Custom Cakes near Garden City, NY

“I always have came to this cold stone, I never felt sparked to write an review until yesterday. It was a nice Friday busy night as expected for an ice cream place so granted the line was long. There were three people working in the front and they were all so pleasant, the girl who helped served me looked new because she asked questions to the others. They jumped up to help her, it was nice to see an environment where kids look happy to work. The young lady who was new served me. She was very nice kept a smile on her face, and added things no problem upon request. This place has upped their customer service. Love it.“

“First time at Leonetti. Loved the place, the layout and open space of the sitting area, the way they have their cakes placed inside the fridge, not overcrowded and are able to appreciate the beauty of the cakes. Everything looked amazing and very clean. I really recommend Leonetti to anyone in the area or just passing by!“

“I had a great experience at Bread in Oven! I bought a cake from here last week, and it was absolutely delicious. The cake was fresh, soft, and had just the right amount of sweetness. The presentation was beautiful, and everyone loved it. The staff were also friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend Bread in Oven and will be coming back again!“

“Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!“

“We had the best experience ever with this bakery - the cake was included in our venue pricing through this bakery, and I can definitely see why! Working with Alison to schedule and have our tasting, which was just down right fun...(because of COVID we had to take our samples home... and she loaded us up with some extras to share with friends) to showing her our vision for the cake on the day of, and then actually SEEING and EATING it at our wedding was perfect all the way through. They really incorporated everything we asked for, and it was simply delicious!!! We even asked for an extra birthday cupcake for our nephew to have on the day of the wedding, and they made it sooo cute! (wish I could figure out how to add a picture here... It was SO pretty!!!)“

“Excellent baked goods. Delicious pastry and the CANOLI“

“She did it again! This is my second time working with Nita for a milestone birthday, and she exceeded expectations once again. She is so professional and such a pleasure to work with. Her pastries are not only beautiful but absolutely delicious—this time I ordered cakes, tarts, and cake pops. She copied my inspiration cake to perfection! I will definitely be recommending her again and again.“

“They make an addictive challah, I nicknamed it the crack-cocaine challah. You need a twelve step program after having that or their incredible pastries once. Five stars is not enough for this bakery, at least 100 stars.“

“Thank you so much for the beautiful cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower! Everyone was Ravi g about them. Not only were they gorgeous but they were delicious ! I gave your name to a few of guests“

“The Bellmore Carvel is very special. The amount of love and care put into my son's birthday cake exceeded my expectations. Amanda is so talented and you can tell she is passionate about designing cakes. She even called me personally to ask if she could alter the cake a bit from the image I provided. It came out a million times better than the image! Thank you, I will only be ordering from you guys in the future!“

“I ordered a specialty cake for my mother and it was FABULOUS! The cake was unique, 2 - tier choc and vanilla with a hazelnut cream filling. It was covered in a lovely lavender frosting with lace flowers and unique lettering. It was fresh and special!“

“You made me this cake for my birthday and it is absolutely delicious..chocolate cake with cookie dough filling..OMG so good you will be making more 4 me lol..this cake had to weigh 10lbs no joke...absolutely amazing I love it thank you so much for putting in such detail.“

“The best everything is fresh , delicious , and there’s lots to choose from . Just amazing“

“They are Best. Everything they make is delicious. The staff is great. Every time I go in for one thing I come out with half the store!!! They still have the famous pac-man cookies !! Cheesecake is off the cart. I would recommend them very highly!!“

“love this place makes what ever you want“

“Rainbow cookies Cannolis Napoleon Cheesecake A MUST !! The bread… best in the world“

“The best Carvel in the area ! What makes it the best is that they definitely have the friendliest staff. And they keep the place super clean. I take my daughter there at least once a week after her gymnastics class and on more than one occasion have been shown appreciation for our loyalty.“

