19 Best Cafes near New Suffolk

Minnow At The Galley Ho Cafe • $$$
650 1st St, New Suffolk

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Speared Blackfish Almondine
Smoked Liquid Gold Old Fashioned
Line Caught Fluke Oreganata
Lobster Roll
Fish

“Everything on the menu is first-rate. We had a great time at Minnow at the Galley Ho. Andrea Tese has done a great job with the restaurant.“

4 Good141 Reviews
Encanto Crepes & Cafe Cafe • $
Recommended
117 Main St, Greenport - 9.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken-Scallion Crêpe
Colombian Cheese Bread
Sweet Colombian Crepe
Regular Brewed Coffee
Coffee Bar Selections
Scramble Egg Crêpe
Ham & Cheese Crêpe
Ham & Cheese Crepe
Coconut Lemonade
S'Mores Crêpe

“So goood every time! Great food and delicious coffee“

4.9 Superb118 Reviews
Aldo's Coffee Company Bakery • $
103-105 Front St, Greenport - 9.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Croissant
Scones

“The place is very convenient. I like the coffee and the ambiance is nice and relaxing and also the service was good. The staffs are very nice“

4.5 Superb112 Reviews
Goldberg's Famous Bagels Cafe • $
131 3rd St, Greenport - 9.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagels
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Hobo Bagel Sandwich
Everything Bagel
French Toast
Lox

“I got something I didn't ask for with my order (I think I paid for it) we ate it anyway it was pretty good. The bagels could have been toasted alittle darker, I thought it wasn't toasted at all when I bit into it but then I saw a very feint light brown on the edge of the bagel so it must have been toasted just not enough for me. I'd still go here again, I'll just make sure everything is in order before leaving.“

4.7 Superb37 Reviews
Pip's Cafe & Provisions Cafe • $
218 Main St, Greenport - 9.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ciabatta
Pastries

“This is the best coffee in town if you like espresso drinks, but the drip coffee is also great. Was here with a large group for the weekend, we all have different coffee preferences and tried other spots too and this place came out on top. They use Counter Culture coffee and a La Marzocco espresso machine. It doesn’t hurt that the place is also super cute and they have a great assortment of vintage records. The croissants are worth it, but the breakfast sandwiches take way too long.“

4.5 Superb56 Reviews
Stars Cafe Cafe • $
17 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Chicken
Chilaquiles Con Huevo
Blueberry Pancakes
Grilled Chicken
Pancake Platter
Huevos Rancheros
Yoghurt Parfait
Healthy Wrap
French Toast
Soup of The

“This beautiful spot is THE culinary highlight of Shelter Island. From breakfast burritos to burgers, to coffee and smoothies, this place can do it all and do it well. They are beyond welcoming and open to everyone that’s walks in. Since moving away I’ve missed their hospitality and food more than ever. So go in and have a try they are definitely worth it!!“

4.6 Superb29 Reviews
The Gallery Cafe Cafe • $$
437 Main St, Greenport - 9.87 miles

“We spent our anniversary here and had a great experience. It’s a beautiful space with a gorgeous outside patio. Alejandro made sure to make us feel special and welcomed for the duration of our stay. The hotel is a 5 minute walk from anything you need and a 20 minute walk to 57 steps beach. We would definitely stay here again!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Four Oaks Cafe & Juice Bar Cafe • $
42 Jagger Ln, Southampton - 8.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cali Bay Chicken Sandwich
Cali Cali Veggie Sandwich
Build Your Own Acai
Hot Chicken Wrap
Avocado Panini
Buddha Burger
Avocado Toast
Surfers Bowl
Buddha Bowl
Quesadilla

“Chef Pilar’s menu is not only healthy it’s creative and absolutely delicious. Thank you for loving food and making it an art!“

4 Good28 Reviews
Shinnecock Eats Cafe Cafe • $$
42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton - 7.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich

“Shinnecock Lobster Factory makes amazing lobster rolls! I ordered a warm, buttery “whale” roll. You could have ordered a small “dolphin,” a medium “shark,” or a large “whale” and the whale roll has the most lobster meat. The whale roll is more expensive but I think it was worth it. I bought a raspberry iced tea for my drink. There is only outdoor seating, including a grass area you can bring dogs. You order at the window and bring the food to the tables with benches. There is no indoor seating. The restaurant is a quick 5-minute drive from downtown Southampton. I definitely recommend this restaurant and will be going back!“

