50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Rockaway Park

“Their logo “America’s Freshest Ice Cream” is so true. So delicious that we get some irrespective of the weather. Satisfaction guaranteed, and the staff are friendly and patient. I finally remembered to take a picture of the cone before I finished it.“

“Delicious and so happy they have vegan coconut so my whole family can enjoy!“

“Wow. Brand new, friendly, great business in a great neighborhood, Prospect Lefferts Garden. Would have been great if it was just good, but omg it is honestly the BEST ice cream I’ve had in Brooklyn. Awesome, creative new flavors every week. Yesterday’s was malted ice cream with chopped malted-milk balls. Also mint ice cream made with mint leaves. Another made with honey that also had some chili heat (forgot the name)—all amazing. Go now before you can’t get in.“

“A fabulous and delicious dining experience in Brooklyn! If you want food that has depth of flavor as well as refined technique in an environment that is warm and welcoming please check out this restaurant! Good for date night or just hanging out with a group of your friends! Highly recommend everything on this menu!“

“Delicious yogurt great atmosphere ❤️“

“Good cakes and very friendly staff.“

“Friendly staff and great service. Delicious! Definitely going back again.“

“The Best Thai-Food anywhere...#Period“

“Went for brunch! The food was fantastic..especially the roasted potatoes and banana bread. The staff was so friendly!! Loved it!“

“il vero gelato italiano, il migliore gelato in assoluto! Un'eccellenza!“

“Best ice cream and desserts ever!!!“

“I needed a cake for my son's birthday and instead of having me come back the next day, it was done in 30 minutes! Thanks for the rushed order! My son will be very happy once he sees it tomorrow 😊. This is just the photo because I'm hiding the cake at his grandma's house, but it looks exactly like the pic“

“Absolutely the best ice cream I've had in Brooklyn. So far, we've tried grape nut, guava, and Irish moss. All amazing. Are the staff going to gush over you? Maybe not, but they will give you excellent homemade ice cream at a very reasonable price and in a decent size. The guava tastes like fresh guava, and the Irish moss tastes like Christmas: so good.“

“I love this little ice cream shop. Feels very nostalgic and vintage. I didn't even get a strange look from the cashier when I asked if small was the smallest size they had. I fully knew it was a weird question, but she was very nice about it. Recommend the galactic ube flavor. I was skeptical of it being made from yams, but just trust me on this one (as a stranger from the internet that you'll probably never meet).“

“Best ice cream in Brooklyn. Both the boozy variety and the family friendly options.“

“Delicious for every age ❤️“

“We were in NYC for the weekend and I was told to check this place out. They definitely did not disappoint! Everything was delicious but now I need this in Buffalo….will always be on my list when we visit NYC!“

“Wonderful time such a calm relaxing area,“

“Vegan strawberry matcha is so fab & be sure to get the sugar cone (the only vegan cone) 😋

Van Leeuwen is my go-to spot for vegan ice cream! They always have such delicious & creative flavors!

Bonus points on this location being huge & so cute inside! 💕🌸💗“

“Fruitti Yummi frozen yogurt is sooo good. There aren’t a large variety of fro-yo flavors, but they have all the solid ones here, and a large array of toppings.It is a self-serve location (and they’re covid conscious), providing you with gloves and hand sanitizer to use before serving yourself. I liked that, it made you feel as though the establishment cares about keeping covid at bay.The place is squeaky clean by the way. Everything is tidy, the machines are clean (been to some spots with dirty ones), and the area for toppings was so perfectly organized that me and my boyfriend barely wanted to touch it lol.There was one young lady at the register over-seeing everything, who gave us a friendly greeting when we came in, so that was nice.Other than that there’s not too much to say about a frozen yogurt spot, but this is definitely one of the better locations. You can tell the difference in the quality of flavor, so I highly recommend stopping by.“

“HI, EDDIES IS BY FAR THE BEST ICE CREAM SHOP IN ALL OF NYC!! NOTHING COMPARES, NOTHING. THE FLAVORS ARE SPOT ON, GENEROUS PORTIONS, GREAT STAFF. NO WONDER ITS BEEN OPEN FOR 100 YEARS. WENT TO ICE CREAM SHOPS IN MANHATTAN, GOOD ICE CREAM BUT NOTHING LIKE EDDIES!! A DEFINATE MUST VISIT FOR ANY ONE, JUST CALL BEFORE GOING TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE OPEN, SOMETIMES HAS STRANGE HOURS. BUT WELL WORTH A VISIT, I GIVE IT TEN STARS!!!!“

