50 Best Sandwich Shops near Brooklyn

“We ordered subs for our high school bball team. Ryan and his team went above and beyond to get our boys fed even offering early pickup before opening to get us to the game on time. The food was well prepared, packaged and delicious. Thank you for your great service and the extra goodies we can’t wait until you come to Valpo so we can visit more often!“

“Fresh off the plane I placed on order in the app. My order was ready within minutes and everything fresh and hot. The gentleman who assisted me was very polite and friendly from the time I walked in. My food was everything I remember when I lived here.“

“Great gluten free bread! Big thank you to the employee making the sandwiches, sorry didn’t get your name. I appreciate you taking my allergy seriously and removing your gloves to wash your hands before putting on fresh gloves!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free bread“

“📍 Deanatella’s Italian Deli – Valley View, OH 🧀🍕🥖 A true hidden gem that screams classic Italian deli the second you walk in. If you can name the deli meat, trust us—they’ve got it. Shelves packed, fridges loaded, and a full lineup of Coke products to wash it all down. We stop here 2–3 times a month, and for good reason. The food never misses. Here's what we had today: 🍕 Pepperoni Pizza – 8.1/10 Hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. A crustless, center-cut slice of cheesy joy. No edge, no problem—it hits hard where it counts. 🍕 Sausage Pizza – 8.4/10 Same amazing base, but the sausage takes it up a notch. Big, juicy chunks of sausage packed with flavor. Definitely the MVP slice today. 🌶️ Mild Pepper Sub – 9.2/10 This one’s my go-to. Not super spicy, but absolutely loaded with flavor. The combo of peppers, melty cheese, and rich sauce makes for one giant, unforgettable sandwich. Perfect from the first bite to the last. The staff? Always friendly. The vibes? All Italian. If you’re anywhere near Cleveland, do yourself a favor and stop by Deanatella’s. You’ll thank yourself later. 🍽️ Two food lovers, one page—justifying our epic food binges, one bite at a time. Follow along at @joeandjrkfoodreviews for mouthwatering meals, honest scores, and the best hidden gems you need to try. Come hungry.“

“love this place...great staff, quick grab and go nutrition and yummy goodness every time. best vegan spot in the area.“

“great food! cozy street atmosphere!“

“Best of the best! Live in Youngstown but everytime we travel for work, it is a guaranteed stop for our team. The staff is great and the food is beyond consistent if that makes any sense. The bread is unique but familiar. Have a hard time not getting the turkey so I’ll usually snag a sandwich for when I get home. DONT SLEEP ON THIS PLACE AND IF THE LINE IS BUSY KEEP CALLING IF ITS NOT PAST 2pm. Good chance they are sold out if that’s the case 😉“

“On Tuesday, June 17th, 18 old ladies and gents "dropped in" for lunch, thinking arrangements had been made for us. Someone slipped up. The restaurant already had a healthy number of customers but the staff hustled tables, chairs, setups, etc. and in no time, we were soon seated and making our food choices. Instead of any of the staff having an "attitude", we were treated with Simon's usual good cheer. Bravo Simon's!“

“I have been buying here since the beginning of this year. Food is amazing. Customer service is great. They do everything with such a pleasure and happiness it brings joy!! Totally recommend if you want to eat in a good place where is clean and you feel safe. Totally recommend.“

“I never thought I'd have another italian sub sandwich again after I stopped eating meat in the late '90s (yeah, people can do it for that long and still be alive. Amazing, right?). And then I saw that Dave's Cosmic Subs has vegan options. Well now I'm enjoying them again thanks to this place. I can't believe I've waited this long to try anything from them, but I'm making up for it now.“

“The food here is so good and so reasonable! My son had the lamb Gyro and he could not stop raving about it! The rest of our party had breakfast sandwiches and they made them fresh right in front of you and I specifically said I only wanted bacon if it could be crispy, very few restaurants understand what crispy bacon is supposed to be But they nailed it! He told me he would make sure it was crispy and it was the best. He cracked the egg in a pan right in front of us went into a little oven and it absolutely perfect. We ate there in the morning before going to the football game and we highly recommend West 3rd Deli!!!“

“Excellent fresh ingredients! Try the edgewater hero ! Delish. Friendly Staff!“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“I don't know who manages this Charley's😋on Broadway Avenue in the hood but I tell y'all this....their food is always HOT&FRESH to order. The customer service is 💯. The food is Delish!!!
Charley's is the BEST restaurant in that area. The one on Lee Road need help.... Young Stunners keep up the Great!!! customer service. To the owner those young adults rep Charley's to the fullest. Give them a raise will I give them a Praise for Excellence❤“

“Consistently 5 stars! The food quality is excellent. The customer service is excellent. The restaurant is always clean.

