14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fishers Island

Topper’s Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
643 Equestrian Ave, Fishers Island

“Love the Flavors and the Novelty of This Gem! So Sad You're Closing for the Season in October! Don't know bout anyone else but I Eat Ice Cream All Year Long!“

4.2 Good19 Reviews
Michael's Dairy Ice Cream Shop • $
629 Montauk Ave, New London - 6.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Almond Bar
Raspberry Swirl
Black Raspberry
Cherry Vanilla
Birthday Cake
Banana Split
Strawberry

“Friendly staff and of course, delicious ice cream! I had Cowabunga Crunch!“

4.7 Superb86 Reviews
Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
2 W Main St, Mystic - 7.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Blueberry Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Lemon Chocolate Kiss
Apple Pie Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Swirl
Family Fundae Pack
Black Raspberry
Mint Chocolate
Waffle Cone
Strawberry

“Best Ice Cream. Chocolate was delicious. Husband had Rum Raisin, loved it“

4.5 Superb300 Reviews
Mystic Sweets and ice cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
7 W Main St, Mystic - 7.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Ice Cream
Maple Walnut
Mud Pie
Marzapan
Fudge

“The staff was amazing and the ice cream was mind blowing. Of all the local, handmade ice cream shops I've visited, this one is by far the best! Chocolate was amazing and the selection was extensive! A must if you're ever in downtown Mystic!!“

4.6 Superb47 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
361 Colman St, New London - 8.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Custard - Coffee Flavor
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Frozen Custard Sundae
Pistachio Custard
Coffee Custard

“So glad there's a Rita's within 15min from home...been 4 years since I've been to a Rita's and that was in Wind Gap, PA.
Had a KiwiMelon Gelati, then my kids had a cotton candy Gelati and a Blue Raspberry Italian Ice. Rita's doesn't disappoint!“

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
Mystic Park Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
10 Cottrell St #2604, Mystic - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sea Salt Caramel Truffle
Black Raspberry Chip
Chocolate Lovers
Ice Cream Flavors
Toasted Coconut
Pretzels

“Love Mystic Park ice cream !“

4.5 Superb42 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
42 Fort Hill Rd, Groton - 6.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turtle Pecan Cluster with Chocolate Ice Cream
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Blizzard Treat
DQ Signature All Occasion Cake
Banana Split
Strawberry
Hot Fudge

“good treat for the family“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
Twisters Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
135 Greenmanville Ave, Mystic - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Banana Split Hard Ice Cream
Ice Cream Shop
Small Sundae

“Always friendly clerks and the ice-cream is indeed high quality!! Plus they have the classic flavors that I treasure since my childhood! It's a win win.( butter pecan, maple walnut).....highly recommended if you like hard ice-cream and classic flavors!“

4.3 Superb73 Reviews
Boro Bodega and Scoopery Ice Cream Shop • $
109 Water St, Stonington - 8.53 miles

“Passing through and checked out their ice cream and gelato! Enjoyed that, and appreciated the suggestion to go to Watch Hill. Thanks!“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
Waffle Pop Sweet Shop Dessert • $
110 W Broad St, Pawcatuck - 9.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

NY Strawberry Cheesecake Gelato
Belgian Dark Chocolate Gelato

“Great for dessert or breakfast waffles!“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Carson's Store Breakfast • $$
43 Main St, Groton - 5.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Big Breakfast Sandwich Egg Cheese Ham Sausage & Bacon on a Roll
Ham and Cheese Omelette with Home Fries
Build Your Own Omelette
Sausage Eggs Benedict
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Smothered Homefries
Corned Beef Hash
Turkey Sandwich
Irish Omelet
French Toast

“What a great place!!! I had sautéed portobello mushroom spinach and cheese sandwich which was delicious. They also had something I’ve never seen fluffernutter ice cream which was amazingly delicious. The place was adorable with the soda counter brought back lots of good memories. I love the sign that said no WiFi talk to someone :)“

4.5 Superb75 Reviews
Seven Birds Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
27 Coogan Blvd #7B, Mystic - 9.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Ice Cream
Sea Salted Caramel
Rainbow Sprinkles
Black Raspberry
Chocolate Chip
Cotton Candy
Mango Sorbet
Soda Float
Oreo

“We had a fair experience here. Quick, efficient service for some good ice cream. The hot fudge came out HOT, which was enjoyable. Not much of a line when we visited today, but I'd return to try more flavors. We liked the Milky Way & Lavender flavors.“

3.8 Good58 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
909 Hartford Turnpike Suite D7B, Waterford - 10.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Somewhere over the Rain-Dough - Freezer
Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake
Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Cookies & Creamery
Red Velvet Luxury
Birthday Cake

“Great little chain ice cream shop that makes custom ice cream concoctions while you watch. Great choices. I really like the mud pie mojo. I usually get a "love it" size in a waffle bowl. To be fair, my atmosphere stars are based on my being spoiled and living very close to the shore and enjoying lots of great views. This place isn't in the ghetto or anything. It's just in a big strip Mall complex. I go here fairly regularly and we always enjoy it.“

3.6 Good101 Reviews
Sea Swirl Seafood • $
30 Williams Ave #2915, Mystic - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Popcorn Shrimp Basket with Fries
Potatoe Fries and Cold Slaw
Two Grilled Fish Tacos
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Whole Belly Clams
Foot Long Hot Dog
Fish and Chips
Clam Fritters
Ice Cream Cone
Fried Shrimp

“05.25.25- Written Review: 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' EP.108 Ft. Apathy Sea Swirl 👍🏾 Mystic, CT Sea Swirl is an Amazingly Dope spot located in Mystic, CT! There is only outdoor seating so this spot recently reopened on April 25th for the Season. This afternoon my Brother AP, his children & I dropped into Sea Swirl to find out if they are serving up Good Lobster Rolls and I also had to try out one of their new "Lobster Cones". I ordered and reviewed: 1. Lobster Bisque Cone $13.99 💣 2. Hot Lobster Roll $28.99 👍🏾 I started with the Lobster Bisque Cone and enjoyed every delicious spoonful! The Lobster Cone is similar to a bread bowl with Lobster Bisque but the cone tastes like a croissant. So good! I gave it a Thumbs up but in hindsight it really deserved a bomb 💣 because it was Top Notch! Next I dove into the Lobster roll. First off, the price of the Lobster Roll is lower than most spots and it was absolutely delicious! I loved it and it earned a Thumbs👍🏾 I will drop into Sea Swirl for Lobster Rolls and Lobster Cones all summer long because that spot is Dope! I highly recommend this spot to my friends and family so hurry up and get your a** down there and check them out! Make sure to tell em', 'Big Al Mayo sent you' ☝🏾💣 'See you on the Rebound Peace out' ☝🏾❤️ -Big Al Mayo“

3.9 Good125 Reviews

You May Also Like