50 Best American Restaurants near Pine Island

“I love this restaurant. The food is excellent and the service is fantastic.“

“Last night, for my birthday, we had what I have to call a perfect, and perfectly delicious meal. You can’t take a picture of an experience, but if there were a way, we would have tried. My fettuccine Bolognese was a detailed joy, yielding a world of varied delights in every bite. Even the radicchio and endive salad… one of those textured, flavorful events where you close your eyes and savor every each mouthful. I could go on and on… but I’m still busy savoring. Gorgeous setting, roomy comfort, delightful servers and employees… and the bank does not break. You’d pay 100 or 150% more in the city to even come close.“

“Sunrise Family Restaurant is hands down one of my favorite places to eat! I’ve been going there for a while now and it never disappoints. I like to call it a hidden treasure in the neighborhood. The minute you walk in, you feel like part of the family — the staff is so warm, welcoming, and truly wonderful. The menu is HUGE, the food is always delicious, and the prices are more than fair. If you’re looking for a new go-to spot, this is it! Do yourself a favor and stop in — you’ll feel right at home and leave with a full belly and a big smile!“

“We are extremely happy we chose this venue for our son's and daughter-in-law's Rehearsal Dinner (50 people) and Welcome Drinks (70 people) the night before their wedding. Kathleen, the proprietor, was a pleasure to deal with and was helpful with the planning. The staff was accommodating and delightful; everyone said their food was delicious and enjoyed the festive atmosphere. I highly recommend this restaurant for casual dining and special events!“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at this place, and I must say, it was an extraordinary experience from the start to finish. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with a perfect cozy charm. The staff were incredibly attentive and made us feel right at home. Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with freshness and flavors. Highly recommended this place. ?????“

“We love this place❤️ coming here for years and the food and cocktails never disappoint. Sad to hear about Sam’s passing. We loved chatting w her. Great food and company❤️“

“Had dinner there this past Sunday for Father’s Day! The service was amazing. The food was absolutely delicious. Will definitely be going back.“

“Excellent food and excellent service!“

“Both times I have taken my elderly handicapped mother here for lunch with family they were absolutely amazing to all of us,amazing staff and the food is always delicious and fresh,having the option to sit outside is lovely,and they are so so friendly and accommodating,thank you all for being so wonderful, a gem in Warwick for sure with great prices on fantastic food, the brioche rolls,the rueban,the burgers,the chicken wraps A++++++++ Everything you want in a hometown“

“Excellent cuisine, attentive staff and an overall cozy atmosphere in every room. This is fine dining without the pretentiousness that usually comes with it. The Old Stone House is, in my opinion, the finest dining experience in the entire county. 10 out of 10.“

“I had a wonderful 50th Bridgerton-themed birthday party, and The Atrium was the perfect venue for the occasion. The Atrium Room was absolutely lovely — filled with natural light, even on a cloudy day. The dinner was delicious, and the outdoor patio seating added a charming touch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making the evening flow smoothly. I couldn’t have asked for a better setting locally to celebrate such a special milestone!“

“The drinks were first rate, food were not only generous portions but also delicious and prepared well.
Our server should be commended for making our dining experience memorable.

Kid-friendliness: It was a fantastic experience thanks to our very attentive and experienced server. She immediately took our order for our starving children, made sure it came out first. We were able to order our dinner and appetizers and enjoy them thanks ro her. The drinks were first rate, food were not only generous portions but also delicious and prepared well.
Our server should be commended for making our dining experience memorable.“

“One of the best and most memorable breakfasts I have ever had. I can’t wait to return“

“This is the best food in Vernon served by the friendliest stuff at the best prices , t The Place is Amazing ,if you are new in the area or just visiting Vernon just stop by because there is no better place for breakfast lunch and dinner at the writing of this post. You don't have to trust me ( I traveled all in jersey and upstate NY for the last 6 years In a way I know as traveler and restaurant visitor) but don't take my word . Just go and see it for yourself ,"The feelings and the value is in the plates" as they say in the restaurant industry, You will be surprised, Be your own judge :)“

“TLDR: Top tier brisket. Nearly as good as Texas brisket and certainly best I have had in New Jersey thus far. The hidden restaurant in the middle of a garden is so quaint and peaceful, I recommend going for lunch or a cozy dinner. View of the surrounding hills is also amazing.

Quality of Food: I had no complaints about the food. The garden salad was refreshing and did not lack in its flavor. The brisket was AMAZING. If you look at my other reviews, you will find I am originally from the south and have frequented a few BBQ places in New Jersey, all of which have fallen short of what I have come to find as quality BBQ. This. Did. Not. Disappoint. The brisket was slightly marbled and melted in your mouth. I can only imagine the quality of the Rib Steak if the brisket was top notch. The cornbread was the only thing I could say was standard taste and quality.

Quality of Service: It was neither over-the top nor mediocre service. Seemed like a decent amount of young adults were waiting on tables. We stopped in for a quick bite before heading to a festival, but we had no issues getting our order taken, food delivered and check processed quickly.

