50 Best Sandwich Shops near Brecksville

“On Tuesday, June 17th, 18 old ladies and gents "dropped in" for lunch, thinking arrangements had been made for us. Someone slipped up. The restaurant already had a healthy number of customers but the staff hustled tables, chairs, setups, etc. and in no time, we were soon seated and making our food choices. Instead of any of the staff having an "attitude", we were treated with Simon's usual good cheer. Bravo Simon's!“

“Our family meal deal to go was delicious and well packaged!!!“

“📍 Deanatella’s Italian Deli – Valley View, OH 🧀🍕🥖 A true hidden gem that screams classic Italian deli the second you walk in. If you can name the deli meat, trust us—they’ve got it. Shelves packed, fridges loaded, and a full lineup of Coke products to wash it all down. We stop here 2–3 times a month, and for good reason. The food never misses. Here's what we had today: 🍕 Pepperoni Pizza – 8.1/10 Hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. A crustless, center-cut slice of cheesy joy. No edge, no problem—it hits hard where it counts. 🍕 Sausage Pizza – 8.4/10 Same amazing base, but the sausage takes it up a notch. Big, juicy chunks of sausage packed with flavor. Definitely the MVP slice today. 🌶️ Mild Pepper Sub – 9.2/10 This one’s my go-to. Not super spicy, but absolutely loaded with flavor. The combo of peppers, melty cheese, and rich sauce makes for one giant, unforgettable sandwich. Perfect from the first bite to the last. The staff? Always friendly. The vibes? All Italian. If you’re anywhere near Cleveland, do yourself a favor and stop by Deanatella’s. You’ll thank yourself later. 🍽️ Two food lovers, one page—justifying our epic food binges, one bite at a time. Follow along at @joeandjrkfoodreviews for mouthwatering meals, honest scores, and the best hidden gems you need to try. Come hungry.“

“Was hearing so much about Charley's cheesesteak, the article in the Call and Post is what really pulled me in. Came and got Philly cheesesteak and Old school cheesesteak with classic lemonade, the sandwiches was delicious and the lemonade excellent. Will be returning. Welcome to the neighborhood 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽“

“Always hits the spot!
Honestly, you can't go wrong here. The steak is perfectly seasoned, and that melted provolone is the real deal. I’m a huge fan of the strawberry lemonade, too—it’s the perfect combo. It’s my go-to spot whenever I’m craving something filling and fast.“

“This is an excellent Mr. Hero. Very clean, good service, and friendly staff. Be sure to try their Jalapeño Poppers and online ordering.“

“This Mr. Hero’s gets a full 5 stars from me. They always make the food fresh whether I’ve gone in person or ordered through DoorDash. Sure, it can be a little pricey, but what fast food place isn’t these days? If I’m spending extra, I’d rather do it somewhere that serves higher quality meat instead of the mystery meat other spots use. Definitely recommend eating here.“

“It's fairly new, so while passing by, I decided to get a sandwich. It's pretty clean and has a nice roomy dining area! They put in a bullet-proof protection barrier, too! That's the 1st thing I noticed coming in the door. That's sad cause none of the other Charley's that I've been to don't have this feature lol. But its in the hood, so I dont blame them for being extra safe. My Food was fast and fresh,
My California sandwich was on point! I'm glad it replaced the nasty burger king!“

“This Penn Station is a go to for my family when we want a quick, affordable meal. The staff are always very friendly to us and I feel as if they genuinely care about our dining experience (which is rare these days). One time they forgot to pack my daughter's sandwich and before I had even realized what happened, they called me and gave us a free sandwich. I cannot think of a place in recent memory that went out of their way to own up to a mistake like that.
So if you're looking for good food that doesn't feel like you're getting ripped off, and quality customer service, I recommend this Penn Station.“

“Food was great, only reason I dropped a star was the $.50 they wanted for my ranch to go with the poppers. Should/ used to get one for free. I guess I understand getting charged more for extra. 2 people already cost $29 without drinks. ( 2 regular sandwiches, 1 fry, 1 popper.😑“

