50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Garden City

“Everything was great- food, service, prices, atmosphere, drinks- could not have been better! We love coming to Seasons 52 every year- food is always delicious, waiters are great and overall atmosphere is very welcoming. Looking forward to return already:) Thank you Seasons 52!“

“Everything was excellent but getting placed next to the kitchen ruins the entire experience. Loud plates silverwear boxes smashing people talking it ruins the fine dining experience almost completely but everything else is great that it balances out. But from now on I'm not sitting near the kitchen that was too much“

“"An Exquisite Experience at PrimeHouse, Garden City" Recently, I had the pleasure of dining at PrimeHouse in Garden City, and it was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere captivated me with its beautiful decor - a perfect blend of elegance and comfort. The real stars of the evening, however, were our host and hostesses, Jaime and Nick. Their attentive service, warm smiles, and expert knowledge of the menu made our experience truly memorable. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort, making us feel like VIPs throughout the night. Now, let’s talk about the food - it was divine! Every dish was a culinary masterpiece, bursting with flavors that tantalized my taste buds. The chefs at PrimeHouse clearly know their craft and take great pride in their creations. Another noteworthy aspect was the parking facility. It was conveniently located and spacious, making the start and end of our dining experience hassle-free. In conclusion, PrimeHouse in Garden City is a must-visit. Whether it’s for a special occasion or just a casual night out, it promises an exceptional dining experience with fabulous food, top-notch service, and a delightful ambiance. Hats off to Jaime and Nick for making our evening so special!“

“Excellent cuisine and friendly ambiance!“

“Whether you are here to enjoy an intimate dinner for two, or an after work get together with friends, this place will not disappoint. Great selection of melt in your mouth perfectly cooked steaks, add to that delicious appetizers, and do yourself a favor and Donny walk out that door without enjoying one of the many delicious desserts, Come hungry, leave satisfied.“

“Nice service as well as great food!“

“This is a great place! Food is fantastic, really all we had was flavorful and had heat but not so much that it was over powering. People are so friendly. Drinks are made with real fruit. Prices are very reasonable. Best for take out bc only one table. Definitely try this place, a true gem.“

“The portions for the appetizers were so igwe couldn’t even order entrees. The food is well seasoned and delicious. The service was attentive. The ambiance is PARTY. You just keep moving as you done. I definitely will be back…“

“My Husband & I Love This Spot So Much. We Come As Often As We Can Which Is A Lot. The Staff Are Very Friendly And Never Had A Bad Experience. I Will Continue To Come, Sit, Eat & Drink.“

“Enormous portions, the bread and salad are excellent starts to a delicious meal. paella valenciana and lamb chops are amazing. Even my super picky, never impressed 75 year old father was in love with this restaurant.“

“Joe and his staff go above and beyond to give you an excellent dining experience, the food is amazing the drinks are on point, and the deserts are excellent. I would highly recommend this place to anyone.Every time we are in NY we make it a point to stop here.“

“Trying this spot for the first time definitely would say I will be coming back! The place was very clean. The service was very fast and the environment was very welcoming. To the inventor of the octopus tacos we said we would leave a review and hands down a very delicious creation! The portions of our orders were very generous and well worth the price! 10/10“

“Great customer service n food was delish“

“Great food Great service“

“The Davenport Press in Mineola NY has been around for many years, and I just had the opportunity to go there for the very first time. I absolutely loved it. The ambiance is wonderful.. it's like a trip back in time. White tablecloths, the most exceptional staff and service and last but certainly not least the food was amazing. I had the lobster tails and my husband had the prime rib, both were delicious. I hope the Davenport stays with us for a long time to come.. I give it a ten out of ten and then some.“

“It was fabulous at the Outdoor Bar! Our waitress Veronica was fabulous! So sweet and accommodating! Everyone was wonderful! Food was great! A great night out!!“

“taco tuesday specials, delicious lobster soup“

“My brother moved by this spot like a month ago and I know this place OH SO WELL. ? I’m in Freeport and I haven’t found empanadas as good as Mamma Gina’s. When I tell you the food just hits every time, they’re honestly so consistently great.

