15 Best Cafes near Shelter Island

“This beautiful spot is THE culinary highlight of Shelter Island. From breakfast burritos to burgers, to coffee and smoothies, this place can do it all and do it well. They are beyond welcoming and open to everyone that’s walks in. Since moving away I’ve missed their hospitality and food more than ever. So go in and have a try they are definitely worth it!!“

“We had an awesome lunch in the back table by the water. HUGELY recommend the turkey meatball pesto sandwich on a baguette, the French toast, the truffle chocolates, we liked the pastries as well.

Sounds like some 1 star reviewers had a bad interaction with the owner and her treatment of her staff. We didn’t experience that so don’t know. We thought the staff was great.“

“I got something I didn't ask for with my order (I think I paid for it) we ate it anyway it was pretty good. The bagels could have been toasted alittle darker, I thought it wasn't toasted at all when I bit into it but then I saw a very feint light brown on the edge of the bagel so it must have been toasted just not enough for me. I'd still go here again, I'll just make sure everything is in order before leaving.“

“the best coffee very good“

“The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!“

“We worked with Pip's to cater brunch for the day after our wedding. Their food was such a hit with our guests and their team was amazing in executing things seamlessly. We loved working with the Pip's team and are so grateful they could cater such a delicious brunch for our guests. Anytime we're out on the North Fork going forward, we'll be showing up at the cafe for an iced coffee, their killer biscuits and the best yogurt parfait in town!“

“We had the repast here for my Mother and I cannot say enough positive things about this place. Jaci took care of all the details and planned a beautiful lunch. Jaci was so accommodating and kind, the food was fantastic and the staff were attentive and very kind. It was so nice to have some of the burden lifted during such a difficult time. This is the place to go if you are looking for something special!“

“Great cozy spot in Southold!

It’s a little further away from my parent’s house than some other options but we try to make it out here a couple times a year.

This time I got the corned beef hash and I loved it! They make their corned beef really crispy how I like and their potatoes are flavored really well! They also have super reasonable prices for the area.

They fill up quick so if recommend getting there on the earlier side if you are able to!“

“This is an amazing place. A little nondescript building with a gravel lot on Maple Lane in Bridgehampton, NY. It’s always busy. You’ll see workers, contractors, local folk, film directors and billionaires all in the same line to get some of the best coffee on earth. It’s a sight to behold.

They make the smoothest and tastiest Americano. My favorites to take home to grind are espresso and Bonacker. They bring in top notch pastries too on the morning. Get there early. They go quick.

When you’re there take a walk around and admire the artwork.

My favorite place.“

“best scrambled eggs around. Just overall favorite spot.. Outside seating charm“

“Thank you for catering our brunch of bagels, muffins and danish. Everything was delicious and all were raving about it. Thank you Susan and crew.“

“Everything on the menu is first-rate. We had a great time at Minnow at the Galley Ho. Andrea Tese has done a great job with the restaurant.“

“They have the best coffee! The deli is fresh and inviting! It’s such an awesome place to grab the most amazing food for a bite to eat or take in In a picnic basket to the beach!“

“Todo es muy rico todo y buenísimo todo la atención 👍“