50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Port Washington

“The finest pizza on that side of Long Island, if you catch my drift. This establishment has a long-standing reputation, and it offers a unique coal-fired pizza experience that is hard to find elsewhere. As someone who is quite discerning about food, I was genuinely impressed when I opened the pizza box. I consider myself a pizza connoisseur, and this place undoubtedly ranks among the top ten in New York.“

“Exceptional food Exceptional service“

“Great customer service!“

“Amalfi is experiencing a spectacular change in its place and in its dishes, everything is great and feels very cozy...
Both the taste of the food and the presentation are excellent... The service is very personal and the waiters are charming, always happy to return to Amalfi ?“

“Omg amazing and fantastic place love the food drinks and drinks the atmosphere, plus the view is fabulous we have a great time very recommend ??????????“

“Awesome food like grandma made ! Beautiful friendly staff family couldnt be Nicer. Love the family run place“

“Raul the manager is such an angel!!! He made sure my order for pick up was perfect and also called as soon as it was out of the oven!!! Moreover he was just polite and conscientious and I felt the need to write a review in the first place!!! ? you have a quality manager in Port Washington New York“

“Best pizza in Port Washington.“

“Great Italian recipes, with wonderful Desserts. The Service is good, and the Restaurant is kept clean. Have eaten at DiMaggios numbers times. Never disappointed!! Recommended Highly.“

“We had the most incredible experience at Pietro’s of East Meadow — again! This was our second time celebrating our daughter’s birthday here, and it somehow keeps getting better every time. A huge shoutout to Oscar and the team there today, who were beyond helpful and so attentive. Oscar made everything feel effortless and was so intuitive — taking care of things before I even had to ask. That kind of service is rare and so appreciated. The girls had the BEST time, and I honestly can’t say enough good things about the staff and the whole experience. Thank you for making our girl’s day so special — we’ll be back again for sure!“

“5 Stars - Highly recommend.“

“The first pie I had from John at Fenice was the Detroit Red...which Tony picked up for me last week when i was at work...i finished the whole pie by just after midnight...but I had to go for the regular NY Cheese pie fresh from the oven. We scored one of the two tables there and were able to decide which of the other slices to bring home...it was like a pizza candy store. We didn't finish our pie so brought home two slices, and I wanted to try John's sicilian, I couldn't leave there without a Detroit Red slice and Tony wanted the multi cheese white pizza...every pizza we tried was perfect! something about the dough. The sauce. The cheese. The dough for the Sicilian and the Detroit Red was light and perfectly crunchy on the bottom. Flavor out of this world. We drove from White Plains just to try Pizza Fenice. worth the trip.“

“Great food and outstanding services. Highly recommended.“

“We went in specifically because it showed has being halal. Halal choices on our day was limited. Pizza overall was not bad.
* NOTE TO ALL LOOKING FOR HALAL. YOU HAVE TO SPECIFICALLY REQUEST HALAL AS THEY ALSO HAVE NON HALAL MEAT CHOICES.“

“Great service and Pizza to die for. My favorite spot for Queens“

“Great local slice shop. The regular slice was solid and the spicy vodka slice was really good because of the added chili peppers but I felt the vodka sauce itself was bland. I actually had to double check to make sure it was a vodka slice after the fact but either way it was a great slice of pizza. Took a pistachio bombolone home and it was absolutely spectacular. These are a must get and they have different flavors as well.“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“We had a wonderful meal and experience at Galleria of Merrick! The spicy rigatoni is a MUST! The pasta was cooked perfectly al dente and every bite was a flavor explosion. I love that they put a unique twist on traditional Italian dishes and you can really taste the difference of the quality, care and detail that went into each dish. They truly cook with love. If you’re looking for an excellent meal in a cozy atmosphere you must go to the Galleria of Merrick. We will definitely be back!!!!

Kid-friendliness: Cozy atmosphere that is family friendly.“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“Best pizza in NYC! And their fried calzones are a must 😊“

“Best Pizza in Queens they are very friendly, customer service is on point they are very fast to make ur order. 10/10 Recommend“

“First time being in New York, and I found this little place close to my hotel. You will not be disappointed! Mario and his father took good care of me, and the pizza was absolutely amazing. Perfect crunch, perfect flavor, and a small pizza is HUGE! 11/10! Highly recommend this spot if you’re in New Rochelle.“

“Great pizza and a comfortable dining experience!“

“Really good pizza ! ordered the upside down Sicilian and it was perfect. ordered it well done. The bottom was crispy and the dough was perfect ! Really good pizza sauce ! Also had a plain slice and it was very good! Fried calamari were Very good !“

“Best food and pizza around!“

“From the moment I stepped in on a sunday i was welcomed by a great service. niko the server of my table took care of us with some excellent recommendations. shortly the food was magnificent and the service top notch. 10/10 recommend this restaurant.“

“**Amore Pizza: A Slice of Authentic New York in Queens**

Tucked away in Queens, Amore Pizza is a true hidden gem for anyone in search of authentic New York-style pizza. From the moment you take your first bite, it’s clear this isn’t just another pizzeria—this is the real deal. The crust is everything a New York slice should be: perfectly thin, with a crispiness that crackles under the teeth, while avoiding the heaviness of doughy pies.

