New American Restaurants near Shelter Island, NY

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!“

“Lovely location with Beautiful views Old world hotel made new and done with excellent taste and style I live in Southampton and decided to take a mini vacation for lunch and that's what it felt like I was another world away The terrace is beautiful. The service was excellent. Everyone was very helpful and very attentive.“

“Love this place for a million reasons“

“Great place. Really enjoyed the food the atmosphere and our waiter Sean was great. Good experience.“

“The food was great, service quick, professional and friendly . Very nice ambiance, classy place.“

“Great meal last night wit PAWPAW at the Lin Beach House. The intimate setting and stellar service can’t be beat. The food never ceases to surprise me. I always try something new, that I never thought I would eat, and end up loving. Last night the Eel hush puppies blew me away! Can’t wait to come back again!“

“Old school diner vibe. Spotless. Nice to drink out of glass instead of plastics like many restaurants there days.
Had traditional fish and chips but swapped out the fries for a salad. All great quality. Fish was fresh and greens simple but tasty. Husband tried the oyster soup and for him to say it was satisfying raised my eyebrow. Heard the desserts are great but too full to try. Don’t skip this gem.“

“Wonderful first time dining here!“

“Apart from the incredible food, large portions, (atypical from other eateries out east) Fred brings the bar/cocktails to a new level. His personality makes you want to have dinner at the bar Oh yes, and my customized dirty martini is beyond compare … anywhere 🍸“

“Food and service was wonderful!“

“Great Place Friendly service warm welcome“

“Very nice atmosphere staff n owners chef are the nicest people My daughter is an employee and we were invited to dinner there n no other job that my kids have done that for the family! Beautiful place n beautiful people! The food is amazing“

“First time visiting and we look forward to the next! Our server, Andrea was attentive and friendly. My steak was cooked perfectly and exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for a wonderful meal!“

“Great food service & amazing Dirty martinis!!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I had my birthday dinner at Topping Rose House, and it was an amazing experience—just like every other time we’ve been there. The food and drinks were absolutely delicious, and the service was outstanding. Our waitress was so kind and patient, even with our little toddler being a bit wild! Gerry was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. They even brought out a dessert with a candle for me, which was such a sweet touch. Overall, a wonderful experience—I’d recommend this place 100%!“

“We were in Greenport for Mother’s Day, and stumbled in here. The smell from outside was amazing. We ordered the half Brisket, Ribs and sausage with large fries, I was worried the food would be drenched in BBQ sauce, this was not the case. We were grateful the food was seasoned and sauced perfectly. The fries for us were crispy, some would say over done but perfect for us. We liked the atmosphere, service initially was a little slow but it was Mom’s Day. Oh two last things, if you order the sausage it is very hot, good but spicy hot so be prepared. Portions were decent, two of us ate from what we ordered and had a box to come home with.“

“This is a gem of a restaurant. My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Very comfortable bar and dining room. The staff is impeccable. The food presentations were artistically done and all tasted amazing. We enjoyed our Old Fashions. My wife loved the seared scallops and I the oysters. My wife thought the stuffed pasta with a fresh local pea sauce was a delight. I enjoyed the juicy and smokey half chicken. We split a nice warm chocolate cake and the coffee was very good. Look forward to returning. Enjoy !“

“We had a great lunch at Noah's, but the clam chowder was the one that stuck out the most...“

“Great food and service. Thanks to Courtney and Kaitlyn for a wonderful dining experience. See you in the spring“

“Had cocktails and apps at the bar last night. It was great and the staff were fantastic,“

“Amazing food, casual dining superb staff.“

“very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.“