Environment & Ambiance: Can't be compared to the other locations at the resort. The garden by itself is adorable and makes you feel like you're in a storybook. Looking out towards the hills provides a feeling of awe. The outside ambiance and cute tables and chairs makes you feel like you're joining Alice at a tea party.

Pricing and Concerns: It's certainly not cheap if you are ordering their higher priced options. However, that being said, it is most definitely worth every penny. Not to mention you're at a resort, so what would you expect besides expensive dishes? For a party of two you can keep it under $$$. Add drinks or an extra person and you're going over. No other concerns to note.

Comment and Recommendation: Yes! I recommend! If I didn't already make it obvious - go for the brisket!“

“Had dinner there last night. Service was great with special notice to out server Denise. Tipped her accordingly. Other staff removed used dishes in a timely manner. Meals arrived hot and portion size was perfect. This was our 4 visit to them and always had great dinning,“

“Finally made it to the new location today with hubby. We sat at the bar and spoke with John. I have to say what a beautiful place John has built here. Beers were cold and the burger was delicious. Spacious indoors and beautiful wrap around porch with seating. Definitely will be visiting again. Oh and plenty of parking. 🍻👏🍔“

“We can’t thank the Farm at Glenwood Mountain enough for how special they made our wedding day! Everything was absolutely perfect. The farm property is gorgeous and the barn’s cathedral ceiling is breathtaking. The food was incredible and is still being talked about, months after our wedding. Steve, Candice, and Stacy communicated with us every step of the way and made us feel so comfortable in our decisions, especially the few months and weeks leading up to the big day. We would recommend this venue to ANYONE and EVERYONE that is looking for a quality venue with staff and owners that care so deeply for their clients. We are eternally grateful for the opportunity they gave us to share such an important day with our closest family and friends, and are thrilled to have become part of the Farm Family! Highly recommend 100%!!!“

“4 of us went there last night not knowing reservations are recommended. We were able to be seated at 5:30 but told (not so nicely) that there was a reservation coming at 7 for this particular table! I almost walked out after that comment was made. Other than that, the food was delicious and our waitress was great!“

“My husband and I went for the first time last night & can't say enough good things about this place. It's fun and welcoming, with inexpensive food & drinks, and open LATE (and we're night owls). The music playlist is terrific, and the whole atmosphere just transported us back to the dive bars we'd hang out at in the city in the '90s & '00s (except cleaner). It's 20 minutes from our house, but it's 100% our new local.“

“Delicious breakfast and great service!“

“Great Food, great service! Nothing more to say.“

“Went to Limoncello’s for dinner for my husband’s birthday! The atmosphere, service and food were top notch! We will be back!!“

“Everything about this restaurant was amazing. The service was stellar. The wine pairings were perfect. And the food! Wow. Each plate was a work of art, yet it somehow tasted even better than it looked. It was a quiet evening when I was there and I loved chatting with the staff. The best part was that they clearly love Chef Aishling. It was a truly special experience.“

“Beautiful venue with a view, great staff and service, tasty food. Had a great time at a line dancing event there with Debbie and Beyond the Line, hope to be back soon!“

“This was our first dining experience at Westtown Fare Restaurant. To say we were very impressed is an understatement. Charming atmosphere, friendly and attentive service, combined with an outstanding meal all contributed to a pleasant and satisfying dinner. We will be returning. A+++“

“Shout out to Brittany for the great service and the food was great.“

“great beer, wine, atmosphere and food. do again anytime..thank you Robin for being such a welcoming and knowledgeable bartender!“

“Ordered Maria’s Rice con Dondulos and Pegnil. Wow! Keep an eye on their Facebook page for this occasional special! It is primo Puerto Rican fare!“

“A Great night at the Cove Castle last night. My girlfriend and I attended the History of Greenwood Lake event at the Cove and it was very enjoyable. Bob, Andrea, Chuck and the entire crew made the experience exceptional. The setting and view of the lake from the second floor dinning room was beautiful. The food was delicious and the presentation was excellent. Drinks were large and reasonably priced. In Bob's 5 years at the Cove Castle he has transformed the place into a fine place to dine, drink and enjoy top notch entertainment. Can't wait to return to "The place to go" on Greenwood Lake.“

“We had a wonderful dining experience! I ordered the filet mignon, and it was absolutely perfect—tender, juicy, and cooked exactly the way I like it. The seasoning was excellent and really brought out the flavor of the steak. Truly one of the best filets I’ve had.

My kids ordered burgers and fries, and they loved them! The portions were generous, the burgers were fresh and flavorful, and the fries were crispy and delicious. Even the pickle on the side was a nice touch.

