7 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fishers Island

“Love the Flavors and the Novelty of This Gem! So Sad You're Closing for the Season in October! Don't know bout anyone else but I Eat Ice Cream All Year Long!“

“good treat for the family“

“The staff was amazing and the ice cream was mind blowing. Of all the local, handmade ice cream shops I've visited, this one is by far the best! Chocolate was amazing and the selection was extensive! A must if you're ever in downtown Mystic!!“

“I love the ice cream, it’s so good and delicious. The price is not too much high, and the staff are very cool. I ordered chocolate ice cream and it was delicious. The shop is clean and looks traditional and organized. It’s a nice experience.“

“What a great place!!! I had sautéed portobello mushroom spinach and cheese sandwich which was delicious. They also had something I’ve never seen fluffernutter ice cream which was amazingly delicious. The place was adorable with the soda counter brought back lots of good memories. I love the sign that said no WiFi talk to someone :)“

“I love the dairy-free options they have! I know the special edition flavors rotate, but if they have the vegan lemon flavor, it's a must try. The staff is super friendly, and the location is easy to access with plenty of parking right out front (which is not easy to have in Mystic!). Definitely recommend.“

“Great little chain ice cream shop that makes custom ice cream concoctions while you watch. Great choices. I really like the mud pie mojo. I usually get a "love it" size in a waffle bowl. To be fair, my atmosphere stars are based on my being spoiled and living very close to the shore and enjoying lots of great views. This place isn't in the ghetto or anything. It's just in a big strip Mall complex. I go here fairly regularly and we always enjoy it.“