27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shortsville

“The BBQ is always excellent. The BBQ Cuban is my fav. Beer is great and the vibe is always welcoming. Hot wings were a hit too. Thanks!“

“Great people doing an awesome job. Got a sheet pizza and wings. Alwsys love the food and down the road from my work. Keep up the great work“

“My and my husband ordered from here tonight and we got a sub and I just got a chicken strips dinner and it was AMAZING!!!! We love it better then most places around us this place is now our favorite so far that’s around us. Highly recommend them!“

“June 2025 Update

The pizza and staff are very good and that continued.
No improvements to the interior were made; the same torn shredded carpeting is present with no upgrade.

Previous Visits 2025 and 2024
The pizza is very good and the staff are nice and friendly. The dining rooms would be much nicer if they replaced the old worn-out, torn, stained carpeting. This presents trip hazards for customers. This drags down your dining experience and makes the place look really bad. The mens room door needs a cleaning.“

“We have been patronizing this store for the past 4 years. We are always very satisfied with the quality of the items we have ordered. We have never had issues with deliveries or to-go orders. Quite honestly, for the quality, price and service, you get an excellent meal.



Parking: The parking lot in front of the store is very limited in space and can be tricky to navigate when the adjacent gas station and Domino’s are busy.“

“5 ⭐️ , the food is delicious, and the employees was so amazing, super adorable , and so tasty! Best deals in Wayne county, worth the drive! will be back!!“

“Quality of this Nima’s location is SO MUCH better than the Newark one.The pizza quality is just 10x better. They season and flavour the dough/crust and the cheese is actually fresh instead of rubbery chew from Newark’s.Service is also amazing here. The lovely lady is always so nice to me.“

“Excellent meal at Il Posto tonight! We highly recommend the restaurant for your next cultural experience! Delicious!“

“Wings are really good and a good price.“

“I haven’t had Pontillo’s pizza in awhile, but it has always been considered the favorite pizza in my family. The pizza and wings were just as I remembered and ready for pickup exactly on time. Staff was friendly and polite. It was nice to see that an order of wings is still 12 good size pieces as most places now only serve 10. Will definitely order again. Thank you Mike for all the years of serving delicious food to the people of your home town!“

“finally got to try this last weekend after moving to newark a year ago was delicious and upset I've been missing out all this time. will for sure be ordering from here more often.“

“Thank you for the awesome lunch and your patience while we placed the order today! The person who answered the phone was a rockstar. You guys are awesome! Wraps and subs were A+ 😎“

“Always bright and cheerful! Their vegetables and meat are the best around. I am pleased that Wegmans stays informed about health trends and the general public’s desire and offers a variety of products. Also Wegmans is community oriented and frequently involved in ways to help out💜“

“My new husband and I came to the Finger Lakes on our honeymoon. We were in Canandaigua and were recommended Wally's by a local for a late-night dinner. What a fantastic experience! We had the wings and the Wally's plate, and we’ll be thinking of both for a long time!“

“We had a paranormal film crew at our museums and Marks was awesome and donated 2 sheet pizzas and 3 different add ons! They were amazingly fast and very accommodating! We highly recommend them to all of visitors when they are done touring the museums! Thanks for all you do in our community!“

“I’ll start this off by saying food is amazing! But we didn’t have the best experience tonight. Food came out wrong, appetizer came out with meal not before , waitress not that nice ,blamed me on food.“

“Really good Hawaiian pizza!! Fast delivery too! (Marion location)“

“The pizza, Parmesan bites was Absolutely delicious 😋“

“Great atmosphere, Great food,Great people...“

“Vegetarian options: Vegetable toppings on the pizza, calzones and garlic knots

Parking: The parking is In a strip mall

Kid-friendliness: There is no profanity and the staff is friendly. The waiting area and dining area is spacious.“

“Nicely lighted with a dim warm yellow throughout and candlelit tables. I had the gluten free flatbread pizza and French fries, so good!“

“First time customer, Pizza came highly recommended & we were not disappointed!! Very good Pizza, great customer service, thank you!“

“My Server was very kind, respectful, and polite!“

“My Server was very kind, respectful, and polite!“

“Traveled from Southwest Pa to vacation with friends from Wyoming County and Fish Lake Erie. Two Veterans, 1 Marine and 1 Army and their wives. Saw the posts online about this Legion and gave the Fish Fry a try. It was the right choice. Gets an excellent rating from us on food and service. Very nice enviroment as well.“

“Like a zoo fast service !“

“I have come to respect and alter my original experience probably just a hard day to get through on my frist trip my second trip was better I loved the huge pizza slice and wings with a soda atmosphere is a little gloomy and dark but well worth a try pizza was exemplary and most of the places should be more like them when making pizza not over done not under done no flaws in the pizza little to no Grice or run off the pepperoni was cooked perfectly to just a little crunch and was in and out in less than 20 minutes not many places can do that and do it right tables needed to be cleaned a little more some gum on the under sides of tables and something felt dirty about sitting there could be just the gloomy feel but was not a bad experience vary friendly and attentive service

Parking: A difficult to find the parking spot the frist time as well as finding the place but the second time was way better I can say plan your visit timely even when ordering from doordash it's best to order with a timely sence can make the difference between a long weight or a short one between delivery and dining in but an experience to try“