50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tuckahoe

“Meatballs & Sauce 😋 delicious.
Nice welcoming front staff - 'Sauce Boss' John 👌 makes a Fabulous Penne alla Vodka - Chicken / Veal dishes.
Very good, tasty 🍕 Pizza Pie - standard italian pizzaria menu - Excellent!“

“I have patronized Angelina's for many years. We have had luncheons and retirement dinners over the years. The food and service is outstanding! Louis and his staff are a pleasure to work with! Thanks!“

“I love to cook and cook all the time, but since I found Villaggio I'm ordering delivery! Their meals like chicken piccata, chicken aceto and an Italian standby lasagna are amazing! Large portions with a choice of a side. The owner Tommy is personable and deliveries come in a timely manner. Try Villagio he won't be sorry!“

“Friendly atmosphere & good food. You can go alone and sit at the bar. You'll always have someone to chat with.“

“5 Stars - Highly recommend.“

“The first pie I had from John at Fenice was the Detroit Red...which Tony picked up for me last week when i was at work...i finished the whole pie by just after midnight...but I had to go for the regular NY Cheese pie fresh from the oven. We scored one of the two tables there and were able to decide which of the other slices to bring home...it was like a pizza candy store. We didn't finish our pie so brought home two slices, and I wanted to try John's sicilian, I couldn't leave there without a Detroit Red slice and Tony wanted the multi cheese white pizza...every pizza we tried was perfect! something about the dough. The sauce. The cheese. The dough for the Sicilian and the Detroit Red was light and perfectly crunchy on the bottom. Flavor out of this world. We drove from White Plains just to try Pizza Fenice. worth the trip.“

“Very nice Italian place. The hand made pasta alone would have had us through the door, but everything was wonderful here. The service was attentive and food was amazing from the appetizers to the entrees! You have to try this place if you want an incredible Italian meal!“

“Mario’s Metro Pizza completely changed what I expected from a pizzeria. We came in for a full tasting and every single dish overdelivered. The chicken scarpariello was the standout, juicy chicken smothered in a sauce with real depth, sausage and thin cut potatoes mixed in, plated like something from a sit down Italian restaurant rather than handed over a counter. The vodka rigatoni with fresh burrata was another surprise, creamy, rich, and not something you expect to find at a pizza shop. The Philly cheesesteak pizza and hot honey pepperoni with vodka sauce were both excellent as well, and the hot honey and buffalo wings are made completely from scratch in house.

Beyond the food, the hospitality stood out. The owners, two brothers with over a decade of experience in kitchens across Westchester and New York City, took over a pizzeria that had been a neighborhood staple for decades and elevated it without losing that local feel. You can tell everything is made fresh and with real care.

If you are in New Rochelle and think you already know what a pizzeria can offer, this place will prove you wrong. Highly recommend.“

“It’s great place with very delicious pasta and artesanal pizza! 🍝🍕“

“Amazing service and delicious pizza! Thanks for the quick delivery of 13 pizzas to the Philipsburg parking lot last Wednesday!!! Sweet treat from Posh Pretzels coming your way in appreciation!!!“

“12/10!!! Great place! Awesome family owned restaurant and the pizza was amazing!! From Buffalo Ny!! We’ll be back !“

“Came here with my mom, who is very very hard to please, and she left saying this is the best Italian she’s had in her 28 years in New York. Great portion sizes, prices, and very fresh ingredients. Could not recommend this place more!“

“the food is phenomenal and the decor transports you out of the Bronx“

“Great pizza and staff!! The gelato was great!“

“Came to this place by chance and I didn't not regret it! The staff is very welcoming and friendly. He gave me a garlic bread to try and took the time to explained the ingredients. I'm touched by Halal King Pizza's hospitality and service. The foods are great and warm (super fresh), 100/10 would recommend this spot for anyone who's looking for a quick and yummy bite!“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“This is the pizza I’ve been searching for my whole life.“

“We stopped here while traveling from RI to PA and WOW are we glad we did. We needed a place to accommodate our small pup so we stopped to ask if they had outdoor seating. They didn’t but they created it by carrying a table and chairs outside for us - talk about customer service! Nick was such a fantastic host - setting us up, providing exceptional service and great conversation! I also can’t forget to mention how incredible the pizza and chicken roll were! This place is a 10/10 and we will definitely find a reason to stop back again!“

“Best pizza in NYC! And their fried calzones are a must 😊“

“I just got a couple slices after running some errands. The pizza was some of the best I’ve ever had- cooked perfectly, crust wasn’t too crunchy or soft, had great flavor. The service was amazing. The man asked every customer if they wanted salt, pepper, parmesan for their table and asked each family who came in with small children if they wanted their pizza less hot and/or cut smaller for them. Will definitely be coming back.“

“All the food is quality and very tasty .From the pasta dishes to the chicken ,meatballs, eggplant ,lasagna,shrimp dishes. .Everything is made on premise and homemade.The specialty pizzas and slices at the counter are outstanding. Plus they will make you ant variation of pizza you like even if its not the menu. highly recommend this establishment. Family run and totally respectful and pleasant at the counter.“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“I was getting my nails done and was starving so I went next door and BAM I was met with the best pizza I’ve had in years. I don’t even like pizza but this place made me a believer. Staff is friendly, place is clean, music is great, food is delicious. And they have great specials!“

