50 Best American Restaurants near New Hyde Park

“In Nov of 2022, I had the most AMAZING gluten-free bagels I’ve ever tasted! At first, I was afraid they had given me regular bagels! They’re THAT good! I live in Kentucky and have been DREAMING of those bagels ever since I ate the last one!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
What a hidden gem!
The food was incredible — fresh, flavorful, and definitely not frozen. The ambience and vibe were on point, with great energy and a live DJ setting the perfect mood. Honestly, anyone saying otherwise must be used to eating caviar or something exotic, because this place is the real deal.

It’s rare to find a spot that nails the food, music, and atmosphere and keeps prices so reasonable. Plus, it’s located right inside a golf course — how this place isn’t packed every night, I have no idea. Highly recommend checking it out before everyone else discovers it!“

“The taste as good as they look🤭🤭🤭 Definitely a 🙌🏻“

“Jade was our server, and she was amazing. Very attentive, very sweet and amazing personality. She made sure everything was going well and made sure our food arrived and tasted great!! 10/10 experience, will definitely be back!! Thank you Jade!“

“Always a Delicious Meal and Cocktails! Friendly and Attentive service! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I recommend everyone that requires excellent pallet for their dining pleasure, service that is second to none and great mixology, then Have It Haviland’s Way“

“We love going to Foster—at this point, you could say we’re regulars. We typically sit at the bar. We especially love their specials, and I’m still thinking about the elk burger I had last year (please bring it back!).The oysters are always fresh and delicious, and the fried chicken is absolutely amazing. Recently, I’ve been loving the salmon with corn and shishito succotash and blueberry teriyaki. Honestly, everything is consistently fresh and delicious.

John, the bartender, makes excellent cocktails—many with fun names like Silence of the Lambrusco. He puts a lot of care into his craft, from house-infused ingredients to thoughtful presentation. He also always keeps you hydrated with their house water, which I truly appreciate.

Happy hour is a great deal and is available at the bar only, Wednesday through Sunday from 5:00–7:00 pm, and all night on Mondays. We love ordering the wood-fired Margherita pizza and fried chicken wings for $12.36, along with their house margarita at $10.30—delicious and affordable.

When we do get a table, the service is always spot on.

We feel lucky to have such an amazing restaurant in our neighborhood.“

“A great night out at Chadwick’s. Ali was great! 😊“

“I experienced Nettie’s for the first time last evening. My dining experience was excellent from arrival to departure. The food was “DELISH!” The owner was welcoming & hospitable, the service was good, and the music and atmosphere wea awesome! I am so pleased and proud to have a “Black” owned establishment where you can dine in Queens in a tasteful environment, supporting our entrepreneurs and our community. I, along with others will be back!!!“

“Jhaon was my server/bartender today.
Such an amazing job.
My drink was absolutely delicious and my meal was too.
Service was kind, attentive, and accurate.
I had a terrific experience today and will definitely be back soon.“

“First-time visit. Food was delicious and the bartender/server, Peter, was friendly and efficient. Observing other patrons, all seemed to be quite pleased. I’ll be back😊“

“Service is always great and the food is amazing. Love to order 3 or 4 dishes and share. ❤️“

“Great spot for burgers and chicken sandwiches! The chicken platters are absolute fire too! 5/5“

“Jessie is always attentive and on top of things. She's always very kind and helpful! Everytime we come here we always ask for her and are willing to wait if there is no table available at that time. She answers all questions and is always very helpful!“

“Truly excellent food, service and atmosphere. We had very attentive service as dishes were delivered promptly and cleared quickly. The food was prepared and presented well and tasted delicious. The twilight special is a great value and we even have leftovers for another meal. We will definitely return and highly recommend.“

“I had the tuna and it was absolutely delicious!!“

“BEST ON LONG ISLAND 💯🫡
FRESH cooked to order AMAZING SERVICE
Impeccable quality of food & im there 5 days
A week for dinner & EVERY time more than
Satisfied from day 1 of finding these gentleman Can’t say enough good things about them & in my line of work all I here are complaint's & nasty comments
For once I’d like to say something GOOD
Here it is & better then good ITS GREAT!!“

“I came here for a get together for a friend's graduation.

It's a really nice family-owned restaurant in the area. Would be a decent date spot, especially because of the outdoor seating... call ahead and see if you can bring a board game.

