Bagels Restaurants near Hicksville, NY

“In my numerous trips to Bagel Boss, I have found the counter people to be kind, nice & helpful. The bagels are huge & fresh. Some bagels seem to lack flavor but more then make up for it in size freshness. I find some customers to be a problem with their ridiculous expectations!“

“Great breakfast and amazing service“

“The absolute best on Long Island. Worth the trip to Oceanside. They never disappoint. Everything /Egg. Are my favorites.“

“Delicious bagels, clean store and great, quick service always. Thank you to Dennis for always supporting our school-we appreciate the generous donations and pricing for all events. We look forward to our green mini bagels for St. Patrick’s Day. We all recommend you any opportunity we get.“

“Literally the best in Rvc.. love everything about this new owner and what they have done with the store, food and customer service..the best. Kevin...keep up the great jib“

“In Nov of 2022, I had the most AMAZING gluten-free bagels I’ve ever tasted! At first, I was afraid they had given me regular bagels! They’re THAT good! I live in Kentucky and have been DREAMING of those bagels ever since I ate the last one!“

“I’ve been frequenting this place for a couple of years and always satisfied.. this weekend the people who make this deli awesome went above and beyond…
If you meed hero platter with all the sides this is your place. A special thanks to Heidi who saved my party.“

“We just used Broadway Gourmet to cater a party for us. Sydney did such an unbelievable set up at our home for a small gathering. Her attention to detail and hard work was so unbelievably impressive. The spread looked beautiful and the food was awesome. Highly recommend! Thank you, Sydney!!“

“I am in town for the weekend and stopped in for coffee and breakfast at about 11 am on a Saturday. I was originally going to pick up food to head back over to the airbnb but ended up staying while I ate a chicken empanada, an Everything Flagel (flat bagel) with lox cream cheese, and a cup of coffee. As I ate, a lot of people came and went and seemed to know the place really well. It appears to be a family business and the customer service is friendly and efficient. The parking is plentiful and convenient, and the place is clean with a great assortment of fresh bagels. The coffee is fresh and average tasting. I was amazed at how many people ordered ordered bagels with the inside fluff scooped out, which I have been doing forever. This is why I was so happy to discover the Flagel which I asked them to scoop out anyway, but there was less to scoop out because it is already flat. I'm interested only in the crispy part, not the soft bready part inside. The empanada was great. They have chicken and beef. If you buy 6 of them, then the 7th one is free. The dessert/sweets assortment varied from things that looked homemade to packaged cookies to muffins from Costco. To go, I bought 2 more garlic bagels with lox and regular cream cheese, a bagel with some homemade chicken salad, a beef and a chicken empanada, plus a black-and-white cookie (which was fresh and delicious even though it was prepackaged.) This place is great, and I wish there was one like this where I live in Redondo Beach, CA. The only negative thing I have to say about Bethpage Bagels is that I wish that they would accept some form of payment other than only cash. Even if it were Venmo, CashApp, or PayPal, any other option would be an easier and more sanitary way to pay for food. I don't like seeing people in a food establishment handling dirty coins and bills if they are also putting food into bags and containers. That's the only reason why I didn't give this place a 5-star rating. If this were not a cash only establishment, I would've purchased 7 empanadas to go, instead of only 2!“

“The recent change of ownership has been a welcomed positive for this establishment. Bagelville is spacious, and there's always room to sit down and read the paper with your bagel and a coffee; that is if you're old school like that. The main reason for my review is the service component of the equation. Oftentimes, Bagel spots can be understaffed and chaotic. People crammed in, long lines, and lackluster experience. My guys at Bagelville want to make sure you get what you came for, and leave with a smile. I recently brought both of my children with me, and it was refreshing the way they interacted with the staff. Overall, if you're in the area, give them a shot. You won't be disappointed. The W7 breakfast wrap is a healthy start to any day of the week.“

“Simply the best bagels! We fill a suitcase full when we fly back to Florida.“

“The owner is one of the nicest and hard-working men you will ever meet. Guaranteed, this is arguably one of the best delis in the East Meadow-Bellmore area. I highly recommend you get their bacon, egg and cheeses OR any of their bagels. You won't be disappointed.“