“Want to see more of my experience? Check out my Instagram @lawyer.traveler.dreamer! 🍦🔥 Ample Hills Creamery – A Chocolate Lover’s Dream! 🔥🍦 I stopped by Ample Hills Creamery in NYC, and their Death by Chocolate Hot Chocolate is a must-try! 🍫✨ Here’s why it’s amazing: 🍦 Served in a crispy, edible chocolate-dipped cup with nuts or spearmints. ☕️ Filled with rich hot chocolate and flavored syrup. 🍡 Topped with toasted marshmallow whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and edible gold—delicious! 🤩 We also tried their ice cream and loved it! 🍨 Here’s what we got: 💜 Egg Carton Sampler – 6 flavors to taste it all! 🍦 Waffle bowl with 3 scoops – All for just $52! Our favorite flavors: 🍪 Cookie au Lait – Creamy and full of cookie goodness. 🥭 Underneath the Mango Tree – Sweet and tropical. 🍫 Death by Chocolate – Rich and perfect for chocoholics. 🍌 Banana Pudding – Smooth, creamy, and dreamy. If you’re looking for the best ice cream in NYC, head to Ample Hills Creamery!“

“Great local frozen yogurt spot. We appreciate that there are always sugar-free flavors available. And usually a dairy free option. Most yogurt places around us only offer no sugar added, and are limited to one flavor if available. There also are sugar-free and gluten-free muffins. The scones are amazing. And there’s a bunch of frozen bagel options, cookies and brownies available. Plenty of toppings, for sugar-free they have chocolate chip chips and hot fudge. There’s also indoor and outdoor seating. Staff is friendly, fast and helpful.“

“The snow cone flavors are amazing here. Fresh, great size, and delicious. One of the best West Indian snow cones I’ve had in NY. My kids and I love stopping in during the summer. We visit at least 7times for the summer. She also sells other items as well which you can take a look at while there getting a snow cone“

“the original one and only ice cream Italian ice stand way before Luigi way before Guido's a local favorite quality products made fresh“

“This is one of the best places to have breakfast. The honey buns are amazing!! The mocha is my absolute favorite drink there. I can’t wait to get the homemade soft serve when the weather heats back up!! Great customer service too. Everyone has to try Dolly’s Coffee Shop!!“

“I want to say a huge thank you to Sam at Cinnabon Carvel for the beautiful cake for my grandma! She absolutely loved it. The cake was perfect, and the service was just as amazing. Sam was so friendly and kind, which made the whole experience even better. I’ve already recommended this location to others and will definitely be back. Thank you again!“

“Pro tip: Get all the soft serve twists!! Literally every single flavor is a must try. Couldn’t pick a favorite and the best part about it… I didn’t need to limit myself to just one. How often can you get horchata, mango, pistachio, raspberry, vanilla, and chocolate in one soft serve cup? Dreamery BK lives up to its name. It is a dreamy spot in Brooklyn with cute knick knacks and people all around.“

“very nice staff,love the milkshakes here!“

“The ice cream is excellent, but they need to bring back bread and roses. ;)“

“Its such a clean place,with delicious flavors and awesome staff�����. I always recommend it too my friends.“

“todo muy rico. las pastas . Los helados .todo“

“Everything is so yummy and its only $3 for ice cream and its vary big I love it so much ❤ !

EDIT: 2025, Sooo! With inflation and all it will be around 4-5 dollars for ice cream but it's still a good price and a quality place! ♡

EDIT: They changed it again 5-7 dollars now, Honestly it's still somehow the cheapest ice cream place around—but at this point, who needs ice cream?“

“This has to be one of the best-named ice cream stores I have ever encountered: inviting, memorable, potent. Those adjectives apply to its ice creams, too, which come in all sorts of intriguing flavors. The consistency leans toward the icier end of the spectrum, but that is nice sometimes, refreshing. I went with fried apple pie, and I did not regret it. Intriguingly, all the ice cream was pre-scooped, which makes it easy to grab and go. I hope they expand. We need this kind of invention in more places!“

“I frequent this location often with my children because my toddler LOVES their pistachio ice cream. She convinced me to try it and it really is that good. My favorite from this store is the coffee ice cream. Hits everytime. The store is very small but always looks clean. There’s not much organization when it comes to the line so they usually just ask “who’s next”. All workers that I’ve interacted with have been pleasant. I’ve never had a negative interaction with a worker so I’d say their customer service is great.

