50 Best Diners near Sheridan

“We LOVE the Fish Fry Dinner, Hot Roast Beef Sandwich, Chicken Croissant, Grilled Meatloaf S/W, and so much more...these are our favorites!!!!“

“Had dinner here and it was very tasty. The establishment interior is a small refined diner. Four booth seats bar top and two stand alone tables. The booth seating was plush and comfortable to fit up to four diners. One waitress and bartender on duty, with a small kitchen. We were sat and waited on fast, but food took sometime as the place filled up fast after. We ordered the steak and the wedge salad and fries. Took roughly 25-30 minutes for the food to come out. The Steak portion was tiny, not diner sized but to be expected for the area. The meat was tender and well seasoned the potatoes were soft and complemented the dish. The wedge salad was cheesy and well seasoned.“

“I can’t believe there is no reviews on this diner on Facebook. We stepped in tonight had Ronnie as our server and the food and atmosphere was outstanding. Thank you all for the wonderful meal! We now have a reason to return to NYC just to visit this diner and get their smashburger!“

“1st time visiting,the staff were lovely and food amazing On my next visit I will be back“

“Mikes has been a staple in the community for almost 40 years i remember bringing my kid to have breakfast on Saturday mornings before her activities it was cheap and cheerful Pratt students and faculty would be there as well. Now its practically same staff bathroom remodeled and costs have increased but so as everuthing else same friendly and fulfilling breakfast no bells and whistles but simple good food“

“Court Square Diner: A Slice of NYC Life Court Square Diner is like stepping into a scene straight out of Sex and the City.Whether you're grabbing a late-night coffee or indulging in a slice of cake that you can’t quite finish because you’re watching your waistline, the vibe is quintessentially New York. The atmosphere is perfect for those late-night gossip sessions with friends, where you can catch up on life and soak in the city’s energy. The breakfast portions here are massive, ideal for those with a big appetite. It's the perfect spot to unwind and feel like a true New Yorker. If you’re looking for that classic NYC diner experience, Court Square Diner is where you need to be.“

“I didn’t expect a full blown broadway show experience in a restaurant! If you want show tunes and pop music served with a plate of great food then this is the place for you! Our server Brandi M. belted out a wicked version of The wizard and I! I ordered the BLT with avocado and waffle fries and my friend ordered the chicken and waffles. Both were delicious.“

“My partner and I had some extra time before heading to the airport and we stop by here for breakfast. What a lovely restaurant! We had the Chilaquiles Verdes with some green hot sauce and WOWWWW! That was good! I also had some cantaloupe juice. 10/10.“

“I love it ! Great service and great food 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽“

“It looks like a greasy spoon sort of diner cafe. A neighborhood place. The meatloaf was good. The iced coffee was ok. The service was impeccable. It looks a little rundown but you don't go there for ambiance. I will return to try something else.“

“Excellent diner overall. Highly recommend.“

“Amazing food as always. Been three times so far and I will be back again this week for more 👌🏻“

“I had the best pancake here. Classic diner pancake, super fluffy, with powdered sugar, piped vegan butter on top, and real maple syrup. I also got vegan sausage on the side! They have a dedicated vegan section of the menu. The staff is super kind. I went at 10am on a Sunday and it was empty, but was full by 11am“

“The people working here make you feel like you matter. You definitely come here for the service. You feel their commitment in both food preparation and customer attention. The place creates the right feeling and attracts fun clientele. I return to this restaurant gladly!“

“We were recommended this diner on the plane to New York and it didn't disappoint. Great servers, always smiling and happy to help. Delicious food and a great place to spend some time.“

“We just had brunch in West way Diner and it was 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Choosing was really difficult as I wanted a bit of everything - really extensive menu, so so good! Servers were fab, attentive but not intrusive. Refillable drinks were available . Highly recommend,. definitely worth a visit 🌟❤️“

“We had lunch here with our family and small kids. Everyone was so friendly and caring and the food was great and amazing service. Highly recommend.“

“Ordered the truffle and roma omelette . Came with house hash potatoes and bread. Delicious food, service was quick and the omelette was prepared fresh. Also saw a lot of orders for their pancakes that looks delicious but we were too full after the eggs. The serving size was decent.“

“GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE+1(8O5)-41O 5OO2 NO NONSENSE AND GREAT ASSISTANCE!!!“

“Baby Blues Luncheonette definitely lives up to the hype. When we arrived, it was already pretty crowded, and for good reason. They don’t take reservations, so be prepared to wait especially on a Sunday around 11:30 a.m. like we did. We ended up waiting about two hours, but they do send you a notification when your table’s ready, and they also show you how many parties are ahead of you, which makes the wait feel a bit more manageable.

