16 Best Bars near Shelter Island

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!“

“One of our go to spots for a casual relaxed time with excellent food and service and quiet enough to be able to hear friends across the table. The special halibut entree was excellent and very lightly prepared over greens, mushrooms and cauliflower puree. One friend had a salmon rice bowl and another a strip steak and fries. Something for everyone. Firecracker shrimp always a favorite to share and the profiterole is a must.“

“So this is a Pub that is Cash Only, and shares it’s parking lot with neighboring businesses. So parking may not be close by. As you enter you’ll notice that The Bar Area is placed against the wall to the right. There’s about 6 beers on tap with plenty of bottled beers and canned beers in-stock, but they don’t serve food here. At the time of my visit, there was Grilled Cheese for $1. The place has a small interior is ideal for small to midsize groups of people to attend. The even have outdoor seating for larger crowds. They offer an ATM, Arcade Game such as Cards, Dart Board, Old School Jukebox, One Flat Screen TV, Popcorn Maker, and a water station. There’s 2 unisex restrooms for use and smoking is done outside the building in the back, that has tables and chairs to sit on. This place has a fun but more of a laid back atmosphere about it and is definitely a local hangout bar, but it’s worth checking out.“

“Favorite place on north east end🫶🏽“

“Beautiful place! Definitely a must. Gabby was so knowledgeable and welcoming. The bar itself is gorgeous with copper everywhere. I kept looking around finding new details to appreciate. And the live music in the afternoon was perfect. Can’t wait to return.“

“Service was excellent. Food was delicious“

“I have always enjoyed this restaurant. They are offering a great deal for a weekend in September in the Hamptons. $45 3 course prix fix. Excellent choices on the menu and every weekend the menu changes. Our food was delicious. Good portion sizes. The Apple Tart Tatin was excellent. And as an added bonus, they gave us a baguette when we left. The restaurant was full. I wish more restaurants would offer great deals like this, especially on the weekends. I hope Armin and Judy continue their weekend prix fix throughout the winter.“

“Gente amable Muy buena atención Rápidos en la entrega“

“Wonderful first time dining here!“

“Good food, friendly spot, big fan. Been coming here for years. Here's my 1 suggestion: for the takeout ...why not offer online ordering? I have to call for take-out, which usually results in the line being busy (in the summer). If I can't get through I have to go elsewhere, which stinks because I live close by. Then, if I do get through, have to provide my credit card info, which is very 2006. Maybe ownership simply doesn't need the takeout biz and prefers it this way, and that's fine, but remains frustrating nonetheless. Just my .02 cents.“

“Bobby D. was a great host! We loved him and the food and drinks were great!“

“We decided to head over to grab a cocktail ? after dinner. The Black Llama is in Stirling Square. This lounge is situated in the same square of the 1948 pizzeria, American Beach Hotel and Restaurant and the Tree bar. The evening was absolutely perfect. We went on a Friday night and it was a good mix of people at each place I mentioned. The Black Llama had a DJ playing music ?. I enjoyed it. I believe the type of music the DJ was playing is Electronic Dance Music - EDM. The drink menu is unique which is what I expected at this lounge bar. The waiter was super helpful and offered up suggestions. A relaxed atmosphere. We sat outside but I took a look at the inside and it looked great. Our cocktails were delicious. Also, for those who might not want alcohol, they do mocktails. I will go back ! It is a special spot.“

“Excellent from beginning to finishing my meal. Joseph our waiter was spot on recommending the wine and specials. We enjoyed our meals ,water view and best service. This is our go to restaurant when we visit Greenport. See you next trip in from Queens.“

“We had an amazing dining experience at Minnow. The best oysters and the BEST local fish! The servers were very attentive and the Chef Ana (originally from Venezuela) came to our table to chat and she was just wonderful Highly recommend it! There was also a guy playing the guitar on the deck at sunset which was very pleasant! We are going to go back for sure : )“

“Great atmosphere and food. Top shelf Mexican cuisine!!!“

“Absolutely delicious 😋 very good place to eat.“