9 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fishers Island

“Love the Flavors and the Novelty of This Gem! So Sad You're Closing for the Season in October! Don't know bout anyone else but I Eat Ice Cream All Year Long!“

“Friendly staff and of course, delicious ice cream! I had Cowabunga Crunch!“

“good treat for the family“

“The staff was amazing and the ice cream was mind blowing. Of all the local, handmade ice cream shops I've visited, this one is by far the best! Chocolate was amazing and the selection was extensive! A must if you're ever in downtown Mystic!!“

“This is the best frozen custard in the area!If you've never tried frozencustard, it's creamier, thicker, and better than soft-serve in every way! Mix it with some Italian ice, and you're in heaven.The staff was friendly and let us try some samples of different flavors.I Love this place, and will drive out of my way just to visit.“

“Best Ice Cream. Chocolate was delicious. Husband had Rum Raisin, loved it“

“Went on a Sunday for a cup of s'mores ice cream. Very very tasty and there were a ton of options that sounded good. Great place to take kids or a family. Convenient location next to the dock

Vegetarian options: Ice cream is all vegetarian. Some meat with the pretzels but very safe for veggies

Parking: Parking in Mystic is tough. Street parking exists but you have to get there early to get a good spot.

Kid-friendliness: Tons of different options to satisfy any kid's craving“

“I recently took my family to Twisters Ice Cream, and it was a delightful experience from start to finish! The variety of flavors is impressive, with something to satisfy every taste bud. My kids were thrilled with the colorful, fun options and couldn't stop talking about the unique toppings they got to choose from. The ice cream itself is creamy, rich, and bursting with flavor—easily some of the best we've had.

The atmosphere at Twisters is welcoming and family-friendly, with plenty of seating to oversee the Mystic River that made our visit even more enjoyable. The staff was incredibly friendly and patient, especially as our little ones took their time deciding what to order. We also appreciated the clean, well-kept environment, which made us feel comfortable and at ease.

Overall, Twisters Ice Cream is a must-visit spot for families. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cone or something more adventurous, you'll find it here. We left with smiles on our faces and are already looking forward to our next visit! Highly recommended for a fun family outing.“

“Absolutely delicious ice cream! Love this new shop in the heart of Stonington borough. The same owners from Noah’s Restaurant opened this great new business next door. Service is excellent and the menu items are creative and fun!“