The place itself is small, and tables are pretty close together, but it wasn’t an issue for us. The menu is straightforward and easy to navigate, and the prices are very reasonable. My partner got the “Plato’s Plate,” and I went for the “Chicken Club.” Both were fantastic. My partner gave her dish a 9/10, and I’d give mine the same rating. The price-to-quality ratio was excellent, and we had no complaints. The only small note from my partner was that the bacon on her plate was a bit greasy, but it wasn’t a big deal.

We also shared a side of “Greek Potatoes and Tzatziki.” That dish was another 9/10. The only downside was that there wasn’t quite enough tzatziki for all the potatoes, so I’d recommend asking for extra on the side if you order it. No real issue though, just a small suggestion. We had an “Iced Coffee” and a “Regular Coffee” with our meal, and both were spot on.

One more thing: we were treated to a complimentary dish of fresh strawberries and blueberries with whipped cream (as you can see in the photo I included). We’re not sure what it was called, but it was light, refreshing, and delicious. Easily a 10/10, and I’d highly recommend it if you get the chance.

The service was also excellent. Our server was friendly and attentive, and even the hostess deserves a shoutout. We arrived a bit late for our seating time, but she was understanding and still got us a table despite it being so busy. Really appreciated that.

The bill was pretty reasonable for everything we got, and I left a $15 tip because of the great service and the complimentary fruit bowl.

Overall, we had a fantastic experience, great food, great atmosphere, and excellent service. The wait time can be long (ours was 2 hours), but it’s totally worth it when you consider the quality of the food and the prices. I’ll definitely be back, and I highly recommend you give it a try too!

Thanks for reading, and I hope this helps!“

“Delicious food, super fast service, casual dining.“

“If you are downtown and don't know where to eat, this is the right place. Great variety, it's not a cart and the service is very good. It's the second time I've been here and I liked it both times. The place is nice and quiet“

“Good food & service, very clean, and parking.“

“First day in NY and found this little gem. All 3 of us had salads and they were unbelievably good. Fantastic place to visit xx“

“Had breakfast there twice. Once solo and the next time with my wife. Consecutive Tuesdays. Just there this morning, after the golf range at Chelsea Piers. It's a combination of Greek and Mexican specialties. I have sampled the eggs overeasy with corned beef and this time had three poached eggs with fresh tomato and feta, home fries and coffee. All wonderful. My wife had fried eggs with ham on top of grilled taco. She loved it. This is a top notch diner with excellent service.“

“Miriam was excellent. Super attentive and hospitable.“

“My son and I happened to be in the area and decided to stop in for breakfast.
Was greeted with a smile and pleasant good morning, how are you guys doing.
Clean, cozy and friendly service.
A nice variety to choose from.
Food ( breakfast) was delicious, original and a good portion.
I enjoy going to these little establishments l, you get the best tasting food. Stop in and give it a try.

Note: people need to stop with some of these comments, if you try the food and don't like it, that's ok. Even 5 star restaurants food may not taste to your liking.. ok. You have other options next time.“

“Delicious food. You get a lot of food for the price. Great NYC diner!“

“John and Julio you are the best and Julio make me an omelet! Jackass! Oops I mean a Jackass Omelet and or a Jackass Breakfast Sandwich“

“Really good pastrami and friendly service.“

“Very nice place, clean and friendly staff, it was especially nice to meet the owner of the Diner who cooks the food and also serves his customers, thank you very much for the delicious breakfasts during the trip to New York and thank u for complimentary cookies for our daughter during the trip to New York“

“We had lunch here with our family and small kids. Everyone was so friendly and caring and the food was great and amazing service. Highly recommend.“

“Everything I've had here has been amazingly good. Best Gyro platter. Good pastrami sandwich. Meatloaf dinner was great. Fries are awesome. What's best is the courteous and fast service.“

“If you want to eat food like is your mom.ho cook it come.to this amazing place
The food is just perfect
The restaurant ambiance is very cozy amd nice
The price is amazing
Try it you will never regret it“

“We had lunch here with our family and small kids. Everyone was so friendly and caring and the food was great and amazing service. Highly recommend.“

“I love this place. The owner and employees couldn't be nicer. The food is good and the atmosphere is friendly and welcoming.

