Bagels Restaurants near Rye Brook, NY

“I don’t understand how you make the bagels so perfect? Just picked up a dozen for mother’s day. Traveled south 1 hour and 10 there and back, totally worth it! No better bagels to me. Very light crunch on the outside and perfectly soft, doughy and chewy on the inside.“

“Huge menu! Everything you could dream of! Terrific selection of deli favorites and salads. Food is prepared very well and comes out quickly. Order was 100% correct. Very kid friendly restaurant. They gave us little bags with crafts for the kids at the table. They have high chairs. Waitress was great. They also sell hand dipped chocolate at the deli counter which is delicious.“

“My husband and I live in Stamford, CT, but we always make the drive to Brooklyn Bagel Company because the bagels are just that good. The shop has plenty of seating, lots of parking, and great coffee and pastries if bagels aren’t your thing. Highly recommend this spot if you love a true New York bagel 😊“

“This neighborhood deli is packed with character and options. I ordered a classic lox and scallion cream cheese—fresh, briny, and generously portioned. The scallion cream cheese had the perfect tang and herbal kick, complementing the lox beautifully. I also grabbed a cup of their Oreo pudding—rich, sweet, and creamy without being overly heavy. A nostalgic treat done right.

Service was friendly and warm—the staff took time to introduce different menu items and made the experience feel personal. Between the massive chalkboard menus, fresh baked goods, and deli staples, there’s clearly something for everyone.“

“The staff is incredibly kind here always. My mom and I came from NY and when we got here everything was sold out for pick up orders. The staff member asked us to wait while they did the math and saw if there was any leftover. He so kindly brought the bagels and spreads to our car and was INCREDIBLY generous. I have never been treated so kindly from a business or employee before. Thank you so much PopUp Greenwich for your kindness, thoughtfulness, and generosity. We will be back for many many many visits. :)“

“good morning I'm visiting for the long weekend your business and bagels came highly recomended.from dear friends I am visiting took home 4 dozen for coworkers friends and loved ones now that I have your FB page I will be back to purchase more of your delicious bagels once you taste a Scarsdale.bagel all others are just bagels thank you for what you do you do it very well blessings to you and yours“

“It’s a little corner bagel shop and this was superb at many directions.
I had just a quick breakfast and mine was a bagel with CC and another one with butter.
One for later obviously but with a coffee add up only to $8.
Bagels were how old school type was crispy and chewy.
Just a regular cup of coffee tasted so good much better than trendy chais like Starbucks.
Totally satisfied with the food and drink and services by the guys.
Maybe the owner.“

“Popped in while passing through, fantastic choice! Great selection of options for bagels and sandwiches, and had a full espresso machine for coffee orders. The lox bagel was so good, we ordered a dozen bagels to go too. Despite it being busy on a Monday morning, the service was efficient and friendly. There isn’t much seating inside, but great for pick up and go“

“Favorite bagel spot 😁 I don’t think there’s any place better.“

“"Still crazy after all these years"! The closest you will find to the memories of the once upon a time NYC bagel. This is the real deal, don't miss out on the holy grail of bagels at Sammy's! Bonus, very efficient and friendly staff.“

“Good service, and AMAZING bagels, they came quick even though place was packed, and the portions were definitely big for their price, the quality of the ingredients is also evident as it tasted AMAZING. Stayed at Eastchester area with my dad and brother, came the first time to this shop out of curiosity, had to eat the bagel in the car as it was SO GOOD, then we came back 3 more times , tried philly cheesesteaks, the BLT and a couple more flavours, they were ALL amazing, i 1000% recommend this place and will be bringing people here“

“Casual, with just a few tables—simple, but Onorio, the gentleman at the counter, takes your Sunday breakfast to the next level. The bagels are delicious, and his personal touch makes you feel welcome and at home. This place is a must-visit.“

“I think it’s one of the best bagels in upper Westchester. I grew up in Queens NY and think most bagel shops are terrible but this one gets my business when I’m in the mood. Easy to park and grab breakfast. The service is usually quick even with a long line.“

“While there is no shortage of bagel shops in lower Westchester, Bagels & More in Hartsdale stands out head & shoulders above other establishments because of the high quality & taste of its bagels (both standard & whole wheat), and availability of a variety cream cheese.“

“When we wake up early enough on a Saturday, my husband and I like to come here for breakfast. Best bagels in town. Highly recommend the everything bagel with bacon basil cream cheese. Friendly staff, delicious food, and plenty of parking in the back.“

“Bagels by Sofia is seriously one of my favorite places. The bagels are always fresh and so good, but what really makes it special is the service. Everyone who works there is so friendly and welcoming — you can tell they actually care about the customers. They’re quick, they remember you, and they always make the vibe feel warm and positive. It’s the kind of spot that just puts you in a good mood. Couldn’t recommend it more!“

“Love your location in port Chester“

“They have gluten free bagels and a clean bathroom in addition to being a good normal bagel shop. They were busy but move very fast... would repeat if in the area.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free bagels available, but a high cross contamination environment obviously.“

“Such s cozy place.. Everything is fresh. The staff is so nice and friendly..Great atmosphere“

“The only reason why people are giving it one star because they had to wait .....because it gets crowded and there is a lot of people there working so if they couldn't wait a minute......then you know what.... they don't need to eat there but the place is excellent I don't know what they talking about..... they need to stop being haters. But what can you say with all the liberals who live around there!!!“

“Love that they make the bagels fresh every single morning. I’ve been a customer here for a couple years now and I’ve never been disappointed with my orders.The ladies who work there make my day with how happy they look to see me and chat with me. Cash only definitely makes it less convenient, but they’ve got an ATM right there and it’s worth the minor trouble. Anyone who says the food is pricey has no clue what they’re talking about - average sandwich is like 7-8 dollars. That’s far cheaper than what you’d get in NYC which is like 20 minutes away, especially for the quality. I’ve only sat to eat a couple times, but it’s about what you’d expect from a small bagel place. It’s not the best for a proper sit down meal, but it feels cozy in there and I’ve struck up conversations with other customers a few times. All in all, this place is a must try, you’ll get addicted to those bagels, they must have some secret formula.“

“Great spot to kill time and meet up with friends. Open, airy ambience, sophisticated and simple decor. Great coffee, great cakes, great empanadas.“

“Perfect location with a municipal parking lot next to the cafe. GCBC bagels are as close to the bagels I grew up eating in Forest Hills. They are soft but slightly chewy. Perfect texture! When I go early in the morning after they've taken them out of the oven, I don't even ask them to toast it. Sometimes I have to wait in line because they're busy but that's a good sign. There are regulars who come every morning and read newspapers while having their bagels. It's a neighborly place with excellent bagels.“