New American Restaurants near Shelter Island, NY

The Terrace at The Pridwin New American
81 Shore Rd, Shelter Island

“Amazing location, amazing venue staff us was impeccable however food options for lunch as the restaurant is on an island to have more of a seafood selection versus hamburgers steaks also the portion sizes portion size could be increased slightly for the lunch menu.“

3.5 Good32 Reviews
Vine Street Café American • $$$
41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island

Customers` Favorites

Hot Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
Spicy Tuna Tartare Tacos
Lobster Bouillabaisse
Crispy Calamari Salad
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Miso Glazed Salmon
Crispy Duck Confit
Rigatoni Bolognese
Grilled Fish
Skirt Steak

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!“

4.2 Good287 Reviews
Page Sag Harbor American • $$$
63 Main St, Sag Harbor - 5.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Local Peeko Oysters on the Half Shell
Charred Spanish Octopus
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Lacinato Kale Salad
Page Clam Chowder
Ahi Tuna Tartare
Crispy Calamari
Bouillabaisse
Coconut Cake
Lobster blt

“Great place. Really enjoyed the food the atmosphere and our waiter Sean was great. Good experience.“

4.6 Superb121 Reviews
4

Fresno

Fresno New American
11 Fresno Pl, East Hampton - 10.34 miles

“The food was great, service quick, professional and friendly . Very nice ambiance, classy place.“

4.4 Superb35 Reviews
Bell & Anchor Seafood • $
3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 5.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Guava Baby Back Ribs w Baby Spinach & Pine Nuts
Old School Lobster Garganelli
Flat Iron Steak Frites
Home Port Chowder
Fish of the Day
Bouillabaisse
Caesar Salad
Almond Cake
Guava Ribs
Frito Misto

“Food and service was wonderful!“

4.7 Superb56 Reviews
Ellen's on Front American • $$
38 Front St, Greenport - 2.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Tea Brined Fried Chicken
House Smoked Whipped Ricotta
Long Island Chowder
Marinated Olives
Ellen’S Burger
Fish and Chips
Ellen
Lenz

“Very nice atmosphere staff n owners chef are the nicest people My daughter is an employee and we were invited to dinner there n no other job that my kids have done that for the family! Beautiful place n beautiful people! The food is amazing“

4.6 Superb109 Reviews
Nookies Pet Friendly • $$
1400 Silvermere Rd, Greenport - 2.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Koginut Squash
Donuts

“Great find! On a chilly winter night Nookies provided the perfect last minute (a rare occurrence, I believe) dinner for two with cool easy vibes and really yummy warming food.

Fun retro decor and neat off the beaten path spot in Southold area.

We also got a nice quick little tour of the motel and would love to stay here on our next visit out!

Will definitely be back!“

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
8

Almond

Almond American • $$$
1 Ocean Rd, Bridgehampton - 9.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sautéed Amagansett Greens
Steak Frites and 2 Sides
Sticky Toffee Date Cake
Turkey Burger Deluxe
Boeuf Bourguignon
Flan Cheesecake
Shrimp Cocktail
Birthday Cake
Roast Chicken
Moules Frites

“Great French/Asian fusion find in the Hamptons. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The ambiance was great, and the service was quick.“

4.4 Superb227 Reviews
southold social American • $$$
56125 Main Rd, Southold - 4.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Basque Cheesecake
Payard Chocolate Dome
Watermelon Feta Salad
Chocolate Bar Dessert
Berkshire Pork Chop
Salad and Gnocchi
Grilled Octopus
Steamed Mussels
Smoked Salmon
Caesar Salad

“Great Place Friendly service warm welcome“

4.3 Superb67 Reviews
First and South Restaurant & Bar American • $$
100 South St, Greenport - 2.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Fried Chicken Sandwich
South Street Chowder
Rockefeller Oysters
Oysters Rockefeller
Really Good Burger
Black Bean Burger
Kale Caesar Salad
Ahi Tuna Burger
Steamed Mussels

“Wonderful first time dining here!“

4.2 Good94 Reviews