8 Best Ice Cream Shops near Phelps

“Always love to go to gooneys awesome food and ice cream“

“We love Mr. Twistee’s! They have a wide variety of ice cream based desserts and lots of flavors to choose from. I especially love that they offer several ice creams to choose from if you have dietary restrictions. They have both dairy and gluten free options, as well as a few vegan and low cholesterol options as well. Beyond that, their sundaes are delicious and their portions are generous. I’ve been here multiple times and never gotten a rude staff member, however I went here recently and was served by Connor, who was absolutely amazing!! He was so patient and kind, answering any questions we had. You can tell he really cared about offering the customers the best experience and was very knowledgeable about each flavor they offered. He really made the experience more enjoyable. We will definitely be back!“

“4 stars ONLY because the location is not exactly in the best spot BUT it works... and the Ice Cream is pretty good. Lots of parking, tho not anywhere really to sit and enjoy. Assuming most sit on thier cars or in them. Friendly for 1st time experience, traffic makes it overwhelming a bit. Very doable tho.“

“I never knew that this place was even there! The perfect spot to rest your feet, use the restroom & get refreshments if you happen to be out for a walk along the water. My husband & I had our dog King with us, who is still getting used to behaving in public places & around crowds of people.He was not bothered or anxious by the people, he actually behaved better than ever! We sat down to eat and he loved every minute! I especially appreciated the pup cup on the menu, King thank you for that. The girls were very friendly & professional. I didn't see any alcohol ice cream though only wine slushies. We were slightly disappointed by the prices vs. quality of the food ( ex nachos) and the options available. But the hotdog was delicious! Overall, it was worth the time & money we spent. We enjoyed our visit and will definitely return again soon.“

“What a lovely discovery!
We stopped here on a whim while out on a drive around the Fingerlakes.
There is quite a large selection of sweet treats here and they are very accommodating.
I selected a chocolate banana milkshake, which was excellent.
I got real banana and got to the bottom of the cup way too fast.

If you are in the area, I recommend a trip to Peppy's.
Very glad we took the time to check it out!“

“This is one of my son’s favorite places to visit in Geneva. Geneva Gelato always has delicious flavors to choose from as well as coffee, tea, and other desserts. Recently, Geneva Gelato hosted my son’s fourth birthday party, and I couldn’t be happier with how it turned out. It was a wonderful venue for family and friends to celebrate. We were able to come a little early to do a little setting up, we were able to bring our own cupcakes, and they even gave goody bags to all the kids who came. The staff was so accommodating and kind; they even joined us in signing Happy Birthday to my son. What a fantastic place! I highly recommend visiting or asking about small events.“

“The soft ice cream is absolutely delicious. Very good quality. And the staff there is very friendly very good place to go.“

“I do recommend however not today. I had asked/ordered under the DYI for all the veggies on a sandwich, my sister ordered a sandwich with dressing on the side. We told them it was for “here”. We got the food brought to us in a bag to go. My sister asked for the dressing on the side. I did not get a veggie sandwich I got a panini with feta cheese, tomato, spinach and onion with a pesto sauce. Granted it was busy, but today the young woman did not listen to what we asked for. It was based on what they thought we asked for. Or who knows maybe the cook misinterpreted the order. Even though I brought it to their attention, she said I asked for a very veggie panini and I told her I did not ( that was her copartner telling us it’s covered under the veggie panini, I told her when she the copartner said that i was thinking i had no clue how they were going to fit all those veggies on a panini but ok). she wanted to make it right, but we already waited over 30 mins for our to go meal which should have been for there to begin with, to even be brought to us. I threw my meal out, couldn’t even eat it I was so disappointed, my sister could not finish her sandwich or chips because there was too much dressing on the sandwich when it was supposed to be on the side. Overall today was a big disappointment and waste of 26.00 plus a nice tip in the jar. Will I go there again? Sure at some point, because really they do a good job. This is the 2nd time I’ve gone this yr, last time was for breakfast which was fantastic! I considered today a donation.“