“The best pizza and friendliest staff!!!“

“Delicious food“

“Good Pizza Great service Good Beer“

“im ivette rodriguez i know sal and his amazing one of a kind pizza,there best 100% garantee you be back for more .there original ,fresh made with love,not only his pizza his calzone patties sicillian,ices.so many things but most of all there clean enviorment.and the best part its a family place.full of love friendly and welcoming.can be all night saying all i experianced etc ...knowed them for 40 yests Greek up eating there and left to pr then orlando and never had one pizza like pugleys pizza.so much that i tell everyone in florida that goes to the bronx must make that stop and prove me wrong .hope one day they move to florida or im going back to the bronx just for there pizza 100% garantee.“

“Want the best pizza in all of New York City. Sorry to break it to you but it won’t be downtown. This place is a gem in Inwood and hopefully will be here for generations to come! Def must check it out if you’re ever In the city.“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“I ate the pizza and wings so fast that I didn't even get a chance to take a picture.

We ordered the Beekman Ave specialty pizza, a regular pepperoni, and the eggplant pizza. The eggplant pizza was absolutely incredible—easily one of the best pizzas I've had in Westchester.

The style is a thin, bar-style pie similar to what you'd find in New Jersey, with a vibe like Colony Grill. The wings were excellent too. If you're a fan of thin-crust, bar-style pizza, this place is a must-visit. Highly recommended.“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“Delicious Vietnamese food! Have had several different items here and keep coming back. The broth of the pho is so silky and delicious. I have only done takeout so far but the waitstaff has always been incredibly friendly at each visit, and there’s always lots of customers. Highly recommend!!“

“This was my first time ordering from here, and I couldn’t be more impressed. The pizza was absolutely delicious! I rarely take the time to leave reviews, but this experience truly deserved one. The young lady who answered the phone was professional, respectful, knowledgeable, and patient. The delivery driver was friendly and courteous, and the pizza exceeded my expectations. Thank you for providing such excellent customer service and amazing food. You’ve definitely gained a loyal customer , I look forward to ordering again!“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“

“awesome pizza, awesome crew“

“The pizza was phenomenal!!!! Customer service was amazing and friendly. Definitely recommend 💯💯💯“

“The service is always excellent here. The food did not disappoint. It was my first time having their pizza and it was delicious, had a magherita personal pie with arugula and wild mushrooms and the sauce to cheese ratio was perfect, the sauce was very good and the mushrooms and arugula were fresh. I completed my dinner with a glass of Malbec which complimented my meal. I will definitely return to try more of Marcello's menu.“

“the food is so amazing. this place never disappoints.“

“I've been ordering Wonder near the office I work at downtown and have always enjoyed their food. It's nice to have access to it by my home now!
Their food always arrives hot and fresh. I like the Detroit deep dish pizza a lot.“

“Nice little place. Pizza and Calzone both were very good“

“Love Riko’s! Nice Atmosphere, Delicious Food The Best Thin Crust Pizza, Outstanding Appetizers, Full Bar With Specialties Drinks & Healthy Salads! Desserts Straight From Italy!“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Never tried the tomato pie until here and fell in love with it.“

“My go to spot fresh delish and hot“

“Every time i come to this Frank's Pizza shop. It always amazed me of the quality and freshness of the food. The service is always polite and always with a good vibe. My favorite entree to get here at this fabulous Pizza shop is the spaghetti and meatballs. For me is the best one!!!“

“Had a great experience with Pizza Nova. This place really stands out as a reliable neighborhood pizzeria with a welcoming atmosphere and a strong sense of community.

You can tell there’s real attention to consistency and freshness—everything feels made with care, from the pizza to the classic Italian-American menu items. It’s the kind of local spot that’s easy to keep coming back to, especially if you’ve grown up in the area.

I’ve been eating here since I was a kid, and it still has that familiar, comforting feel that makes it special. The owner’s daughter was a pleasure to talk to, which added a nice personal touch to the experience.

If you’re looking for a solid local pizza spot in Tenafly with history, consistency, and genuine neighborhood charm, Pizza Nova is definitely worth checking out“

“awesome food,great portions and prices wonderful owners go there you wont regret it“

“Just good moist and crispy pizza. Yes, moist and crispy is featured together. What is not to love?“

“Love their chicken wings Always order two trays for family gatherings Everyone loves them and says they are the BEST Peggy“

“i enjoyed the city feel inside this gem of a restaurant, the dining experience, was super friendly and very accommodating, I enjoyed a delicious salad followed with cacio e pepe, definitely coming back.“

“Service terrible and tomato soup tasted like it was watered down plus cold.Waitress was visiting with colleagues more than giving us service. We were the only ones in the restaurant during lunchtime. When it came to receiving our bill she put the wrong price down she said there was no manager to talk to which she lied to us. Overall Service and Food at the St.Albert location I would definitely not recommend on the other hand McGrath on the southside excellent for service food everything etc.“