The atmosphere was warm and inviting with candlelight on the tables, and the service was friendly and attentive. Overall, a fantastic meal for both adults and kids—we’ll definitely be back!“

“Been here twice and some dishes are really good and some fall flat. Cocktails are great, pretzels are great, oysters are great, the Nice salad is actually perfect. Garlic shrimp are meh, soba noodles are good, burgers are very good, desserts are great, Steak frites are overpriced and suck and was just burnt fry ends and really hard and tough steak that I brought home to my dogs.“

“Awesome dinner last night. We were in town from Kentucky Highly recommend“

“great atmosphere, drinks and food!“

“The owner and bartenders are great. Great wing specials, live music and more. Good food and drinks and a good price. Family atmosphere.“

“We went to Beer Pockets BBQ for lunch this Saturday and the food was out of this world! Donielle and John made the best suggestions! We can’t wait to come back! Thank you!“

“On October 23, 2023 we had a wonderful brunch at the George Inn the day after our son's wedding in the area for the guests. We had breakfast and lunch items on the buffet. Everything was fresh and delicious! Our hostess, Linda was fantastic. She made sure all or needs were met and the service was wonderful! Thank you George Inn and Linda for a great event!“

“Had an incredibly bizarre experience here where they said they could only see us at 7 PM and then the place was entirely empty except for us the whole evening. They also didn’t serve us the tavern menu until we specifically asked for it. Everything was delicious from a food standpoint, but one of the more bizarre dining experiences I’ve ever had.“

“We had the pleasure of dining at Delancey’s during our visit to Legoland, and it was a welcome change from the usual hotel fried fare. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the food was exceptional! We ordered the steak, Deanna’s Chicken, and the seafood bowl — and each dish was absolutely delicious. The staff was incredibly friendly and went out of their way to accommodate a few special requests. Our son was excited to try the seafood bowl but didn’t want the spicy marinara sauce. Our waitress took the time to explain the dish in detail and made sure she understood exactly what he wanted. The kitchen delivered it perfectly, and our son devoured every bite. Delancey’s was a highlight of our trip — we’d highly recommend it to anyone in the area looking for a great meal and outstanding service.“

“Great sandwiches! Delicious bread and they are big!! Highly recommend them“

“Sunflower Café in Goshen, NY, is a true gem that radiates warmth and charm from the moment you walk in. The atmosphere is inviting, with a cozy and rustic décor that immediately makes you feel at home. The staff is exceptionally friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant experience for every guest.

The menu is a delightful mix of fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that cater to a variety of tastes and dietary preferences. From their hearty breakfast options to their flavorful lunch dishes, every meal is prepared with care and creativity. The avocado toast and the blueberry pancakes are absolute must-tries!

Their coffee is superb, brewed to perfection and the perfect companion to their delicious pastries and desserts. Whether you're stopping by for a quick coffee or a leisurely brunch, Sunflower Café never disappoints.

Overall, Sunflower Café is a standout spot in Goshen, NY. Its combination of excellent food, welcoming ambiance, and outstanding service makes it a place you'll want to return to again and again. Highly recommended!“

“Fabulous pizza. Will definitely return.“

“Amazing experience at kink great food. The chicken and waffles are amazing.“

“The best veggie burger ever! love this place! I will be back! The staff are so friendly, great atmosphere! thankyou“

“We loved the Wienerschnitzel and beer. Service was excellent! Friendly staff! Thank you Tracy!“

“We arrived on a Wednesday afternoon and we were one of two customers in the restaurant. We waited at least 45 minutes for our meal. We didn’t complain because we were having a nice leisurely day apple picking. The food finally arrived my beans were watery as if they were cooked in water with no seasoning. OK I let it go because if the beans were the only thing wrong with the meal that’s not bad right. My husband got to the second half of his brisket sandwich and the brisket was petrified (Not my word I got it from another reviewer were but it fits perfectly). At this point we obviously mentioned some thing to our waitress. She agreed that the meat was not OK and said she would contact her manager who is not on location. She then came back and said the owner Laura who is the manager too who she called said she would give us 10% off. My husband was blown away by this response. He said it was a smack in the face which I completely agree. I then proceeded to add on all the rest of the issues we had that we did not say a word about at first. After the real issue that we wanted resolution from this is how they handled it? Are you kidding? Wait get ready for the best part. The bill came and they took 10% off of my husband‘s meal we got $1.60 off!!! Can you actually believe it? This restaurant is managed poorly and should go out of business. We spent $150 on a terrible lunch.“

“Wow it's a wow ,food was off the chain,i am on vacation and i will visit again before i go home ,the pancakes were so delious i ate them all,i would like everyone visiting to go eat their especially my home town persons Jamaicans Food /service and Atmosphere excellent.Thank you for your service Ihop i never get my server i am so sorry.Thanks again your customer Winsome M ROCHESTER.“

“Had a really great time at minerals hotel restaurant tonight. I was on a first date with a gorgeous man. At first I was nervous after reading some of the past reviews. However don’t let that fool you. The crab cake appetizer was delicious. The salmon entree was seasoned extremely well. This was my first experience here at this establishment. Hopefully we’ll make back again soon. Thanks again for a great start to a first date!!“