The sauce is simply outstanding—succulent and rich without being too sweet, striking a perfect balance that adds depth to every slice. It has just the right level of tang and a smooth consistency that complements the crisp crust underneath.

Then there’s the cheese: perfectly melted, with a gooey, stretchy texture that oozes with every bite. The blend of cheeses is spot-on, succulent and tasty yet firm with a creaminess and that pairs beautifully with the sauce. Each bite showcases the harmony between the sauce and cheese, making the pizza irresistibly delicious.

Cooked to absolute perfection, the pizza emerges from the oven with a golden-brown edge and an ideal texture from the first bite to the last. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this Queens institution offers a dining experience that reminds you why New York pizza is in a league of its own. If you’re craving a slice of the city’s finest, Amore Pizza should be your next stop.“

“My mother has been a patient for years. I'm very grateful/ lucky to have such an amazing/ caring/ dedicated professional team, helping my mother manage her pain with treatment/medications. Dr. Ji Han and the entire staff are amazing professionals, knowledgeable. Thank you for always making sure, that my mother receives the best care tailored to her specific medical needs.“

“Absofreakinlutely! Eh yo fuhgeddaboudit!“

“Frank’s pizza is an absolute slice of heaven! It was so good I forgot to take pictures of it. Service is very fast and efficient, the cashier Agostin is very polite and accommodating. My new fave pizza spot!!! Will definitely come back to try their pasta and other things in the menu.“

“Amazing pizzas Esp the Roman, go and try it. The owner Rob is great too!“

“They make the absolutely best Pizza 🍕 the GRAMMA PIZZA US JUST THE BEST!!!“

“Everyone was friendly and casual. The waitress and owner took time to speak with us. The Margherita pizza and meatballs appetizer were good. The tomato sauce was excellent.“

“Went here with my friends. We all enjoyed it. One of my friends mentioned this place being like subways(without Jared) but for pizza because of the options you have. I agree and honestly I can see the appeal. The pizza is definitely isn't the best in Queens but it's pretty decent and its very affordable. My buds shared a whole pie(plus some garlic breadsticks) and we spent around 25 dollars in total. Plus drinks are free if you are a student so that's a plus. If you are walking around the fresh meadows area, I'd give this place a try. Especially if you aren't alone.“

“Small pizza shop. Perfectly crispy dough/crust.
Ordered a slice of pep and mushroom.
Also, humble kind and respectful owner and workers.
An Asian elderly woman came in demanding food saying she did not have money. Employees handed her a slice and a cup of soda“

“Awesome staff and excellent pizza!“

“The second location is truth, and the quality is the same. You should definitely spend some money with this spot. Doesn't matter which location you go to, the food is amazing. The customer service is a 10 out of 10. I came in at 9 pm and received the same beautiful service as if it was opening time.

Vegetarian options: Vegan oxtail pizza“

“There pizza is so yummy. my son and daughter love it very much.“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Never tried the tomato pie until here and fell in love with it.“

“Ginos is #1. The staff, the service and the food. Their signature slices are the move. BBQ/BUFF CHICKEN, sicilian, vodka chicken roll, pinwheel, vodka slice, Margherita slice. Even the plain pie is delicious. VIP move grab yourself a Fresca can and enjoy!“

“Amazing food! We order from them every week! I love their salad pizza and the fact that they have gluten free options makes it even better! Their minestrone soup is delicious as well! The food is always piping hot & ready, we never have to wait! Their staff is super friendly and always get our order right! Highly recommend Rustica!!! 🙂💗“

“We have been using Garden City Pizza’s catering for our parties for years. The food is always amazing & outstanding service, especially from Greg. He is honest & really cares, as if it is for his own party. He always goes above and beyond to make our parties great and helps me figure out how much food is needed. Our guests are always complimenting the food and asking where it is catered from. Their prices are reasonable & they even delivered to St James!“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“The food is great! Tony and his crew are always there to make sure you get top notch service and a delicious meal.“

“This place used to have a small restaurant attached. It was quite pleasant to eat there. Now it is basically a take out place. Food is still good but eating in place was better than taking it home, especially if you live far.

Vegetarian options: Eggplant.“

“Legitimately the best pizza I ever had. I look forward to every pie she makes and I’ve never had one I didn’t like! The calzones and cannolis are ridiculously good too. 11/10 every day“

“Very good pizza we buy pizza only there and good price“

“Vinny's is the go-to for great food, good quality, friendly service, at affordable price. Love penne alla vodka & mozzarella sticks! Support a local family business. Go to Vinny's!“

“Best pizza in town.. highly recommended 👍🏼“

“Overall, this place is great. Food is good and staff is friendly. Be prepared for the tip though. Not their fault - many restaurants are doing this these days. Still, the food is awesome. Get the grandma pizza as others say. Falafel platter is great but they should add 1-2 more pieces of bread. Food is kosher, still tastes amazing. Clean spot if you want a nice restaurant to go to near St. John’s and Cunningham Park. Left feeling full, but satisfied. Well done.“