Every time I visit. Regardless of who's working. This place is the standard by which I judge other fast food restaurants.“

“They have hired amazing staff here! Second time I ordered once I dined in second time ordered online and both times my food was hot and ready and every topping you see in the ads are actually on their sandwiches I’m surprised! Friendly staff and they actually add every topping to their sandwiches you see in the ads ! And affordable pricing, i recommend this location way better than south park mall“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“My wife and I eat there once a week as a date for us the staff is awesome and the food is great,they do a wonderful job there great great service!“

“We arrived early and enjoyed the very nice calamari appetizer at the bar as part of a really nice happy hour. We were then taken to our table with wonderful views of the lake and Cleveland skyline. Melissa was a wonderful server and had some great wine pairing recommendations for our meal. The food was outstanding. A very enjoyable dinner for our special night.“

“Literally dining here as I write this. We go to Penn station all the time and this is the best service we’ve had. Such friendly employees working here today, and our subs are perfect!! And hot, fresh fries to go with them. Great job! Fast food workers aren’t generally the kindest but these guys are great. ?“

“Every time I come here I’m very pleased with my overall experience! Tim and Jacob are the best! They took great care in making my sandwich, and they also were very calm and collected under the pressure of a rush which can be difficult for a lot of people within the industry! I appreciate the staff for always being cool and welcoming ~ it really goes a long way :)“

“Served by 777 on 09/05
The staff member was nice, attentive and quick. She handled everything so smoothly. I didn't have cash on hand to leave a tip unfortunately but she definitely deserved one.
The store is clean and tidy. Everyone there does a tremendous job.“

“I just want to give a big thumbs 👍 up, I've been here 5-6 times and it never disappoints, Today I ordered the small original cheese steak as I was waiting on my sandwich and it was accidentally given to another customer, so they upgraded my sandwich to a large and gave me a free Fry, That's what you call great people working there and you guys didn't have to do that I understand mistakes happen, Thank you“

“This location has friendly staff and the food has always been cooked well. The location and outside leaves much to be desired but since the food is good we don't care as much about the outside 😆. Most likely you will want to get food through the drive-thru or order on the app and pick it up.“

“had the steak and cheese and it was excellent, along with a cup of chili.. mm 😋“

“I liked it here. I got the BBLT w/o tomato’s and it was pretty good, 4/5 for the chicken noodle soup and they have a lot of different options you can choose from ! 8/10 for the peach juice (in photo) a little sugary but typical juice yk. I love the different varieties of beverages to select from! I am a big ice fan so I was a little disappointed their ice machine was down but I understand. Both take out and dine in portions matched. No wait ! I will b back“

“Just tried this great little sandwich shop in Ohio City, and we were so impressed! They were extra careful with my husband’s celiac needs and made the BEST chicken salad sandwiches we’ve ever had. The best kind of messy! The kids’ sandwiches were perfect too. Thanks, Little Cloud!“

“People r nice n food is great I would go here🍔🍟👍“

“Hanini Subs on Woodland isn’t just another sandwich shop—it’s a neighborhood staple. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the energy: the grill sizzling, the staff moving with purpose, and customers who clearly know this is the place to be. The subs are stacked heavy, the corned beef is legendary, and the loaded fries are the kind of comfort food that hits every time.“

“2 people working a buttload of customer's and everyone was takin care of quickly we had the value pack and the order was correct and made in good time. So thx for a giid experience and friendly service and giid food. A right around the corner customer 😁“

“The best Subway in the area if you really need a Subway sandwich & their cookies. Daughter enjoys a good Italian sub at this location only. Veggies and meat are always fresh, never suspicious and worried about quality here... They seem to care!“

“Was very good! We will be back!“

“I worked out in strongsville for 4 years but left for another job in cleveland. Started back at my old job recently in strongsville and stopped here for lunch and the lady behind the counter remembered me and my order lol. Very nice lady, food is always good!“