Kimchi burger was amazing and I'd come back just for that!“

“Ashley is the absolute best server ever! She is so friendly and attentive and is your secret sauce at 32 North. I will always return because she ensured that we had a great experience. The food is top notch and the restaurant is a VIBE! Playlist was on point and the decor is A-1!“

“Lamb special Chicken special Tuna Salmon pasta Impeccable service. Perfect evening“

“I have been a customer of Austin’s Ale House for many years, I know them well they know me well. This year I decided to give the excellent and highly favored family cooking team a break and had Austin’s Ale House cater our Christmas Dinner. I went with the ham dinner for 10 to feed 7 people🤣. The ordering was done with ease and so was the pick up. The family did a preliminary tasting...... LOVED .IT and whatever we have left after the “taste test” will have to serve as our Christmas Dinner. Since the taste test was so aggressive we may need to supplement what’s left with a few cheese omelets 🤣. We enjoyed it so much there was much talk about it becoming the new family tradition. THANK YOU AUSTIN’S ALE HOUSE AND MEREY CHRISTMAS........ PS I’m going to need one of those backyard igloos in a day or so. See you then 🎄❤️“

“My favorite local pub. Excellent Sunday brunch!Always lively and fun. They always accommodated me when I organized high school reunions.“

“love this place. the service is excellent. The food is fresh and good quality and most of the time I can’t finish it they give so much very generous portions. always greeted when you come in the front door like you a family can’t get any better than that“

“Customer service was excellent!!!The atmosphere was very beautiful. The food was very delicious. The craziest thing was my boyfriend and I would pass by there all the time not knowing about this restaurant until I went for my birthday. The experience was everything 💕I will definitely be coming back to try their delicious food.“

“Our group had a wonderful experience at Sullivan’s Quay. Delicious food, cocktails and great service. Thank you Brian and crew! We will be back!💕“

“This place it's so cute! A must try for sure. Their food is amazing good! I went with my girls to celebrate our birthdays and it did not disappointed. Coming back for sure!“

“Just had a Birthday Dinner and we enjoyed from the beginning to the end. The food was amazing! The octopus dish is delicious.. i loved the atmosphere and the service was excellent. I highly recommend this place!!!!“

“Great place For food,drinks and an amazing staff.what a great crowd always!“

“Excellent food and service. A+++++“

“Fantastic restaurants space both indoor and out. Greg, our waiter could not have been more courteous and giving great service. The food is very meticulously prepared and the taste is absolutely delicious. Definitely under utilized in the neighborhood but what a a find“

“Thyme is a beautiful restaurant with great ambience, wonderful waitstaff and fantastic food! Food presentation is wonderful and prepared to perfection. Do not hesitate to go there for a Sunday brunch, any day dinner, you will not be disappointed.“

“Louie’s has an extensive menu where can’t go wrong with anything on there! The service is quick and very friendly. I tend to get something different every time. It’s bar far my favorite diner.“

“New menu...OMG!...and must try!...the ruben!...the best we EVER had!...the chicken curry half and half...the most unique warm flavor that makes you want more!...the staff?...the most attentive caring warm humans!“

“There ribs are second to none“

“The team from River Mill has fed our team multiple meals and it has all been delicious! The owner is absolutely amazing and the staff was all friendly with great service!“

“Delicious breakfast old style atmosphere“

“My wife and I had a great experience at Nancy’s restaurant the food is delicious with excellent customer service five stars for sure ❤️“

“The Coral House is a grandiose experience. It emits a unique sense of style and elegance suitable for a wedding. But, it does have a few cracks.
The lighting and overall atmosphere is incredible! When you think of the highlights of a wedding venue, the Coral House should be a strong consideration.
There was a wide selection of food and drink, and the rooftop area for cocktail hour leans in to the New York wedding experience. For some reason, people cannot deny drinking and eating while looking over the gorgeous lake the Coral House rests next to.
I’ll also state, the overall service was great!
Now for the cracks. While the “vibes” are great, there is still a lot of unsightly corners. For example, the rooftop bar broke the level of elegance by letting us see into the dingy corners of that room. A few curtains, some dimmer lights, and maybe some other set dressings would have made the experience just that much tighter. A venue is not just about the view, it is also about the presentation.

Besides those little bits, I think The Coral House deserves to be on the short list of wedding venues.“

“nice atmosphere different than most, food good too“

“friendly, helpful service good food good dessert, love a good Fribble“

“Absolutely fantastic! Impeccable food and service and the place is a plus: elegant and unique atmosphere. An added bonus is the outdoor dining area with great view to the golf course.“

“Wonderful dinner - seasonal selections. Chef/owner is so friendly and polite efficient server“

“Great service! Great food!“

“Great food great customer service“

“And - we're back for the 2nd time in a month - just couldn't resist trying more options on the winter menu. This time around we shared tuna tartare app which was plenty for sharing and an excellent option. Dinner choices from our servers suggestions were butterfish and scallops. We enjoyed it all. Great flavors and presentation. Portions were just right, even if it means no take-home box. Looking forward to Spring!“

“From NC and my boi Terrell suggested here. Food and ambience was absolutely incredible!! Will definitely come back!“

“I’ve been eating at The Chateau since childhood. The creators of the Mish Chopped Salad. The friendly atmosphere, the comfort food, those great soups, everything is delicious and fresh. I love the dinners too. Good old fashioned food and service.“

“Food was outstanding! My first time there. Will definitely be back!“

“Awesome food, drinks, atmosphere and service“

“The place is a vibe. The atmosphere and esthetics is everything. It has a great vintage, cozy, bookstore mature feels with these bold eclectic open frames. Food is good. Well presented but lacks flavor. Where the food lacks in the drinks make up in style. Service is attentive but not amazing. Overall. Great time. Great vibes. Would recommend and go again for the feel, not the food.“