27 Best American Restaurants in Williamsville

“It was a minute before our waiter came to our table. He apologized straight out which was admirable. Dylan was an amazing server and was very attentive to all our needs. We have been here many times and it has always been a great experience. We started with the Jalapeño mozzarella sticks. Then my wife and I both got chicken sandwiches. I had the Glen falls chicken sandwich which was excellent with a large portion. My wife got the Buffalo Chicken sandwich which she enjoyed. My son had the Main Street burger and my daughter had a kids grill cheese. We were very happy with the food and the excellent service provided by Dylan- he deserves employee of the month!

Kid-friendliness: Good for kids“

“The second we walked in we were greeted with a friendly staff. The food was amazing and the staff was wonderful. Highly recommend.“

“We visited for the first time tonight & we were very impressed. The food was absolutely outstanding. I got French onion soup, a burger & the beef on weck. Everything was top notch.“

“Hands down amazing food. we stopped in after a long day of shopping and I am so glad we did. the service was great. the food was honest to God phenomenal. so good that we all shared bites to appreciate how yummy our food was. My dog was accepted at outdoor seating and I was even allowed to take her out in the field for some fetch after we ordered. Don't drive by... STOP in and grab a bite... you won't be disappointed!! Oh and GO BILLS!! ❤️🤍💙 🐃“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious food! Share Kitchen & Bar Room is the perfect spot for a relaxed yet classy night out. . The food was absolutely outstanding – fresh, flavorful, and beautifully plated. Each dish we tried was clearly made with high-quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation. The menu offers a great variety, whether you're in the mood for something light or more indulgent. The cocktails were also a highlight – creative, well-balanced, and expertly made. Highly Recommended.“

“This old gem doesn't need another glowing review, but here it is anyway! Classic dishes like pot pie and open faced turkey sandwiches are perfect for a chilly Buffalo night. Gorgeous building with a great bar area. Good local beers on tap and decent wine list. Friendly service.“

“Charlie The Butcher continues to be the premier Beef on Weck of Western New York! Thank you for all you do for the community as well! Merry Christmas!“

“Always a great experience! The prices however are going up and the pepper dip that is awesome no longer comes with bread which sucks because tortilla chips just don’t cut it and I refuse to pay $3 for a small loaf of bread. Otherwise service, atmosphere and food are awesome!“

“Always have some unique seasonal gifts. I particularly like their costume jewelry. The staff is friendly and helpful! Especially my sister-in law FayK“

“Charlie The Butcher continues to be the premier Beef on Weck of Western New York! Thank you for all you do for the community as well! Merry Christmas!“

“Great staff, food and all around atmosphere!!!“

“Excellent food, perfectly cooked, generous portions!! Well priced . Pleasant surroundings and very well maintained facilities. Ample space and easy accessible for handicapped.“

“We ordered drop off catering for our 30th anniversary party. Everything was delicious and HOT. Matt was absolutely wonderful to work with. Our numbers kept growing by the day but that didn’t phase him. He went over and above, making sure we had the biggest brisket he could find and he even brought us an extra pan of veggies just in case. The bbq pork mac n cheese was a huge hit. The prices were very reasonable, especially for the superior service. I highly recommend Blue Fire BBQ! Thanks for a great experience, Matt!!“

“Excellent Cajun wings and good service!!!“

“By far the freshest tasting Mediterranean food I've had in Western New York. The restaurant is intimate which enabled a very personal feeling while dining there. The prices are reasonable and the quantity of food is overwhelming. They have takeout but I highly recommend dining in.“

“Busy place -bustling, lots of energy - seated immediately at the bar (our choice) - wonderful service and attention - easily three different people took care of us to make sure we had everything we needed throughout the mean - very friendly - high level of care - wings were great!“

“A Buffalo institution and one of my must visit place(s) if I'm in the area. Personally, I like the original Anderson's location on Sheridan (in Tonawanda) better than the other locations. But this one is not bad. Only got a twist of chocolate and vanilla custard this time but I've had majority of the items on the menu. The custard is always creamy and flavorful. Try one of the special flavors, like pistachios or strawberry, if they have it. You won't regret it and it's worth the calories.

Dietary restrictions: Dairy

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly - who doesn't like custard/ice cream?

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“By far the most amazing spinach artichoke dip I have ever had, the burgers taste like they came right off the grill , nice ambiance and waitress was attentive ! Right across the street from one of my favorite taco places by Transit rd. A busy area with many options but more on the commercial side. This is a good pick, Another buffalo favorite !“

“The Britesmith has the best burger I have ever had! Will definitely go back!“

“Fish fry was delicious and crispy. They will split it in the kitchen for you if you are going to share it. In all my years of splitting fish fries I have never seen a restaurant do that. Will be back again!“

“Great food but the soda is too expensive“

“Upon my first visit i fell in love with everything from the food to the atmosphere. Im a bit of an adult child and i love chicken tenders and tullys is right they make the best around! If your a bit of a sport nut that loves a good applebeesish atmosphere then this is the place for you.“

“Good old fashion diner. Good food, good service, good price. CLEAN!“

“Good evening! I could not go to bed tonight without acknowledging the fabulous service my two friends and I received at the Acropolis on Main Street. Our server Anthony C was outstanding! All three of us commented that we could not remember a time where we had such an attentive server that was also entertaining and gracious. You are blessed and lucky to have some like him on your team. We do a monthly dinner on Main Street and are already planning on coming back to Acropolis for our September dinner (if we can find out when Anthony C is working!) Thank you Anthony for a night of fabulous service and great laughs!!“

“This place is great! I got slices for lunch and they were heated up perfectly and the staff was very friendly. Highly recommend and I will be back for some more.“

“The Cheesy Chick food truck came to my Fattey Beer fundraiser last night and they were AMAZING! Everyone raved about the food and the staff was friendly and kind. I highly recommend them!!!“

“Went to the Williamsville location on Memorial Day. Our server was Hanna, who did an amazing job! Shout out to the manager, Jason. He went above and beyond! I wanted to recognize him in this post. Thank you for your hospitality!“