10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wainscott

“Going to La Capannina for many years...I'm happy they are here in Wainscott...Albeit I would travel miles for their excellent Pizza, and entrees. Friendly staff, wonderful pizza. Frankly anyone that would give this less then 5 stars should be banned from East Hampton.“

“Wow ! What an amazing local place . I'd your not local hop on a ferry . Food is delicious and freshly made. Chicken Parm hero best I've had out. Staff super nice and courteous. Doesn't have to be fancy to be so good . Best of all, so friendly priced.“

“The pizza was great. The beverage was different but okay. The atmosphere was unique. Parking was good and I was there when it wasn't busy. Not to forget that Andrew was great. I would visit again when I am in the area. The grandma square...just say I went back up for another square.“

“Sam's has been a staple in East Hampton for years. I washed dishes there when I was a kid and they always gave me a pie to take home. I take the family out sometimes and it's always consistently great Italian food. I started thinking about pizza the other day and just couldn't resist picking up a Sam's special. So many great choices I hope my review doesn't make it too busy there because it does get a little difficult sometimes when they are swamped. Love you guys!“

“We had stopped in for a quick slice. The pizza was delicious and fresh. The staff was super friendly. I enjoyed the canned lemonade. Great pick if you want something that isn't too sweet.I especially loved the green signs all over the wall.“

“This is a great place in the Hamptons. Very real and unpretentious. Service was wonderful and attentive. Basic food is excellent: burgers, salads, sandwiches, etc. And the ambience is really pleasant, mixing the virtues of a good restaurant, a sports bar and friendly pub. Highly recommended!“

“Pizza is spectacular, I'm not really a pizza/pasta person, but Ferro's is the best. The crust, the toppings, and the perfect bake It's also reasonably priced (for East Hampton ?). I enjoy Domino's, but it is really far from home. This is the hometown equivalent. Rather you want a slice or a whole pie, there are options. 8.5/10, just because I don't like the hours they're open.Parking: Fairly close parking for East Hampton.Kid-friendliness: Yes.“

“Delicious Grandma pizza, fried calamari and the garden salad was one of the freshest we've had in a long time! Highly recommend this place if you're in the neighborhood! Friendly and attentive service too! Cozy and comfortable booths to dine in also.“

“My girlfriend and I had an airbnb stay about 2 min drive away from Harbor Market & Kitchen. We’ve been cravin lobster rolls for a few months and we ran into this spot in the morning. We stepped in and immediately the place was super cozy and beautifully curated with a bunch of interesting and really cool items consisting of books, home goods, souvenirs, grocery needs, snacks etc. Unfortunately their lobster rolls werent being sold currently as it was considered out of season, but we decided to grab other food to make the best of it. We both ordered the HMK breakfast sandwich one with bacon and the other with ham. We were really blown away by how great it was. The quality of the ingredients used were amazing, you can really taste the freshness of each bite. We also ordered 2 iced lattes with oatmilk which was good too! The staff was super friendly, when we were told about the lobster rolls being unavailable we asked one of the workers for any recommendations since we were from out of town and he gave some suggestions for other spots which we thought was super kind to help satisfy our cravings lmao. The market itself is placed cozily in a very quiet/cute neighborhood with no trouble for parking and a very walkable distance from other sag harbor shopping stores. Their public restroom is available and it was clean and tidy as well. Our first experience was nothing but positive vibes, we decided to come back the following evening to try grab sandwiches to bring back to our airbnb for dinner. We arrived about 430 towards end of day for them and we asked for a turkey and salumi sandwich. Unfortunately their sandwich are only prepared earlier in the day and are only available as a grab and go style on display at the counter. So whatever is available will be wrapped up already, and the only sandwiches left were their roasted eggplant. Once again, we decided to make the best of what was available so we grabbed 2 of them, and also a brownie. Few hours have gone by and we popped our sandwiches in the toaster oven for dinner. WE WERE BLOWN AWAY BY THE HIGH QUALITY OF THE SANDWICH. Ive only had eggplant parm sandwiches so my first thought of ever trying a roasted eggplant sandwiches was that it was going to be average. I was really impressed by how tasty it was. My girlfriend and i couldnt shut the F up about how delicious it was we wanted moreee. The following morning we checked out of our airbnb at 930am, and before we drove back for the ride home we decided to head back to the market once again lmao. When we arrived one of the cashiers recognized us and asked if we found our new favorite spot and we immediately said YUP lmao. As before we ordered HMK breakfast sandwiches one with bacon and one with ham, 2 hot oatmilk lattes, and we decided to buy 3 sandwiches to have for dinner at home. We ended up purchasing their turkey, salumi, and another roasted eggplant lmaoo. And once again we were both blown away by the flavorful high quality ingredients used for the sandwiches. Out of the 3 we purchased we both agreed the salumi sandwich was our favorite. Side note, we bought the sandwiches in the morning, put them in the fridge during the day, and for dinner time we put the sandwiches in the oven to a good temp to make the bread crispy which is a key move! Our experience with Harbor Market & Kitchen has been extremely positive down from the high presentation of its store, high quality ingredients and warm friendly nature from all of its employees. I read a few reviews about the bad service from the employees but from someone that has worked in customer service for 10+ years, i can only say that service workers are a reflection of their store. With a beautiful store with such high standards, it shows from the help they provide. My girlfriend got nothing but great positive vibes from the staff. Hopefully other customers follow the same practice of “treat others the way you want to be treated.” All in all, AMAZING EXPERIENCE! Totally worth our drive from Queens Ny, we want to come back soon to try other food items“

“One of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had- I ordered the Grilled Chicken Focaccia and it did not disappoint. The flavor and quality from the house made rosemary focaccia and smoked mozzarella pulled fresh that morning and tender marinated chicken made for the perfect lunch. A must visit for a classic Italian deli experience.“