50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bexley

“Best gluten free crust ever. By a ton. Yum!“

“Relaxing, entertaining & fun. The food is adequate.“

“Delicious NY-style pizza! Whenever I want pizza, this is my go-to. The customer service is very nice when I pick up my order. I ordered delivery once, and it was also a great customer service experience. Five stars!“

“When are you guys going to come into this century and sign up with GrubHub or DoorDash? You'd definitely increase your profits. Driving to pick up food is old school, LOL!!“

“Was working in Columbus all weekend closest spot was Mikey‘s. We ate there three nights in a row. Great pizza and cold beers. Highly recommend I will be back.“

“Was working in Columbus all weekend closest spot was Mikey‘s. We ate there three nights in a row. Great pizza and cold beers. Highly recommend I will be back.“

“Very quiet!! Very polite atmosphere!!! No one hurling out F-Bombs!! Very peaceful.

I visited 6 - 10, 13 April 2026. My lunch destination for now on!!! I am a charter customer eating my first meals in 1979 prior to joining the US Army and a few times a week once my brother retired from the US Army in 1995.

This of course until the relocation to Main & College St.

The Lunch Special #1 is my mainstay!!!“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“The best and crunchiest pizza I have ever had! First time having it and it will definitely be number one on my list! The sub was loaded with meat and super good too!“

“We were staying with friends in the area Friday night and decided to come here for dinner. Best pizza we have ever had and the atmosphere was great too“

“I love this place. So many good memories were made over a delicious slice of pizza. At one point in time I was fortunate enough to live nearby while in college. Unfortunately, that distance grew by several time zones soon after. Fortunately, my work occasionally brings me back to the area for a mandatory visit for the Smokin' Joe's crust and Spicey sauce.“

“Good pizza. Sausage was delicious 😋“

“After working with the front and back staff for over a year I get to see how everything is running as far as receiving all the foods and produce in the back I know everything is kept very clean and organized in a busy kitchen with all the preps and cooks working together. Out front we have a bunch of young awsome experienced ladies always working together and keeping all the customers Happy and Full. The Food and staffs are second to none😎“

“Best pizza in the entire WORLD“

“Nu voor de 3de keer in bouillon en het eten is iedere keer goed.zeker gezellig nu met het mooie buiten terras zeker een aanrader om heen te gaan als je in bouillon bent“

“Stopped in last night with a coworker to grab a slice and ended up trying the meatballs too! honestly some of the best Italian meatballs I've had in Columbus. Andrea was our server and she was fantastic. Super friendly, greeted us with a genuine smile, and just made the whole experience feel welcoming from the moment we walked in. You can tell she actually enjoys what she does. We'll definitely be back, and I've already been telling people about it. Great food and great service.“

“Great News to report. I graduated in 1991. Eagles Pizza was our hangout spot. I have lived away from Eagles Pizza for many. Dennis the owner is a great man. He is coming near where I live. And bringing the famous Taco Pizza. Try one!!! U rock Dennis and Eagles Pizza!!!“

“We ordered from the new store in Galloway, Ohio. Pizza and sub was very hot and delicious. I highly recommend trying their food.“

“Food is great however educate your staff on wines and cocktails. Also $63 for a hamburger fries, drink, and appetizers tip is getting ridiculous.“

“Amazing service and delicious food! We have been to multiple locations and they are all equally delicious!“

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“So much fun! Glad we had reservations so we had actual seats. I would hate to stand all night. Our server, Alexis, was phenomenal! Friendly, attentive, and when we asked for napkins bc of the condensation from our glasses causing our table to be wet, she went a step further and came back with a wet rag and cleaned our whole table!“

“Delicious pizza! I ordered the meat lovers pizza and their boneless wings. I absolutely loved it. The pizza tastes very good and has a lot of toppings. They aren’t cheap with the toppings. I will be back! The customer service was great. Pricey but worth it if you want a delicious pizza. This might be the best pizza I ever had in columbus“

“My husband and I wend here for the first time after moving our son into his apartment today and absolutely loved the food, the dining experience and the conversation with the owner while we sat at the bar watching our food be freshly made definitely 10 out of 10 and the fact that the ingredients are local and fresh was huge!!!“

“This was a delivery so I can’t comment on atmosphere. I ordered the Umami Bombi and added green peppers. The crust and white sauce were great and there was a good amount of mushrooms and shaved truffle on top. I was glad of the peppers and marinara dipping sauce because otherwise it would have been bland. I learned that I am a red sauce and multi-veggie lover more than a white pizza person.

The only snafu was the delivery person leaving the pizza on the sidewalk and not bothering to let me know that it had arrived and where it was. I have very limited mobility and I asked for it to be brought to my apartment door. I had to find someone to retrieve it from outside because I can’t manage the security doors and my walker or bend over to get the delivery off the ground. This was a Door Dash delivery. Choose Uber if you can.