“The chicken salad was delicious. A nice large amount was distributed. Chicken wells seasoned very good . I noticed the mushrooms were canned, not fresh. You can tell the difference. Instead of putting certain items on your salad, you may want it on the side, for example, jalapeno peppers, pickles, etc.. they will charge you for putting those items in a side cup. I didn't agree with that, the choice of salad dressings, you can get those on the side free. If you want an egg on your salad you have to pay for it. I've noticed lots of great things on the menu. I will continue to go back there and also try new things as well. The overall price, I think, is reasonable. The customer service was great and pretty fast.“

“We ordered subs for our high school bball team. Ryan and his team went above and beyond to get our boys fed even offering early pickup before opening to get us to the game on time. The food was well prepared, packaged and delicious. Thank you for your great service and the extra goodies we can’t wait until you come to Valpo so we can visit more often!“

“Clean. Friendly. Letter from owner on wall said it well. They appreciate our business: nothing less than great product, happy service and clean environment is acceptable

Vegetarian options: More would be better. Would visit more often if more unique options.“

“2 people working a buttload of customer's and everyone was takin care of quickly we had the value pack and the order was correct and made in good time. So thx for a giid experience and friendly service and giid food. A right around the corner customer 😁“

“I love going into this subway all the workers I get they give me the best service. I love the random sandwiches I get when I go in there I the workers make me a random sandwich. I will keep going back there for any subway sandwiches I want to get.“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“This is the best Mr hero! Growing up always loved Mr hero. Used to eat from there every Friday when dad got paid as a kid lol. In all the years, I have found that this particular location is my favorite . Excellent with food! Very clean place! And friendly staff. Every single time!“

“Awesome little deli. I have not had anything there that I did not like. I would definitely recommend it!“

“This is the best cheese steak I EVER had!!! ❤️❤️❤️“

“I had just visited this subway on monday. Everytime i come in the service is below average.
The service was so well, these girls really know customer service skills. I had asked the girls their names and it was maddie and bella. Will definitely start coming in more often if the service continues this way.“

“The guy working was extremely nice as can be everything is always good the stores always clean and fresh ? best subway still for years and years“

“!! Phenomenal !!
We ordered The Incredible Dave sub. It was delicious and would definitely recommend for Die hard fan of Sub. Portion sizes were amazing and Staff was Very Very friendly. Price is very reasonable for size of sub. Place was very clean. We will be back soon.“

“My first time to any Jimmy John's. Guy behind the counter was really nice. Good food. Will definitely be back. 4 stars.“

“I was here on 10-11-25 after a previous negative experience and both the service and food were outstanding. There was a team member working in the grill area who noticed me waiting and asked the front counter person to find out what I was waiting for. I hadn't been waiting long, but it was nice to know that they were paying attention. My food was fresh, which I appreciated because I previously had cold fries and overly toasted bread. I felt like a valued customer and I hope they keep this standard of service.“

“Placed an order for 4 sandwiches. Each was special order and they were ALL perfect and delicious. They were friendly and welcoming…will DEFINITELY go again.

Vegetarian options: PESCATARIAN

Dietary restrictions: Tomatoes, onions,peppers lettuces restricted and veggie sub was GREAT for a pescatarian.“

“Great food!! I like that they remodeled it!!!!!!!“

“Always get the Philly sammich, sometimes it's better than other times, but for the most part they're consistent and one of our regular spots, the kids even like they're subs, so that's saying something because they're picky eaters! 😊 This last time, they forgot my sub, I called and they said they'd have it ready in 10 minutes and they loaded it, it was definitely one of the better subs, maybe it was because I was more hungry from the wait or the anticipation 🤷, but whatever the case, it was good. We usually get a large fry and it feeds the 4 of us well, so it's a perfect size, I'm not crazy about how they put them in a cup with napkins on top because the top layer always sticks to the napkins and they get cold quickly, so it wouldn't hurt if they actually came up with a better container to put them in, but I still order them, they remind me if fair fries! 😊“

“Oh my goodness! So hot, fresh and good!!! Love their fish and chips. I grew up eating this and it’s so good. Anytime we come to Cuyahoga Falls we stop and get this. Amazing food. Brings back childhood memories. It was down the street in Barberton growing up and we had it often.“

“The sandwich artists at Toasty Subs make the most epic sandwiches. The food is fresh, the prep looks clean. I'm always happy to visit this area. Atmosphere is only three stars because, well, it's a gas station, not a dine-in experience.“

