9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Oswego

“The food is always great, and the service is always friendly. 10 out of 10! I would definitely recommend!“

“This is the best pizza in all of Oswego Ny and a great price as well!! I mean that’s what I would expect coming from a guy who works the front counter with a Yankees shirt on.(ALWAYS). Now I’m from longisland so I know real pizza. This is real pizza. Anyone who walks around in this town and says hmmm let me get some cams doo doo or some pie guy trash (they cut their pizza in rectangles…)
I’m convinced they don’t know what true authentic NY pizza is!! I kid you not this is the best there is in this town. It’s a shame I see people walking into any of the other pizza restaurants in this town they are unworthy. Their market is for drunks this Yankees dudes market is quality… trust me I know… so if you ever want REAL NY style pizza this is your place.“

“We have tried most pizza joints in Oswego- and none of them quite hit the mark. Cold upon arrival- raw onion tossed on the pizza prior to arrival (oops we meant to cook it) or just crappy pizza! So we decided to try Pizza Villa and we are pretty happy with the pizza. It is on the thicker side which presents a small issue that I will address- but the flavor was great, toppings abundant and the baked wings were delicious. Heading home from Liverpool we called and placed a pickup order. Meat pizza with onions and an order of plain wings- crispy. Staff that answered the phone were great and informative and after a “give us about 30 min” I hung up the phone and headed their way. Arrived to lots of smiles and happy staff making pizzas and wings and told them we had not had great experiences with other places in Oswego- and they said “well we hope you love ours” Got home and dug in. The pizza and sauce (just the right amount) is delicious. I had asked for it to be well done as we generally prefer thin crust, theirs is pretty thick, and they obliged. The wings were really great and fell off the bone. The only criticism I have is that due to the thickness of the crust, it wasn’t cooked through and was doughy. They seem to cook the pizza in a pan in the oven and it doesn’t have direct contact with the oven (that is what I saw) so perhaps the pan is keeping the crust from cooking through? Not sure- but it was the only draw back. It wasn’t horribly undercooked just enough that it was noticeable. Other than that- great taste, great experience and we will be back!!“

“amazing. Wonzones Calzones is a gift from the gods. I don’t know what sort of magic the folks at Wonzones are putting in their food, but every bite is filled with flavor. The staff are angels in aprons. Wonzones is the perfect place whether it’s 2AM or 6pm. If I could give the 6/5 stars I would. This place is perfect. They might jus have the best calzones on the PLANET. Don’t miss it.“

“Perfect ending to a perfect day, Cheeseburger pizza and wings, Dar + Norm 2/14/21“

“Its a tad expensive for what you get. Meal does come with 4 slices of bread but no salad or soup unless you pay for them. We had lasagna and chicken fetticine alfredo and 2 mixed drinks for $80 (without tip added) - could not taste any alcohol in drinks so asked for another shot to be added. So we paid for doubles. Waitress was wonderful, lasagna was over baked. Alfredo sauce was delicious.“

“It was fresh out of the Oven and it was delicious.“

“Ordered an Eggplant Parm Hero for delivery and it was absolutely beautiful! I ordered it with extra cheese and it was SMOTHERED in Mozzerella with the crispy eggplant and it absolutely made my night! Will def be making this place a new regular spot!“

“Great night wine Wednesday with a great singer Eric Ruckus“