Slammers refunded my money without my even asking for it. Essentially both Slammers and I lost out but the rotten delivery person got the tip. And please try Slammers pizza and other foods. You will enjoy them without a doubt.“

“Great food and people would Definitely go back“

“Not sure how this doesn't have five stars across the board. We drove from almost ten hours away and after scouring places to eat we decided to stop here. The crust is crisp, not soggy or tough with good flavor and thickness. You can't go wrong with fresh ingredients like the mozzarella and mushrooms (fresh not canned, wowee!) either. We also tried Gina's Gem and between the beautiful focaccia and the dip being creamy while also sweet with a small back burn to it, you really can't go wrong. The bar is a great place to sit, no spoilers, but the walls and shelves are filled with awesome and hilarious things that make good conversation. It's a shame this wonderful place is so far from home but we're hoping to make it a yearly tradition. Thanks for the great food, staff, and atmosphere!“

“Great meatballs!!!! Love the pizza.“

“The food is great - we’ve tried most of their pizzas and the antipasti salad is to die for. Unfortunately I can’t speak as highly about the staff. On several occasions, usually on Sundays when they close at 7, I’ve gotten my food close to 7 but NEVER after 7. I’ve placed orders for pick-up at 6:45 and if I wasn’t there at 6:45 on the dot I’ve been called being harassed to get my food because they close at 7. Today I went in at 6:50 and they had already put everything away, taken out the trash, and sanitized everything and gave me lip about wanting to place my order (1 pizza and 1 salad). They proceeded to loudly complain to each other while making my order. Closing at 7 means you stop taking customers at 7 - not that staff gets to walk out the door and lock it behind them at 7.“

“Good food pleasant environment.“

“I stopped in on my way home to order and pick up a 10" BBQ Chicken Pizza. The lady who took my order was very pleasant and efficient. The owner came through the dining area and stopped to tell me about the restaurant. I had planned to eat the pizza in the car on the way home, but it was so loaded with fresh and delicious ingredients that I was afraid that I would spill it on myself. I wisely decided to eat the pizza in my car in the parking lot. I really like BBQ chicken pizza, and this was the best I'd ever had.“

“If Robert Peyton likes your Pizza, I'll love your Pizza!!!“

“Classic Columbus Pizza! Worth the trip.“

“This crew knocks it out of the park every time.“

“The Don Corleone w/ sausage and my delicious date Judy.“

“The wings are amazing!!! The grape leaves are too! But the wings are done right. I am annoying. I ask for well done. Sauce on the side. They do that. Their well done wings are still juicy. Which is the right way! That you guys so much! Family run! Their pizza is Ohio pizza, (more so Columbus) which is good, just not my style. But by boyfriend and his friends loved it. I will go here weekly for the wings! They have other items I want to try and can’t wait to try them. We also got the baklava. That will be a later treat for tonight. You guys rock and your family is amazing. Love seeing family owned companies.“

“Thank You Mod Friends for making us always feel welcome and appreciated. In this very difficult time in our world you provide a clean safe place to enjoy great pizza and salads. We thank you for your kindness and thoughtfulness today. Merry Christmas ! Sandy and Cindy“

“We were so excited to try their new Jerome location, and it didn't disappoint! Their pepperoni is the best we've ever had, their Caesar salad was amazing and their loaded fries are definitely crave worthy. There was a bit of a hiccup with our reservation, but Rusty made it right, handling the situation with professionalism and kindness. We will definitely be JT regulars!“

“Love Dewey’s!! Their house salad is my favorite.“

“This is the best pizza in the Westerville area! We have been ordering from here for over 10 years. Today we had the first mistake ever with our pick up order. I called to explain and the manager Ryan was quick to offer many solutions and wanted to make sure they made it right. Mistakes happen. How you handle mistakes matters. One mistake by a busy pizza place in 10 years is best in the industry.
Great pizza and great customer service!“

“Ordered from the W. 3rd location lastnight. The food was great!! Fast delivery, food was hot on arrival and the price was good as well!! Definitely recommend!“

“I love Mexican food I recommend eating here. My family tried the beef and chicken birra enchiladas. We all loved it, even my three cats. 😋“

“This was our first visit to Figlio's in many years. (Was our daughter's favorite place when she was growing up here). We had a very nice evening. The food was as good as we remembered - two different pizzas. Our server was very helpful and attentive. The highlight was when we learned they still have the French Quarter Ice Cream Torte. Not to be missed. Hard for a restaurant to maintain such a consistent level of delivery over time. Congratulations!“

“Great pizza, always friendly staff“

“A huge shout out to Romeo’s for absolutely nailing my lunch order today! Everything was perfect!“

“Hit up this place based on a friend’s suggestion during a day trip to Columbus! Clean and casual atmosphere, reasonable prices, and amazing food!

The loaded fries, candied potatoes, and Mushroom Special pie were amazing! The Summer Heat pie was the best pizza my husband and I have ever had! And we do not deliver that praise lightly!

Staff was friendly. Service was timely. A delightfully kosher find in Central OH! My only regret is I forgot to take pictures!“

“Stopped in for pizza...it was amazing. We will definitely be back“

“Who can I message about our pizza tonight?“

“We've been ordering Frankie's for many years. It's our go to for guaranteed great pizza. The burnt ends are astounding! So good!! I'm not usually a fan of smoked food but the smoked wings are crazy good. Meaty with the perfect amount of seasoning. It's really hard to find good onion rings but theirs are better than anywhere else. Tried the Dub Sub (Italian sub with double meat and double cheese) tonight and it is the best Italian sub I've ever had. And the funnel cake fries - yum! The only problem is deciding which items to get when we order since we can only eat so much! 😀“

“Wonderful establishment. Wonderful staff. Delicious pizza. Anyone who says otherwise are clowns…“