22 Best American Restaurants in Depew

“Ordered the fish fry. Great size, great price. Ready when they said they would be. Will definitely order again.“

“The baked cod and salad was delicious! I'm so happy I decided to try this restaurant. Definitely on my repeat visit list!“

“I hosted a baby shower at Magruders yesterday and everything was phenomenal! We had beef rollups, and baked chicken, which was beyond delicious!! Along with homemade mashed potatoes, corn, pasta, salad and rolls. Shannon was perfect from helping plan the event to making sure everyone was happy the day of party. If you’re looking for a place to host your next event 10/10 recommend here!! Everyone waved about the event“

“great beef on weck and buffalo wings highly recommend if going to a sporting event or show“

“Great hospitality and great people!!!“

“The 2 men working the drive thru window today (4/27/24 at 11:50am) were extremely kind. There were ducks next to the window that my daughter in the car was waving to, the gentleman working noticed and he came to the window with safe snacks to feed the ducks that my daughter would be able to give them. Now for a 7 year old… that brightened her whole day! They were fast, food was excellent, and the customer service was a 10/10! This location is the best!!“

“We sat at the bar for lunch …. And Sarah was great ! Very attentive , quick service with conversation and good pointers about what to visit while in Buffalo .“

“The best dogs in Buffalo! Order 2 up and fries with sauce! Always satisfies!“

“Great place, live music, friendly fun staff, owners rock, the food is awesome, burgers, homemade fingers, BBQ bacon wrapped pizza logs and more... its such a great place to check out a band w friends. outdoor patio also“

“8/20/25 the food is awesome and offers a great price. The bacon cheese burger I ordered was huge and was delicious. It came with a pickle & a side of fries. Our waitress Kim is the nicest waitress you could ask for. Her experience and friendliness is truly an asset to Tully’s. She accommodated our large group with perfection. Thank you.

2022-The food and service were very good. We had a large group and the waitress accommodated us. She even did separate checks.“

“Fantastic pizza logs and beef on weck!“

“mostly quiet relaxing atmosphere“

“My daughter and I stumbled on this place by accident. We were driving around, looking for a place to eat. Today was our second time dining there. The waitresses are professional yet friendly. The food is amazing and it seems to be a nice, family friendly place for a meal, a snack or dessert.“

“Helpful staff, outdoor & indoor safe seating, lots of food & ice cream choices.“

“4/5 isn't really fair, I think they get like a 92% for 2024.
Awesome spot to order breakfast on a lazy Sunday. We've ordered here quite a few times since around 2019 or so. During covid, the business was ran into the ground due to strict gov't regulations and I respect the owner for fighting back against this. Campfire's pricing has gone up over the years quite a bit since this whole ordeal and due to that, we don't order as often anymore. We almost always order take out because sometimes one of us will get sick or we're trying to take care of house stuff.
The food quality was consistently insanely great like 10/10 status up until this year and now I'd say sometimes it feels a bit more rushed than what we've had over the years but it's still great.
I am a sucker for biscuits and gravy and highly recommend giving it a shot if that's your jam. They have incredibly good home fries that have amazing flavor. Their home fries are extremely addictive. Their sausage patties are my preference compared to links and have a bit of a spicy punch to them which I enjoy and they always cook eggs exactly how you order which I respect. Most of the time if you order bacon, you get medium which is how I like it. My girlfriend enjoys their french toast (I think that's what she usually gets) and country fried steak. She said they gave her a massive portion of steak last time and was pleasantly surprised.
We've ordered take out plenty of times and I'd say there's about a 5% shot that our order's missing something from our experience. Not a huge deal, but because their take out is bagged up and tied, they don't really check to make sure everything is there at the register. They've never given us a problem when something was missing and you just let them know before taking off from the parking lot if that's the case. I've rushed home twice before checking and learned to check in the parking lot or sunroom before leaving. That said, they're always pleasant when picking up and don't make you feel bad for not seating in which I appreciate. Sorry we get busy!
We've eaten inside here quite a few times as well and I really enjoy the staff and atmosphere. The theme is family oriented and old school which is really a great throwback that I appreciate bringing me massive amounts of nostalgia as someone who was born in the 1980s. The seating is nothing fancy but everything about this place is comforting and traditional feeling. We've never had one single bad experience with staff here and think every worker we've ever interacted with has had a positive and welcoming attitude which is a needle in a haystack and worth the few price hikes we've endured since covid.

Parking: Always the right amount of spaces open in the lot. We've never had a problem getting a space despite the dining area being very busy every time we've gone.

Kid-friendliness: Great atmosphere and friendly and respectable staff, every time“

“OK. So haven't been to Applebee's in like 20 years. Had a gift card so me and the gf went. Honestly really surprised. The steak was delicious. The sides were also really good. We sat at the bar and the bartender was awesome. Played some quick draw. Great atmosphere in there. The drinks were also very good. Nice selection. Guess I've been sleeping on Applebee's. Will definitely be back“

“food was good the waitress could have been a little more friendlier but she was busy“

“Ordered online for pick up. Very easy to use their app to order, full menu is available to take out.
Ordered pancakes and fruit cup. Estimated time was 30 min to pick up. I arrived at 27 minutes and food was ready and steaming hot. I didn't even have to reheat when I got home.“

“By far the best pizza in my area! They build a pie the way I remember most pizzarias did it back in the day. No frozen crust, no canned sauce, and definitely no fake cheese. Their pizza is baked well done creating a the perfect crust and the pepperoni cupped and charred just they way it should be.
Consistency is the norm at Santora's, I have never received a sub par order. The prices are a bit high but you get what you pay for and you won't be disappointed.“

“Friendly and great service.There was only one waitress working. Late lunch hour vary attentive to everyone, under the circumstances. Wait time for food was a little slow but the food was great tasting and would go back again because of the friendliness of the staff(bar tender)coming in and leaving.“

“They need better napkins. There napkins are tiny and are like using one sheet of 1 ply TP. They just disintegrate all over your mouth and hands. And they have some messy @$$ pizza and wings too. But it's all delicious and would def order again and recommend!“

“Surprisingly spectacular little place. My family got split up, half going to Niagara and stopped at the border so about 5 of us stopped here while we waited. We had some sandwiches, pizza and pasta. Its a simple place, so don't expect much more than a tasty meal, on a paper plate, but we came away happy and full.“