18 Best Italian Restaurants near Shelter Island

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!“

“What an exceptional dining experience we had! Every dish was exquisite, with the Korean ribs standing out as particularly delightful. But what truly sets this place apart is the exceptional service. Maroni truly stands out for its top-notch food, attentive service, and inviting atmosphere. If you're seeking a memorable culinary journey, Maroni is a must-try option that won't disappoint.Special tip: Don't miss their sushi menu on Tuesdays - you can either dine in or order takeout.“

“The food, vibe and service were all A+ at Alpina. Everything we tried from the Swiss beer, to the entrees to the desserts was excellent. Extremely fresh food, kind and attentive staff and very cool and cozy atmosphere inside. Already can’t wait to go back!“

“"Leon1909 - A Culinary Masterpiece!"My experience at Leon1909 was nothing short of extraordinary. From the moment I stepped through the doors, I was enveloped in an ambiance that seamlessly combined sophistication with warmth. The restaurant's elegant decor, reminiscent of a bygone era, immediately set the stage for an unforgettable dining journey.The menu at Leon1909 is a testament to culinary excellence. Each dish is crafted with meticulous attention to detail, showcasing the freshest, highest-quality ingredients prepared with innovative techniques. Whether you're a connoisseur of fine dining or simply appreciate exceptional food, Leon1909 promises to tantalize your taste buds and exceed your expectations.Every bite was a symphony of flavors, perfectly harmonized to create a culinary masterpiece. From the delicate variations of appetizers to the succulent mains and decadent desserts, each dish left me craving more. The presentation was also impeccable, elevating the dining experience to new heights.Complementing the exquisite cuisine is the impeccable service at Leon1909. The staff exudes professionalism and genuine warmth, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and pampered throughout their visit. From recommendations on wine pairings, cocktails to accommodating dietary preferences, their attention to detail was truly commendable.Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking an indulgent night out, Leon1909 is the ultimate destination for discerning diners. Immerse yourself in a culinary journey unlike any other, where every moment is savored and every bite leaves a lasting impression. Trust me, a visit to Leon1909 will leave you counting down the days until your next reservation.“

“great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious“

“Delicious! We like to explore the east end in the off season. Plentiful hiking and no crowds. We popped in right before a traditional dinner time and were treated like we were regulars. Started off with pillowy garlic knots that were extra garlicky. Our meals were top notch: huge portions of salmon that were perfectly cooked. Our son had spaghetti topped with huge meatballs. Almost too stuffed for dessert but we couldn't pass up the chocolate chip cookies we saw when we walked in. Couldn't have been happier with a nice end cap to the weekend.“

“The pizza was great. The beverage was different but okay. The atmosphere was unique. Parking was good and I was there when it wasn't busy. Not to forget that Andrew was great. I would visit again when I am in the area. The grandma square...just say I went back up for another square.“

“Best restaurant in Greenport! Try the Sea scallops next time you come in - amazing-Ask for Jackie or Loranda at the bar and Brenda is the best hostess- see you there!“

“We love the spot. The pizza is delicious, I had the mushroom gorgonzola for the first time and it was phenomenal. Super fresh and made the order. The garlic bread is wicked. AND the steak was SO GOOD! Its all good. Everything I’ve had here is great.“

“Great service! Huge portions of old school red sauce Italian. We enjoyed the garlic knots, baked clams, meatballs, lasagna, chicken special, frutti di mare with linguini and the ribeye (huge).Topped off with Italian cheese cake and lava cake. Wow!“

“Ordered a cheese pie for delivery and it was more affordable than the other nearby options. From placing the order to the delivery driver the staff was very friendly. Plus the pie was delicious! Added a picture of the box because it's a nice touch!“

“Ponte is a smart looking sophisticated restaurant; sharp as a tack. The service personnel were on the mark; responsive and Cordial. The food is wonderful ! The presentation of the whole grilled Branzino was breathtaking and it was perfectly cooked; fresh and flavorful. Great pizza, veal and linguine vongole were totally enjoyed. I also ordered a 5 color salad that was perfectly dressed, festooned with avocado and fresh burrata. And, the fresh house made bread is slamming. I was lucky enough to sneak a taste of my son's panna cotta and wished I'd ordered one myself; next time for certain. And on a rainy January evening, the place was popping so you know they've got it right. See you there!“

“Had the pleasure of my wife and I returning to one of our Islands restaurants, Isola last night and was really pleased. It’s nice to begin thinking of enjoying local restaurants after a summer of visitors, guests and other obligations. Really enjoyed the Cioppino with pasta. Sauce was wonderful, rich but not heavy and overbearing. It was filled with seafood, including shrimp, octopus, squid and shellfish. Totally enjoyable nice portion, so that I had enough to take home for lunch the next day. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the swordfish special served over various vegetables. It was prepared to perfection and the caper sauce complemented the entire dish. Really nice place to enjoy that is “affordable”.“

“I order pizza here pretty regularly but last night I placed an order. They forgot a slice- which they refunded when I called. And I should have checked. However I got the baked pasta trio and the ricotta cheese in the stuffed shells and manicotti and lasagna was sour. It must have gone bad. So that $20 dish was thrown in the garbage. The marina very bland. I admit I was surprised. I chalk it up to life but hope someone checks that cheese because I wasn’t the only one that tasted it. Didn’t feel like calling again to complain after calling during dinner to say I never got a slice. Service is always friendly and prompted. Sometimes it’s busy and some of the reviews here show that they have never worked in a restaurant, especially after 2020- it stresses me out going anywhere. I can’t imagine how it is dealing with these fragile attitudes day in and day out. The ladies up front definitely work hard.“

“Amazing food…gorgeous design Loved everything about the vibe here❤️“

“It is truly a delight to find a place affordable, and also be able to get large portions of homemade foods. Everything I've eaten there is delicious. My favorites are the roasted artichokes and the most delicious focaccia bread. The service has always been and still is excellent. They have my food ready on time when I order by phone to go and they are always polite and kind. Everything that you would want and expect to have from a local takeout and even more. I highly recommend !!!! D.A. Powell“

“Delicious and great atmosphere“

“I stop here frequently either before or after my visit to vineyards. Sometimes we pick up a pie or two and head on out, sometimes a few slices in the way back. For Long Island it's good pizza. It's not NYC pizza but it's good. The specialty slices are stacked with goodness. Definitely worth stopping by.“