19 Best American Restaurants in Ashtabula

“good food, good homemade soup“

“Our family of 5 dined in early Jan 2026 and had a fabulous meal and experience! The hostess and server were welcoming and knowledgeable. We tried 3 items from First & Seconds, 3 pastas, and 2 Thirds. Everything was cooked to perfection!! Thank you for an amazing meal! I’ll definitely be back.“

“Best place to eat in the city overall. Biggest portions and fairest prices. Great tastes and even better service.“

“We were on vacation from Missouri & I have a serious food allergy to anything mammal, Tina & the staff were so helpful & took great care of me. This is only my 2nd time to eat out in over 5 months & I had Salmon & it was amazing and I had no reactions 😀 I look forward to more vacations to Ashtabula. Thanks so much ☺️“

“Absolutly loved the cinco de mayo specials!“

“We had a great time! People were professional and kind. Restaurant was clean and food was delicious. We witnessed a customer giving a complaint and was unnecessarily rude and we were impressed at how calm, patient and professional Mike was. We had 4 hyper kids in our group and the staff was patient kind and engaging with them. We will be back!!“

“Very nice homey restraunt. Waitress all if them treat you like old friends. And very important, the food is always hot“

“My first time here was tonight. I got a Gyro combo. So I did not get to eat my food for 45 mins, (driving to our destination and then waited about 20 mins to eat.) but the fries were still crispy and delicious! The gyro….absolutely incredible. The flavors are out of this world. Will be returning because I’d like to try more menu items!!“

“We spoke with the owner, Jay, today. This is just the most unique place to have a drink along the many Great Lakes towns we have visited. He told us he is hosting a Jeep club tomorrow, and we wish him the most heeps of well. We all need to visit the Bun Boat to keep these types of unique establishments thriving!“

“Best steak I have ever had!!“

“Just an awesome restaurant! Always great food and service!“

“Wonderful atmosphere and fun! Axe throwing is always fun and Liz takes the time to make sure you are prepared and enjoy your time. This is a little hidden gem in our beautiful Harbor for those wanting a peaceful evening out.“

“Amazing food. Mild wings + fries with bacon & carolina gold sauce 👌.“

“great food, great prices, and friendly service! you cant ask for more! Definitely enjoyed the fried bologna sandwich and the corned beef hash was cooked perfectly. Mahalo Marcy for the fantastic service and thank you for having us 🥰🤙“

“I first want to say I love this restaurant. I just don't understand why they are open today with a level 3 snow warning. They are urging people to stay off the roads unless its an emergency. Eating at this restaurant isn't a emergency.“

“Ok so normally we avoid this place like the plague of the black witch doctor in France my wife had gift cards from an even we didn't want to go bad we used them most definitely changed my mind I let the staff over a phone call my food was so fresh THREW DOOR DASH THAT IM IMPRESSED MY CHICKEN WAS CRISPY AND NOT SOGY AND OVERFLOWING WITH SAUCE I HAD TO CALL AND LET THERE STAFF NO TEN OUT OFF TEN THE MANAGER ON DUTY IN THE DRIVE THREW HAS HER CREW TOGETHER AND MOST DEFINITELY WILL BE ON THE LOOK OUT FOR BETTER S SERVICE THEN PAST EXPERIENCE“

“It’s delicious I really love the frisco prime“

“Ordered catering for a program and everything was fantastic! On time, accommodating, and over all delicious! Will be ordering with them again!“

“Great food / prices/ awesome waitress. Not to mention fast service 👏🏻“