Parking: Parking right next to the building.

Wheelchair accessibility: Handicapped ♿️ parking in both the lot and the street. Handicapped entrance and the side of the building.“

“Food was good and environment was friendly“

“Fantastic food awesome service. 10/10 from me“

“After looking at reviews I expected more. No carnivore starter options. Had to settle for a 10 ounce steak as an appetizer and another for a main. Well prepared but hardly sufficient for a grown man. Partner had the pressed chicken that was dry. If they catered for meat eaters by having a carnivore appetizer and more substantial steak I'd return. Service and ambiance very nice.“

“Great food and service, highly recommended“

“Most diners can best be described as basic. They cover the bare minimum of quality and service, and your typical customer will accept it. There are no surprises, good or bad, so the experience will be similar to any other diner.
Eat Here Now is not your basic diner. Granted, their menu isn't the size of a paperback book, but what they offer covers whatever you're looking for. The service is where EHN shines. On top of efficiency, the staff is friendly without being too solicitous.
If you're in the neighborhood and don't want to visit a more formal and expensive restaurant, consider Eat Here Now“

“Always good & good specials“

“This is one of those classic diners you hope never goes away but are always afraid they're gonna get priced out. They are dirt cheap and they deliver exactly what you'd expect out of a diner. Just get your basics and enjoy a simple life for a moment.“

“10/10 diner experience. The food is fresh and delicious, the atmosphere is top tier, and the service is literally everything I want in a diner. The owner Nick was so great, it seemed like he knew everyone who was there, but I quickly learned although there are clearly many regulars, Nick makes an effort to make sure everyone feels at home. Could not recommend more, if there’s a wait, it’s worth it.“

“Delicious food and very nice service from Rebecca. I had a party of 6, with some vegetarians, and someone who had to eat something gentle on the stomach. We sat at the bar and our server, Rebecca, was super nice, attentive, bilingual (which was helpful for our group), and gave great food recommendations.

I ordered the braised short rib 5/5 would order again in a heartbeat, especially for the price. Comes with brasato sauce a lemon vinaigrette, perfect for cutting the richness. Some of our party ordered veggie burgers, others ordered chicken noodle soup. I also ordered a mocha.

Definitely eat here if you’re in the area and in the mood for comfort food this winter!“

“The Best Diner Family Run! People are so lovely! Food is Great! Very Clean!“

“A cozy family run cafe with welcoming and friendly staff, their food is AMAZING and cooked with so much love! You CANNOT find any other spot that can beat their prices, that’s forsure!! Their breakfast is delicious - their French toast is a must have btw- and their burgers are great as well as the wraps, food is always served hot and quickly. As for delivery, they always exceed expectations because the food is always earlier than the suggested time and the drivers are very kind and friendly! Definitely recommend visiting, you won’t regret it!! They also have the best servers - Cleo and Aly are the absolute BEST ?“

“Nice atmosphere and everything tasted wonderful. The only thing that would make this place better would be mimosas!“

“Everything you'd expect from a diner. Staff knows the clientele. Food comes out fast. And if there is a problem, someone has eyes on it and comes to help right away.

Got pancakes and waffles my boys loved.

Got a wrap I enjoyed.

My partner got a salad. The protein (chicken kebabs) was delicious though wished there was a different greens option to pair with it. Spinach or romaine or even mixed seasonal greens.

Anyway worth a visit if you are craving a solid diner experience.

Kid-friendliness: My kids were a bit wild but the staff was helpful and understanding.

Tall booths keep grumpy side eyes from other customers away.

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps. And booths with an open side. Seems pretty wheelchair friendly.“

“Found Legends because we were coming from out of state to Jets game and taking local train to stadium from Secaucus. Very friendly staff and terrific home fries!“