3.6 Good7 Reviews
Panera Bread Cafe • $
180 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 8.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panera Cookie Varieties
Panera Bagel Variety
Creamy Tomato Soup
French Baguette

“love the coffee club! great place to relax!“

3.9 Good28 Reviews
Pookaberry Cafe Food • $$
Recommended
140 Pike St, Mattituck - 3.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pooka's Personal Pan Pizza
Potato Cheese Balls
Chicken Sandwich
Bang Bang Shrimp
Sauteed Oysters
Pancit Noodles
Chicken Inasal
Chicken Adobo
Ramen Carbona
Crab Paste

“Completely stumbled on this place and honestly I was a little leery at first. The menu is more extensive than anything I’ve ever seen in my life, which is their goal, but makes ordering a little hard for an indecisive Gemini like me. Marco, the front man, recommended something, I ordered it and I was not disappointed. The hubs loved his app,meal and his drink just as much, and Marco has so much personality and self admittedly can talk your ear off, but in a good way (if ya like that sort of thing)“

4.6 Superb53 Reviews
Southold General Cafe • $
54180 Main Rd, Southold - 5.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich Display
Quiche

“The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!“

3.8 Good52 Reviews
Country Corner Cafe Family • $
55765 NY-25, Southold - 5.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado and Chicken Salad over Greens
Croissant French Toast with Berries
Buttermilk Pancakes
All American Panini
Ice Cream Sundae
Roast Beef Melt
Grilled Cheese
Corn Beef Hash
Eggs Benedict
Egg Sandwich

“Despite the unassuming appearance of the Rueben, it was probably one of the better ones I’ve had in recent years. It did not come with thousand island, so I requested extra on the side. It was flavorful, and the corn beef was tender. Even without the thousand island, it wasn’t a dry sandwich to begin with. I was pleasantly surprised.
We also ordered the Southold Burger which was insane. It was massive and messy, but it was a very good burger. A side of fries will run you up $5, but they’re solid. They needed extra salt but were hot and fresh.
Everything on the menu sounded fantastic, and I don’t think you can go wrong here. Definitely would stop by again.“

4.5 Superb50 Reviews
The Village Cheese Shop Cafe • $$$
105 Love Ln, Mattituck - 3.07 miles

“Fabulous selection, excellent and friendly staff. Made shopping a breeze!“

4.6 Superb18 Reviews
Bagel Place Cafe & Deli LLC. Cafe • $
40 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays - 8.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Turkey and Swiss

“Friendly clean atmosphere great food good customer service best place in town I highly recommend it. Friendly helpful staff great selection of food very consistent great bakery items“

3.6 Good44 Reviews
Goodfood. Health Food • $
535 Pike St, Mattituck - 3.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Empanadas & Vegetable Chili
Gula Gula Meal
Soups

“I have been frequenting this place alot this season due to its reliability, friendliness, and quality. The Cold brew coffee is great, breakfast empanadas are the perfect way to start your day, the smoothies are refreshing, and the lunch empanadas are delicious!

Looking forward to continuing to support Goodfood this season!“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews
East End Bagel Cafe Cafe • $
46455 Middle Rd, Southold - 6.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
A Bagel

“Thank you for catering our brunch of bagels, muffins and danish. Everything was delicious and all were raving about it. Thank you Susan and crew.“

3 Average20 Reviews
Golden Pear Cafe Cafe • $$
99 Main St, Southampton - 8.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Authentic Challah Bread French Toast
Chicken & Black Bean Quesadilla
Mega Protein Omelet
Tomato Mozzarella
The Sag Harbor
Cheese Danish
Brownies
Soup

“I take comfort, knowing that the golden pea is right on the corner. If I need a healthy Ish snack it’s always right where I need to be. The coffee is good. I would say that in the summary you should sit inside because the bees will swarm.“

3.1 Average55 Reviews
Marie Eiffel Market Cafe • $$
184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island - 9.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Parisian Sandwich
Pastry Raspberry
Tart Tatin for 2
Apple Tartine
Baguette
Pizza
Bakery

“Food was pretty good, simple but quite a few nice options for breakfast. Something for everyone. They roast La Colombe coffee, which we enjoyed!

Lots of bees outside on the dock area so we ate inside but felt the inside could be a little more elevated/cleaner given the concept and price point. Would be a great place to pick up some provisions if you’re staying in a house on the island!“

3.4 Good32 Reviews

You May Also Like