“My brother and I were craving a real bagel so we set out to try finding a nice place and grab a half dozen. He remembered “ Poppy’s bagels”. The staff were very nice and attentive. It’s a nice cozy place and well cared for. Clean and we definitely will be new customers of theirs. The bagels were delicious and fresh, even stopping at 1:30 in the afternoon. I was very impressed. Great job and wish you great continued success in Amityville. See you guys soon. Thank you.“

“In Nov of 2022, I had the most AMAZING gluten-free bagels I’ve ever tasted! At first, I was afraid they had given me regular bagels! They’re THAT good! I live in Kentucky and have been DREAMING of those bagels ever since I ate the last one!“

“Not only the best bagels and spreads in town, but the service is top notch.“

“very unfriendly, lady at the counter didn't even speak English. It was half hour before closing and they refused to make us a sandwich . will never go there again“

“I love this place but please if you guys see this review, my wife and I love your bagels but my wife just got diagnosed with Celiac which means she can't have anything with gluten anymore, if you guys can come up with a gluten free bagel option so that she can have her nova sandwich that will be great! You might already have the option but we just don't know about it so please if you see this review reply and let us know. My wife and I love the Nova sandwiches with the pickles and potato salad on the side, I have told all my clients about you guys, everytime someone asks what's a good bagel place that I know I brag about you guys. I have sent more than 12 people to your place the last 4 months! I will keep doing so but please look into gluten free options if you don't already have them!! Thanks guys!

-Chris Norman“

“Bagels on the Main is easily one of the best bagel spots around, with perfectly golden bagels that have that ideal crispy outside and soft, chewy inside, tasting fresh and homemade every time whether you go for a classic everything or something sweeter; what really stands out is how generous they are with their cream cheese (with tons of flavors) and how filling their sandwiches are, all made with fresh ingredients, and even when it’s busy the service stays quick and efficient with that classic, authentic bagel shop vibe, making it a place you’ll keep coming back to if you’re anywhere near Huntington.“

“We ordered a 5’ hero - half fried chicken cutlet with peppers and mozzarella and half with lettuce , tomato and cheese. We also ordered mild Buffalo wings. I have to tell you that the hero’s were delicious and the wings were some of the best I’ve had!! Christine was very sweet and responsive, and made the ordering process very easy. Thank you for making our Father’s Day delicious!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Great bagels and coffee“

“Manager of the store is super friendly!! Been here 2x with my dad already. Commuter special is great when you are rushing out to work and need to grab a quick breakfast. Bagels and breakfast sandwiches are fresh. Not salty compared to some bagels that i have had before from other bagel shops. Prices are reasonable“

“The man at the counter was so nice! Great bagel breakfast sandwich and good coffee, such a cute shop.“

“In Nov of 2022, I had the most AMAZING gluten-free bagels I’ve ever tasted! At first, I was afraid they had given me regular bagels! They’re THAT good! I live in Kentucky and have been DREAMING of those bagels ever since I ate the last one!“

“I Have To Say, I Am A Huge Food Critic. These Guys Make The Best Egg Sandwich On Long Island... Delicious & A Definite Recommend 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“A close friend needed to send food for shiva this morning. After just reopening from Rosh Hashanah Sam was able to have this prepared for the family in a short period of time. Everything delicious and plentiful as always. Thank you for always being there for people in our community!“

“Amazing bagels and excellent on everything else. I have moved to FL and never buy bagels. I come to NY and never leave without taking a couple dozen bagels. Excellent customer service. #1 in my book.“

“So on point quite amazing. friendly staff. Perfect scores 10/10“

“Much appreciation for the fresh and delicious dinners served at the Young Israel of East Northport. The assortment of huge bagels, salads and giant cookies hit the spot for the dozens of seminar attendees!“

“all tasty goodies plus the people are great been in town forever 😀😄“

“Love this place, but there are two downsides. One, the beverage cups. The lids never stay open and leak. And two, the man who works the counter whenever I visit (the one who handles the coffees) is very cold. He has been the same ever since I first visited this place 2 years back. I was hoping he would change his demeanor over time so that I would not have to write this, but he still is cold as the first day I met him. He does not make me feel welcomed, has made careless jokes in the past, and never greets me with a smile. I always feel like I am walking on eggshells whenever I ask him for assistance. Aside from that, I do really love the coffee and bagel options, the atmosphere is warm, and the owner is very inviting. It would just be nice to not feel like I am a burden every single time I stop in, and I would visit much more often.

