25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Jamaica

“It was my first time there and the experience was great!!! The place was clean they played good music and the young lady behind the counter was soooo nice 😊 and the pizza was nice hot fresh and delicious that curry oxtail slice is lifffffeeeeeee“

“There pizza is so yummy. my son and daughter love it very much.“

“Great New York Pizza! Price is not bad!!!“

“HI MY STUDENTS FIRST TIME AT YOUR RESTAURANT AND THEY HAD AN AMAZING TIME. OUTSTANDING SERVICE AND AN AMAZING PIZZA FOR THEM.“

“I have been coming here since the late 90's when I was a student @ JHS217. The food has always been fresh and well made to order! The remodel was much needed and the quality hasn't been sacrificed from what I have seen over the years.

I no longer live in the area, but was visiting on business recently and decided to grab a slice for nostalgia sake. Sadly, it was late in the day and they were preparing to close, so the selection wasn't as vast as mid-day would be. My Sicilian Margherita slice was still amazing and I will continue to patronize this neighborhood gem for years to come! A1 from day one.“

“I ordered sandwiches from Mr Benny on several occasions - for my own functions and also for my Church. The latest order was for a church function on 07/11/2026 and I have to say that every type of sandwich was a tremendous hit. Everyone enjoyed every last bite. Customer service was exceptional and Mr. Benny and his staff are all awesome. When you walk in, you feel at home.
Thank you Mr. Benny and staff for everything!“

“Great food, nice employees, and quick service, I have no complaints but whenever we go in and this particular staff member is behind the counter, she always says they have no olives. That would be fine but it seems to only be when this person is taking our order that they say they have no olives. I visit this place frequently and whenever we are seen by another staff member they will give us olives no problem, or even ask green or black? How is it that there are neither green nor black olives whenever this person takes our order? It is a great establishment but where is this woman hiding the olives??? I would also like to mention that she frequently gets our orders mixed up. I asked for a mushroom slice and my friend asked for an olive slice, she took our order and went to prepare it but we saw her making 2 mushroom slices instead. We quickly corrected her, and only then she said that they had no olives. Instead of asking if my friend would like something instead of olives while taking our order, she didn't mention that they didn't have any and decided to give her mushroom instead without her knowing.“

“buenas noches quiero dar gracias a Jones pizza por haberme dado un trabajo y por confiar en mí como persona y de antemano quiero agradecer a la señora mambo la al señor Miguel a Orlando y a champ hablo que a lo mejor ellos no me recuerdan pero juntos comenzamos el sueño de la pizzería John's pizza les mando un saludo desde mi tierra México soy Ari Aristeo y que mi Dios los bendiga“

“The pizza is awesome and the chicken is my drug of choice!!! Their food isn't salty at all. I love getting food from here. The atmosphere is okay. It gets crowded with lots of kids after school and in the summer but thank God, I've never witnessed any fights“

“(Translated by Google) This is the neatest and cleanest establishment in Jamaica. Tasty and big pizza for $3.5 - $4.5 ??(Original)Это самое аккуратное и чистое заведение в джамайке. Вкусная и большая пицца за 3,5 - 4,5$ ??“

“I recently bought 1 slice of pizza with extra cheese & it was VERY GOOD!!! Gabby’s is SOGGY & Farmers is RUDE, so this is my NEW spot for pizza!“

“The best price for great food, that arrives quickly without any issue. I highly recommend them, granted a world class pizza place is next door... but even Singa's pizza is not something I'd turn away. And given how much easier\\faster\\cheaper ever an issue it is to get their pizza vs Danny's, I recommend them even for pizza.“

“Quick delivery, well priced. My favorite slice is the chicken bacon ranch 🍕“

“many closed in my area. glad this one is still open very busy“

“So happy there’s a local pizza shop with halal (hand-slaughtered) options. There’s a halal platter shop inside, I did get a mixed platter to go which was pretty good (they have a lot of toppings available you wouldn’t normally get from carts). The pizza shop itself offers halal chicken and pepperoni, I tried a bbq chicken slice. Can’t wait to come back!“

“The pizza here is the real deal. Sauce delicious, crust perfectly foldable, yet crispy, cheese fresh and velvety. Hands down the best pizza I have had in many years. Brought back great memories from the past.“

“We came from the airport looking for breakfast and boy did we enjoy this best service friendly staff loved it would recommend this spot to everyone who's interested in good old fashioned breakfast and style enjoy everyone give them a try you would not regret it ?“

“This our second time ordering from Mario’s. The first time we had a typical NY style pizza and it was amazing, this time we went with Pasta and a Roll and a calzone. OMG our taste buds were dancing around in delight. Mario’s is convenient for us as truckers as they deliver and very quick as well. If your a Trucker delivering to JFK then this place is a must. If your anyone else and your in the Jamaica area this place is a must. Thank you for a delicious lunch and dinner.“

“I've bought lunch for me and my 3 workers, the salesman who help us, what a wonderful way to make you feel well treated, promptness , kindness, professionalism, smileness , what else to add ???
I recommend 100%, also tasty pizza.“

“Another local favorite for the area. They have a huge selection of menu and alot to choose from.

Food: 🍽 I have tried the Personal Pizza, Lasagna, Chicken Parm Hero and Calzone from here. All was delicious and amazing. Extra cheesey and good. The Lasagna was definitely my favorite and would get again. If I had to pick a 2nd favorite, it would be the personal sized pizza. Those are my 2 favorites. They have some pretty amazing wings and salad options that I havent tried yet but definitely plan to on my next visit. So I'll be adding those pictures later on.

Price: 💲The Lasagna is $11. And the Personal Plain Pizza is $7. The Chicken Parm Hero was $10 and the Calzone was $11. The beef patty with cheese was also $4.50. All great prices to be honest.

Location: 🗺 They are located on Farmers Blvd near Bedell street. Right under the LIRR Locust Manor Station. Nearby Busses include the Q3, Q85, Q89“

“The service here is excellent. Our server was attentive without being intrusive. The entire staff worked seamlessly together to create a seamless dining experience. We never had to ask anything twice!”“

“I frequent this superb place from time to time as I like the special air that is characterizes this restaurant. The personel is extraordianrillyremarkably friendly and experienced. The service is awfully quick. Not to mention, the food they prepare is good. I ate there many times and I was always satisfied. The payment is modest. I recommend this place to my friends and family.“

“I believe that their service is very quick. You get a pretty big slice of cheese pizza for 3 dollars however I have had pizza this big and this reasonable in terms of price but tasted better than this spot. Though I must say if you’re looking for a quick bitter for your child if they’re hungry you can stop there and buy a slice or two.“

“I recently had the pleasure of visiting Papa John’s and was thoroughly impressed with the overall experience.
The quality of the food was excellent, with fresh ingredients and perfectly baked pizzas.
The service was prompt, efficient, and handled with great professionalism.
The staff members were courteous, attentive, and ensured a welcoming environment.
Special appreciation goes to the manager, Shikha, for her outstanding leadership and customer-focused approach.
She managed the team exceptionally well and maintained high service standards throughout.
The cleanliness and hygiene of the store were also commendable.
Orders were prepared accurately and delivered on time, enhancing the overall satisfaction.
It is evident that customer experience is a top priority at this location.
I would highly recommend this Papa John’s outlet for both quality food and excellent service.“