the people that work their are very friendly. lots of antique items and handmade crafts to decorate for fall and Halloween 🎃“

“Looking for a neighborhood spot that boost delicious food and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere? Look no further than The Coal Yard. I recently had another excellent experience there, reinforcing why I keep coming back.

The food is, without a doubt, a major draw. Their menu is packed with dishes that are consistently delicious, and I’m always eager to try something new. On this particular visit, the food was, as usual, outstanding. It was so good, it single-handedly made any minor inconvenience fade into the background.

Now, I will admit that the food took a little longer than usual to arrive. It was clearly a busy night, but what impressed me most was the way The Coal Yard handled the situation. The staff were attentive and understanding, regularly checking in to keep me updated. More impressively, the owners themselves came over to sincerely apologize for the wait. That level of personal attention and genuine care is a rarity these days.

This experience isn’t a one-off. I’ve been a frequent visitor to The Coal Yard, and the food typically arrives promptly. However, it's the consistent commitment to customer satisfaction that truly sets them apart. The owners are visible, engaged, and genuinely interested in ensuring everyone is having a great time. They'll actively ask patrons if anything is amiss and, if so, go above and beyond to rectify the situation.

This proactive approach creates a welcoming and trustworthy environment. It's clear that The Coal Yard isn't just about serving food; it's about building a community, fostering a sense of belonging, and making sure everyone feels valued.

While the wait might have been a little longer on this particular occasion, the exceptional food, the sincere apologies, and the genuine care demonstrated by the owners more than made up for it. It reinforced my belief that The Coal Yard is a truly special place.

So, if you're looking for a place with delicious food and owners who genuinely care about your experience, give The Coal Yard a try. You won't be disappointed. Just be prepared to become a regular!“

“The Mrs. and I stopped in today (8/8/24) for the first time and had some lunch. The special was delicious (Belly Stuffer Philly cheese steak), and only $9.50 with fries and free refills on the soda fountain! I upgraded to a beer with mine, which only costs me $10.50! The owner, Josh, was very nice, as was the bar maid. The bathrooms were spotless, too. We sat at an outside table and really enjoyed our first visit. I read some old reviews that were negative, but I can say that was not our experience. We'll definitely be back again for more. Also, I can't believe how reasonable the prices were, considering the ludicrous inflation, and I'm sure setting up shop in Fayetteville isn't a cheap venture. So... great service, great food, great prices, friendly folks; a nice little nook off the beaten path. They get an A+++ from me!!“

“Stopped for slices on they way through. Very good!!! Prices are second to none.“