9 Best Ice Cream Shops near Phelps

“We stopped here after a photoshoot at Ontario Pathways on recommendation of our photographer, and it was a wonderful experience! The staff are friendly, the atmosphere is wonderful with indoor and outdoor seating options, and the food is delicious. Conveniently located near the trails and along NY-96, this place is an easy quick stop and totally worth the visit. Will come again!“

“Been coming here ever since I was a kid. Great ice cream at a reasonable price. The service is usually fast even when there's a long line, and the overall ambiance is nice for a small town. It's easy to come and order ice cream and just eat it outside or in your car. Overall I'd recommend the place!“

“Every time my family goes here we are stuffed! There portions are great! I always get dark chocolate and cheese cake, it's a great combo, you also can't go wrong with the banana split, the is almost always a line around the building but they move really fast and if you don't feel like waiting you can go inside, where they have a little above ground pond/fish tank“

“I was just looking for a quick hit of soft serve ice cream while in Geneva and stopped by Mr. Twistees. The person in front of us got their cone which looked too much so i asked "what size is that?" "This is literally a small"“

“Peppy's Ice Cream is very good. Except the only problem is that sometimes they don't make the flurry's as good as I want them. All they have to do is add more Oreo's! When I eat it all it is is just vanilla ice cream. Hardly any Oreo. I'm not trying to be rude or anything. I just prefer more Oreo's. Thanks :)“

“A hidden gem in Wayne County. There is a special menu change each week for their lunch special, which is nice. Love the Finger Lakes Roasters coffee. Fairly decent prices, if you'd like to sit down.Since this cafe employs both individuals with and without developmental/intellectual needs, you have to be patient sometimes. Typically a 5 min (max) wait if no one sees you come in.**Helpful tip - There are three businesses within Erie Shore Landing! The Cafe, Ice Cream Shop & Print Shop. The cafe faces the canal, the ice cream shop is on the corner of the building and the print shop is right next door to the ice cream shop. :) The print shop does AMAZING work. Krystal and Jessica will be rebranding my business soon! It's so great seeing such friendly local faces helping one another.“

“Clean, friendly and very open staff that will help you order on your next visit! Food was ok. Not as good as I was expecting but it was good enough to eat.Parking: Pretty big parking lot.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes and they have a ramp style sidewalk.“

“The owner was behind the counter, and I came in later in the evening. The coffee was very good so of course I had to try the cheesecake. I loved that it wasn’t too sweet, but it had flavor and a great consistency. The atmosphere was really fun a little, funky old school, but comfortable while I’m in town. I’m definitely gonna go back and try something else there. This is the kind of place we want to see more of :-)“

“They have good pizza, and the prices are fair, but I really wish they had a larger variety of toppings. I wanted a sausage & meatballs pizza, but they don't have meatballs. I ended up getting pepperoni & sausage with 2 orders of wings. The mild wing sauce is good and the garlic parmesan is outstanding! Other than not having the meatballs or was a good experience.“