Parking: A lot of people double park. It’s paid metered parking and spots are usually taken.“

“At first I thought my wife poisoned me.... And than it slowly dawned on me that it was probably fruity yummy from.earlier... but my God it was delicious! The whole time I was doubled over and writhing in pain all I could think about was the vanilla flavored yogurt with the m&m sprinkles. It really burns!!.... I can't wait to go back again and get myself another yogurt.... As soon as I'm able to walk.“

“Amazing first time experience, the staff is very friendly and helpful when choosing what to get. They explain everything and suggest what you may like. It’s all really fresh too no powdered or anything they chop up the fruits and veggies right in front of you before they blend it. Highly recommend if you want real fresh and great tasting juices/smoothies 😄“

“I come here almost every week and I’m kind of obsessed with it. The decor is wildly eccentric — there’s an ice cream shop setup that never seems to be active, these indoor-patio-type structures, and a whole bar world in the back I’ve still never explored. You even pay at what looks like a candy-shop counter. It’s just fantastic.

It’s also almost always empty, which I truly don’t understand, because the food is great. The menu is mostly classic Mexican fare, but nearly every dish I’ve tried has some unique little twist that shows they’re really putting in the work.

I’ve gotten pretty enamored with this place. Highly recommend checking it out.“

“Workers are kind of awkward cuz they're all teens except for the manager, which is okay.
The ice cream is amazing though. And they piled that stuff on. I couldn't finish it and it took me half an hour to even get halfway through it.
I ordered a small vanilla cup with no toppings.
It's far cheaper than Cold Stone Creamery and almost has the same aspects.
If you loved Mr. Softee's ice cream growing up, those ice cream trucks always going around the block, than this ice cream is for you.“

“yum! unlimited samples...very nice sundae for the birthday boy!“

“I discovered this place completely by accident — not through Google reviews, but simply while walking by and looking for something to grab for breakfast. And now, my absolute favorite bagel is right here.

The combination of flavors is incredible — I honestly haven’t found anything similar anywhere else. Everything tastes unique and perfectly balanced.

I also absolutely love their lavender latte, and the pistachio one is just as amazing. This spot has truly become one of my favorites!“

“I ordered the rolled ice cream for my daughter’s birthday and we ordered the banana pudding flavor, the candy flavor and the Oreo flavored rolled ice cream. They were all very delicious. I highly recommend. You have options of toppings like cereal or chocolate chip or whipped topping etc and also for the type of syrup that you want on top .There are lots of toppings to choose from. I can’t wait to try them all?

Vegetarian options: Lots of vegetarian type options from the plant based ice cream to the toppings eg, fruit loops, cookie crisps, dark chocolate chips etc

Kid-friendliness: Cereal flavors for kids to choose from“

“Absolutely delicious!!! This has now become my spot. I ate the 2 scoops so fast I forgot the flavors lol. I had one scoop with coconut and the other scoop was chocolate fudge & peanut butter. Did I mention it was delicious? I should add that I haven’t pulled off in my car after eating it. I had to leave this review first. Highly recommend!!“

“Food was good; we were 8 women, I ordered a fresh salad but it was so expensive (I ordered a regular container for 1 person-which included lettuce, 2 different colored peppers, olives, tomatoes and a few other items added- it was very expensive....“

“We went there to check out the new spot. We told them we were going to dinner but just wanted to look. They gave us samples and the gelato was exceptional! We left with a pint of biscoff lotus gelato that was so good. Really rich flavor and the pint had ribbons of biscoff caramel. I can’t wait to go back. Such friendly and patient staff too and a small business!“

“Lo mejor es una delicia me encanta este lugar y sus atenciones perfectas“

“I can't get enough! Thanks for a great summer!“

“This place has it all such an amazing assortment of freshly made treats. They also have shakes, frozen, yogurts, and toppings galore. I always pass with my family as my kids love the frozen yogurt and the self serve that they can make their own delicious Sunday. I suggest you stop by give the place a try if you haven’t been there before. Thanks for reading my review you could also give me a follow on Facebook.“

“I got the regular size cup with Coney Island custard and Cookie Monster. The custard was amazing, it had a nice taste of condensed milk that wasn’t too heavy. The gelato was also very silky. Cookie Monster was delicious too, it had a cotton candy taste and the cookies inside made for a good sort of chocolatey taste too go along with it. The only problem I really have is that the cups are too small for the portions given. The second we went outside the icecream started melting very very rapidly. It felt like a race against time to shovel each scoop into our mouth because it was dripping outside the cup onto the ground, our clothes, and making our hands sticky. I feel like the portion size was perfect, any less icecream and it was wouldn’t feel worth the eight dollars, it’s just the cup sizes.“

“The young woman behind the counter is absolutely amazing!! Then we tasted the fun and exciting sweet treat with fresh mango, tamarind candy, Tajin and delicious pineapple and delectable mango ice cream. The dessert was presented like a work of art and it was a taste explosion! This is a must try for the whole family!!!

Kid-friendliness: So much fun for both little kids and big kids too!!!“