“My first time at DiBellas, got a 10 inch tuna sub at the Strongsville shop today, it's huge! Good fresh tuna, fresh toppings (I got provolone cheese, mayo, oil, lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumber) but kind of bland because no seasoning and couldn't really taste the onions. The Asiago bread was good. Forgot to ask for salt/pepper because it wasn't listed as an option on their in-store menu. On my way out I asked about it and they said salt and pepper are in packets that they keep behind the counter. I think they should at least have salt pepper listed as an option on their signs.“

“Went there yesterday to get tobacco and tubes somehow every time I go go there lately the price of my hot rod tubes go from 2.19/2.49/4.31 yesterday, I’m on a fixed income !! The tobacco hasn’t changed but if the owner/manager isn’t there they charge me what ever they want“

“Stopped for a Cheesesteak meal today, 4/22/23 around 5pm. Everything was cooked just right, and delicious. I'll certaintly be going back. Also, staff very friendly and restaurant very clean. Thanks!“

“Wow what a amazing person
U have running this place definitely a asset
One of the nicest kindest on it employee after I told him my order for me and my wife he was on it I watched him from start 2 finish if I had a shop he would be the 1st person I would hire ,, my wife and I will be back his name was Jim his last name I could not pronounce even if I tried ,, this guy definitely needs a raise he was handling the whole kitchen on his own“

“Claudia & Tory served us and they were so welcoming and friendly!!! Before we even got our food, I told my husband, we’re definitely coming back here! Would absolutely recommend !!!! Plus it smelled so good and was nice and clean when we walked in!“

“The guy working was extremely nice as can be everything is always good the stores always clean and fresh ? best subway still for years and years“

“great sandwiches. very nice customer service“

“I've always enjoyed this Mr. Hero location. I love the Roman Burger with waffle fries and of course you got to have the cheese sauce with the fries. It hit the spot today. The staff has always been helpful and it's a nice area if you want to enjoy your meal inside. I will say the food is hit or miss at times on when it’s ready so it’s hard to tell if it’s busy or not but other than that it’s good.“

“Great place. 9 out of 10 times you'll get good food. That 1 time you don't and the sandwich under performs for the price is expected in the fast food industry. One thing they lack is service. I generally order online and when I pickup the employees never greet you, just look at you, say your name, get the food, leave. All without them saying a single word. If they do talk they are mostly rude, unless you get the normal woman employee who runs counter sometimes. She's really pleasant. Overall I def recommend.“

“I love eating at Mr. Hero in the mall. The manager is always so nice and always has a smile on his face. The food is always hot and fresh, and the service is quick. Everyone is friendly, and I always have a great experience. I definitely recommend this place!I love eating at Mr. Hero in the mall. The manager is always so nice and always has a smile on his face. The food is always hot and fresh, and the service is quick. Everyone is friendly, and I always have a great experience. I definitely recommend this place!“

“Just had the brisket sandwich. It was delicious. Thank you. It was just as good as I remembered. I need to stop in more often.“

“Cheese steak was delicious. Lady at the counter was friendly and prompt.

Update as of July 2023.
I come to this particular Charlie's cheese steak location as much as possible. Quick, friendly service. My order has never been wrong and I asked for no mushrooms every time. I probably been here 50 times. The app is 100% legit, I'd probably have to say it's the number two maybe three of all fast food apps that I've used behind Chick-fil-A only. Charlie's rewards is on par with any other fast food at and every single time you come here they're offering free stuff with the purchase of a cheesesteak whether it's fries or a milkshake or buy one get one milkshakes or buy one get one cheese steaks etc...“

“I love going into this subway all the workers I get they give me the best service. I love the random sandwiches I get when I go in there I the workers make me a random sandwich. I will keep going back there for any subway sandwiches I want to get.“

“The sandwich artists at Toasty Subs make the most epic sandwiches. The food is fresh, the prep looks clean. I'm always happy to visit this area. Atmosphere is only three stars because, well, it's a gas station, not a dine-in experience.“

“This Subway in my opinion is by far the best in the city, It’s always kept clean and the presentation is always on top. The employees are always very nice and inviting, And my food is always great, my personal favorite is the tuna! I definitely recommend the store!“

“Whoever made order number 26 today should be in charge of making all the chicken bacon ranch sandwiches. At 6 months pregnant, all I want are these sandwiches. They went above and beyond for me today as I accidentally ordered two sandwiches. A refund, I got to keep my second sandwich, and it’s the best one I’ve ever had, you made my day.“