Parking: It’s a small lot, so just take it slow turning into it.“

“UN EXCELENTE SERVICIO 👏🏻👏🏻 MUY EFICIENTES!!!“

“Anyways, I loved this place. I went with Yeerunner, the person who also reviewed this place. The staff are amazing, and the food is just delicious. You have got to come here, they just opened and need more customers. For the price, you get so much delicious meat and I want to go back again and enjoy the food. Attached, view some photos of my friend enjoying the food. It was AMAZING.“

“Very friendly staff and great service food was amazing and very nice cocktails“

“My new fav spot! I will be going again this week for my birthday 🎂“

“been going here my whole life. the best there is!“

“Great food and services.I really enjoyed this place“

“I enjoyed having there Cheeseburger.“

“Fresh food, great service“

“Great ambiance, food was good and service was excellently. Hosts were personable. Will definitely recommend.“

“The portions for the appetizers were so igwe couldn’t even order entrees. The food is well seasoned and delicious. The service was attentive. The ambiance is PARTY. You just keep moving as you done. I definitely will be back…“

“Place was not busy for a Sunday night. We sat outside. We ordered fried calamari, oysters and a new england clam chowder for apps. Main courses: chilean sea bass, broiled seafood combo, lobster roll & crab pot. Everything was delicious. Suggestion: ask to have the scampi sauce on side.“

“Everything was wonderful.
Great little hidden gem with delicious food!
We had fish tacos, several sushi rolls and eggplant— everything was perfect and fresh.
And the owner and GM are absolutely lovely people.
We’ll be back - thank you“

“I came here for fresh seafood and ended up purchasing several prepared food items, since those are easy and looked well made. I tried both seafood and vegetable dishes. All were fresh and tasted delicious. I care about fresh seafood. Prices are not cheap, but with seafood, quality really matters. There also appears to be a sushi restaurant onsite, which I'll have to try next time I'm in town. Roslyn is fortunate to have several local gourmet markets and this counts.“

“Was driving back from New Jersey a couple weeks ago and there had been some accidents and a ton of traffic so we decided to take a unplanned detour and stopped in Great Neck. Happily we found a Great Mediterranean Seafood Restaurant/Bar AND saved on drive time! 😜 The server greeted us with a basket of Warm Grilled Pita & Humus, on the house. Pictured we have the Grilled Anchovy & Chilled Roasted Beet Salad with Scallion & Raddish, Tuna Tar Tar with Guacamole, Seaweed Salad & Raddish Apps The Fish 🐟🐡🐙🦀🦞🦐🦑🐚 was Super Fresh & Plentiful and Plenty to choose from! I even saw the Host presenting a table 2 Whole Fish to inspect, compare and choose from 👌👌👏👏 FRESH! An Incredibly lite white airy Chilean #Seabass and Broccoli with garlic, olive oil, sundried tomatoes and chickpeas, was, for me, perhaps the star of the whole show. Grilled Olive Oil #GROUPER with Roman Green Beans 👌 Lastly a Kid's Steak Tidbits order with Fried & Broccoli.. Pearl was Impressed! Skirt Steak.. whole basket was only like $12 $7 #margaritas 👍👍#fullbar #liny #longislandfoodie #freshfish #mangiawithmaggi #Greekfood #mediterraneandiet #lowsalt #nosalt #healthyfood #goodeats #tellthemmaggisentyou“

“Got my lobster roll before they close for the season. No problem about The hot sun the afternoon was extremely blustery. I’ve always loved this place even though it is pricey for a clam shack.“

“OMG!!! Everyone needs to dive into the flavor of Cookerz Blend, one of Queens hidden gem on 217-84 Hempstead Ave. From the moment you walk in, you're not just a guest, you are family!!! The warm welcome from both staff and fellow diners sets the stage for an unforgettable experience. I was like, "why is everyone clapping?" Prepare your taste buds for a rollercoaster ride of deliciousness! One visit was all it took for me to fall head over heels for their mouth watering menu. Whether you're craving oxtails, irresistible jerk chicken, or hmmmmm... theeeee honey-glazed salmon that's seasoned to perfection, Cookerz Blend delivers every time! Ha, there's more, you should taste their rasta pasta, it's so divine... heavenly! Oh yes, the fried chicken wings that practically melt off the bone with each bite. oh, oh, oh, and let's not forget about the pepper steak and the curried goat - juicy, tender, and bursting with flavor. Even if you fancy yourself a kitchen whiz like myself, Cookers Blend culinary magic will keep you coming back for more. They kept pulling me back in, like what the hell is their secret ingredient? With each visit, I'm not just dining out, I'm embarking on a flavor filled journey that's keeping me hooked. Don't take my word for it, experience it for yourself, trust, you'll thank me later. Prepare to become a lifetime devotee. Thanks to ALL the staff, you got a lifetime customer!“