“Good place to eat nice staff, and great sandwiches.“

“HORRIBLE! Waited over an hour for COLD, SOGGY, inedible NASTY food! The pics they post look yummy...mine look like hog slop!“

“This was my first visit here and I must say I am impressed. I ordered online and picked up through their drive thru window. My order was actually done before the time given & the order was correct. The food was very good and seemed to be very good quality. The girl at the window was nice and greeted us with a smile. I will definitely be visiting again. Good quality food for a good price.“

“Tuna flat bread wrap is delicious. A foot long cookie is very good and plenty. Nice and clean environment. Quick and friendly service.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of veggies.

Parking: Plenty of parking

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Very open for wheel chair accessibility“

“We enjoyed our visit.The prices are just tad high.The food was really good though,and I liked the cheese sauce withmy waffle fries.The man who took our order wasnice and helpful.The lobby REALLY could have usedsome attention as all of the tables weredirty and trash was scattered around.It sure is a busy place as well.Oh, by the way, they've got lemonade and fruit punch. If you mix 2 parts lemonade and 1 part fruit punch... you get Sweetarts.?“

“I go to this particular location because the manager Jeannie is always so friendly and the food is always consistently great. The store is clean and I rarely have a wait. There is a closer location that I could go to however the manager there was rude and I noticed that there pricing was way higher then this location. I highly recommend this particular location on brookpark rd.“

“This location is the best to me I have 2 different other Mr Hero's near me on is not even a mile away in Shaker his the other is on Miles rd about 2 miles I will never eat there ever again the taste is not how I remember it but I was leaving work and decided to take a chance on this location North Randle and me and my wife was NOT disappointed love it and well worth the drive“

“First time ever trying a Mr Hero. Had a medium Hot Buttered Cheese steak. Waffle fries.(Like Chic-fil-lay) And a soda. 15$ fast service. Clean, well lit place. (You can dine in) Men's room had a sign saying "out of order" although a male employee used it...food was hot and flavorful. Not a bad experience.“

“The best Subway in the area if you really need a Subway sandwich & their cookies. Daughter enjoys a good Italian sub at this location only. Veggies and meat are always fresh, never suspicious and worried about quality here... They seem to care!“

“I work in sales in the area and I visit the owners of Mr. Heros frequently in the Slavic Village area and they are very nice and accommodating. I always order ahead of time for our lunch-ins and they always surpass my expectations. Fantastic food and friendliness every time! Thanks for putting up with our huge orders! Happy Holidays!“

“We don’t live in OH anymore but every time we come back to visit we come to Mr hero’s at least every other meal. We absolutely love this place and unfortunately they are only in OH. This location is very friendly and the food is on point every time. Please expand into my states please.“

“great food! unique recipes, Romanburger rules.“

“The workers were really nice with the owner being very talkative. The food is to die for. They do speak a different language however they didn’t say anything bad about me in that language as I also know how to speak it. All they said were questions on whose orders were ready to hand out. I would highly recommend.“

“#bestbakerrrrrrrrrrr @Bre“

“We love this place food and service is on pint it taste great and the service is great love it will go back every eeek“

“Amazing they're still around. My dad was their accountant in 1952 and as a two year old I'd tag along to work with him on Saturdays. Now I don't have a great memory from 1952, but it sure looks like the same complex. My dad worked and I drank a bunch of juice out of 1/2 gallon glass bottles.“

“I hadn't had Subway in a while, so I decided to go and have the Chicken, Bacon Ranch sandwich on the Italian cheddar bread. My sandwich was bangin. The staff was really nice and she made my sandwich so neat. I will go there for my Subway crave.“

“Visiting the area or just want a delicious burger? ABSOLUTELY one of a kind!! This is the only place to get a Roman burger ?, One of the best by far burgers in town. From my first day Visiting Ohio I go straight here and before I leave I go straight here. This is a must go to must try burger and I promise you will absolutely Love this burger spot. Prepared fresh as you order and the taste is a unique local favorite. I grew up eating them. No other state has this particular style burger. It is the best by far burger in town. Locals Love it and so do I ❤. D E L I C I O U S !!!! ?“