Side note: I am as friendly as can be, so I know that's not the issue here.“

“Bonnie was absolutely amazing! From the moment we walked in, she was professional, attentive, and incredibly efficient. She helped us quickly without rushing us and made sure everything was handled perfectly. Her positive attitude and willingness to go above and beyond truly stood out.

The entire staff was extremely helpful, friendly, and welcoming as well. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers and work great as a team. Overall, it was a fantastic experience thanks to Bonnie and the wonderful staff. Highly recommend!“

“Great bagels, sandwiches, coffee, iced tea and coffees“

“I just want to start off by saying that the bagels at Maru Bagel are SIGNIFICANTLY smaller then the average size bagel you would get at another breakfast / bagel store. I paid $18 for 3 bagels and an orange juice. With that being said… they have a wide selection of options of lunch foods (sandwiches) and breakfast wraps and egg specialities. I love coming here because it is local and they have a GREAT selection of cream cheeses. They by FAR have the BEST pumpkin cream cheese in the area. YOU MUST try to the cinnamon French toast bagel with the pumpkin ? cream cheese you will love it!“

“Super nice staff. Great NY bagels! Willing to cook me anything my mind makes up! Great baked goods, cozy, friendly, great coffee.“

“Egg sandwiches and the best bagels 🥯“

“Great bagels. Every time we come back to NY we always stock up on the best bagels in the neighborhood.“

“Been coming here since they opened. The owner & everyone who works here is amazing. The bagels & sandwiches never disappoint and i love to support small business!“

“Loved the delicious breakfast and the neat environment since the new owner came . Keep up the great work 👌🏻“

“Loved This Place! Went here my 3 morning in Freeport!! Can’t wait to come back and visit! Originally from N.Merrick. Currently living in Denver“

“They have the best breakfast ever🙌🏻😋“

“Great food and wonderful people. 👍👍👍“

“I have been patronizing this store since they opened. First of all they have the most amazing one-of-a-kind everything bagel twists with sesame, poppy and salt…delicious! Then, the store is the cleanest I’ve seen…everything is fresh and perfectly presented. They make the best sandwiches, and the service is prompt and courteous…they’re polite, fast and efficient. I definitely recommend Lotsa.“

“The staff are amazing people, Miguel has always treated me and my family so well and the food always comes out exactly how we asked. The best bagels on long island they're fresh and never disappoint. 10/10 would tell anyone to go here for bagels on Long Island.“

“Stopped by this bagel shop recently and honestly, it did not disappoint. The bagels were fresh, soft on the inside with that perfect chewy crust on the outside—exactly how a good bagel should be. You can tell they’re made fresh.

I ordered an egg and cheese sandwich on a toasted everything bagel, and it was simple but really satisfying. The portion size was solid, and they didn’t skimp on the fillings. Coffee was also fresh and paired perfectly with the meal.

Service was quick and friendly, even during a busy morning rush, which I really appreciated. The place itself was clean, casual, and had that classic neighborhood vibe.

If you’re looking for a reliable spot for breakfast or a quick bite, this place is definitely worth checking out. I’ll be coming back to try more from the menu.“

“i got the chicken cutlet cup bap. it was good. The japchae was great and the kimchi wasn't too strong, but the chicken was a little bit burnt and the rice lacked salt. Otherwise, nice place, friendly staff, and reasonable prices. But the cups are 13 dollars, not 12 as it says in the store or $15 like on here.“

“Love, love love this place the best bagels breakfast service around a Farmingdale staple for many many many many many years🥯🥯🥯🥯🥯🥯🥯👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽“

“Stellar bagels. Hot, fresh and always delicious. Once I discovered this place I can’t stop going. The staff is always friendly and no matter what I order they always get it just right. I’ve been on the island for about 5 years now and am happy to have finally discovered a bagel spot where the price and quality meet hand in hand.“

“Simply the best bagels! We fill a suitcase full when we fly back to Florida.“

“The bagels had a great flavor to the bread. They were perfectly chewy and pillowy. I love the color on the bottom. Perfection!

We didnt like the egg salad which I don't add to my score since I can count on one finger how many times I have gotten that at a deli. My daughter wanted it on a whim.

The Staff was the right amount of gruff and kind“