“This was my 1st time visiting Red Crab! The Food is Absolutely DELICIOUS! The Atmosphere is Sophisticated, Warm and Cozy! The Service is OUTSTANDING! When you visit Red Crab, please ask to sit in Jennifer’s section…She is an Amazing Hostess! Jennifer…Your kindness, energy and positive spirit made us ALL feel valued & appreciated! Honestly, I feel like Jennifer should get a huge raise! She provided us with excellent customer service, she laughed with us, she danced with us and she made my 2 friend’s Birthday Soooooo Special! YESSSSSSS, I will be returning! 5 Stars! Wonderful Experience! YUMMYYYYY FOOD! Thank You, Red Crab, for making my two friend’s Birthday Unforgettable!!! WOWWW…So Much FUNNNNNNN!!! Red Crab owes me nothing…LOL🤣🎉🥳💕🥰👍🏽😃 (One small suggestion…the music can be turned down slightly. It was a little difficult to talk across the table…)“

“I visited Kuttanadan Indian Restaurant last Friday all the way from New Jersey, and it was absolutely worth the drive! It was Fisherman’s Night at dinner, and the experience was nothing short of amazing.

The food tasted just like home — especially the kalamari fry, which was crispy, flavorful, and perfectly spiced. The fish peera was another standout — fresh, authentic, and cooked with just the right amount of tang and spice that brought back coastal Kerala memories.

The ambiance, the hospitality, and the traditional flavors made it a truly special evening. I could feel the love and effort in every dish. Thank you, Kuttanadan, for bringing a slice of Kerala to our plates!

Highly recommended for anyone who wants to enjoy real Kerala seafood and warm hospitality. Will definitely be coming back! 🙌🐟🍛“

“Food was good, very attentive and accommodating servers. Even though I am not particularly into sea food, i did enjoy the meal as did the party I was with. I would go back. If u like seafood, you may even rate them higher than I did?

Parking: Small free parking lot and street metered parking.

Kid-friendliness: Good. young kids ate and played at our table/ booth like set up“

“Great dining experience. Superb cuisine!!“

“Highly Recommended, Highly Satisfied, A Great Hospitality, Perfect Family Restaurant, and overall it’s the best homemade home fried rice and Cajun fries and Seafood are top notch best quality food services where the Owner (chef himself), his Newphew are such a friendly company. I enjoy the business and when whenever I’m around my old neighborhood in Town of Freeport (PORTKNOX NATIVE) I come here to enjoy with my family and my small parrot 🦜 - happy folks and nice environment staff..“

“We had an incredible dinner. The service was impeccable and the food delicious.“

“😄a great value ,good food, cool place friendly staff, we have been going here along time always great time“

“Lobsters roll are the best ever I had it“

“Sehr gute Küche, freundliche Bedienung und angenehme Atmosphäre“

“Nice huge portions , delicious food, great service ! We will be back.“

“great steaks & service. live music select nights“

“Bonefish Grill had a nice atmosphere and good food, but the service was slow to start. We waited a bit too long for someone to take our order, which was disappointing. However, our waitress was friendly and made up for the delay. Overall, we had a good time, and the food was enjoyable.
4/5 stars.“

“Thank you Prime on the Mile for a wonderful evening last night! My husband & I hosted a Christmas dinner party of 17 & everyone was more than satisfied! From the private dining hall, to our menu options (Crab stuffed Salmon, Surf & Turf Prime Burger & Mango Shrimp Skewers), to our wonderful server Danielle, we had a great time. Thank you manager Lee for your attention to our party. Big, big shout out to owner, Bryant Postell for making the plans seamless & easy for us. See you again in a few weeks for EBS & Associates Christmas party!“

“We were a party of 11 people and the service wasn’t good. The waiters were not friendly. They gave us a very small basket of bread for a table of 11 people, and their tables are huge. I asked for another one and they took forever to bring it. I guess they don’t care because their tip is already included in the check. And I usually tip 20 to 25%, but not this time. It’s a nice place, the food is okay, but won’t be visiting again because of the service. You don’t feel welcome as soon as you come in.“

“all you can eattttttt...“