“It’s incredibly difficult to find a bakery that can make a delicious gluten-free free cake, but Sisters has not only nailed the recipe they have also set a very high standard! Those of us who have to be GF constantly lower our expectations. That’s just how it is! My birthday cake was the most delicious cake I’ve ever had and it was gorgeous! Thank you so much for the attention to detail and for being such amazing bakers! ???“

“This is my go to bakery for all of my events, whether it’s Eid, birthdays, casual gatherings. Their desserts are so unique and taste amazing. I usually order their mini shooters and their pistachio tres leches, and/or lotus biscoff 3 milk cakes for my events. For the first time, I asked them to make a custom made cake, and provided them with a photo of it. I was so shocked by how it looked the same as my AI-generated example! The cake looked and tasted AMAZING! This will always be my go to bakery! By the way I’ve order from and been to all of their locations and all of them are very friendly and the atmospheres are great. Also, they are Muslim owned and only use halal ingredients!“

“Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat or to order another specialty cake.“

“Everything is delicious and fresh! Cookies, pies, cakes, pound cakes, cheesecakes, and the pastries. Holidays are extra special. I only go here whenever I bring something when visiting and everyone loves it. I buy extra for myself too cant resist. Hands down the best bakery I travel from a few towns away.“

“Some of the kindest, most understanding people work here.

It's a Coldstone Creamery, you know what you're getting into.

But the staff is exceptional, we'd been here more than a few times and always had great ice-cream. My keys stopped working and me and my fiancé were locked out of our car late at night in sub 20 below weather. The manager attempted to help us open the car, gave us shelter, and was so kind and supportive. They moved a bench inside for us, checked in and offered so much. They took care of us in more ways than not after an already long and hard day.

Outside of being a good place to get ice cream, I think any locals should support these people as much as possible.“

“I come here at least once a week and everytime I try a new flavor from the assortment of flavors in their store. The workers there are very ecstatic and always ask about my day. Great ice cream with different toppings. Everyone who gave a bad review is mid and obviously wrote their bad review on the wrong store. Keep up the great work!“

“Ordered a pull apart cupcake cake for my daughter's 1st bday. All the guests enjoyed. Tasted fresh and delicious. Thank you !!!“

“Uhhhh, it’s carvel, of course it’s amazing in every way!!! Love it there, yummy and the staff is great. The owner is such a nice person... we love him.“

“I Recommend EVERYTHING! I have been ordering cakes and pastries from buttercooky over 10 years. I am a cook kinda girl and they are to die for lol . Just go“

“John at Polito’s Bakery in Williston Park made my daughter’s wedding cake, and it was absolutely beautiful and delicious! The cake was moist, the frosting was amazing, and the fresh strawberry filling was the perfect touch. Everyone loved it and couldn’t stop talking about how wonderful it tasted. John did an incredible job and helped make the celebration even more special. We highly recommend Polito’s Bakery!“

“Their ice cream cakes are great“

“Cory at this Location has Outstanding Customer Service he understood my concerns and catered to my respectful request without any hassle . I recommend this Cold stone for Cleanliness, Customer service , Respect and Outstanding service
Thanks again Cory“

“I come here some Wednesdays for the BOGO soft serve. The same two guys are always here and they are always very polite and helpful. Some days there are crowds of kids or families waiting to be served and they still provide good service. I love Carvel in general and this is a good location, very reliable. Parking can be iffy if there isn't anything open on the street but you may just need to find something residential or a block or so away and walk.“

“I had an amazing experience thanks to Malaika at Cold Stone! She was incredibly friendly, patient, and welcoming . She took the time to make sure my order was exactly how I wanted it and did everything with a positive attitud. It’s rare to come across someone who genuinely cares about providing great customer service, and Malaika definitely does. She made my experience enjoyable, and I truly appreciate her kindness and professionalism. Cold Stone is lucky to have her on the team!“

“This is my go to spot. The staff here is really friendly, service is really fast. I usually hang out here for a bit. I just really wish that there was a TV to watch sports. I love the area and the vibe here, it’s just missing some entertainment. Hopefully this place could get a TV soon.“