35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Buckeye Lake

“all the employees and people who delivered my food are the sweetest most kind hearted people you could ever ask for. They always go out of their way to give you exactly what you want“

“Moved to Pataskala 3 weeks ago. We met my niece and nephew at Pizza Cottage, my nephew’s suggestion from previous visits. We ordered 3 different pizzas. All amazing! Even reheated ar home, wonderful! We’ll be back for sure!!“

“driving home from OSU, Wexer, remembering that when our daughter lived at Miller sport, we loved this pizza 🍕. ate inside, lots of people waiting for take, a lot of delivery orders going out, and yet we got our pizza and salad in less than 20 minutes...hot and wonderful.“

“Great wood fired pizza and service.“

“Friendly staff, and great pizza.“

“The best in Licking County!“

“It’s great food!!!!! Check it out you won’t be disappointed!!!!“

“I was born in Queens NY, and then moved to PA outside of Philly when I was around 9. The pizza from that was is just out of this world, and when I moved to Ohio I was so sad because honestly every place I’ve tried pizza I’ve been disappointed. I will note that I am also Italian so I’m a stickler about pizza 😂 On a whim yesterday My husband, kids and myself decided to give Christy’s a try. It was such a cozy atmosphere for starters. Every single thing we ordered was fresh hot and sooooooo tasty. There was a little bit of a mix up with my husbands calzone, but they made him a new one very fast and took care of us! He said it was absolutely delicious and he is a very picky man. The pizza was THE BEST PIZZA I have ever had in my 5 years of living in Ohio now. I honestly will never eat pizza from anywhere ever again, also very affordable prices! With every bite I just kept saying wow this is so good 😭 We will 100 percent be recommending to all our family and friends! Thank you so much!! You have earned forever customers“

“Creno's Pizza Company is a longtime old-school pizzeria chain. The pepperoni pizza is so good! his is the best spot near SPI Spot. You can always try nicely cooked Pepperoni, pizza salads and blt - a special offer of this pizzeria. Creno's provides food delivery for the convenience of its clients. Classic crust with sweet sauce and toppings that go edge to edge.“

“We had a great experience at Champs! I did an early call in a group of about 20 ( lunch between baseball games) and they said they would open the back room for us! They made sure to know how much time we had, suggested items off the menu and the food came out quickly! We appreciated it so much! Our server and the manager made we were all taken care of the entire time! We will be adding Champs to our go to restaurant!“

“Food was AMAZING!! The cheese pizza was very cheesy, thin and garlic crust. Flavor was superb. I got the pickle pizza and added chicken on a cauliflower crust. Best cauliflower crust around!! Think and crispy cauliflower crust. I also got a keto bowl for tomorrow. I can't wait to try that masterpiece!! I will def be back soon. There are so many menu options, I want to try them all!!!!“

“Too Talls hands down has some of the best pizza in Newark Ohio 🫶🫶🫶“

“We ate in the restaurant on our way home. Good food, good staff. Cute place. Friendly people.“

“Definitely one of the best Pub atmosphere with phenomenal food. Pizza , Burgers , Onion Rings, Fresh Cut Fries and more“

“We love their pizza and get at least one a week good stuff!“

“Always amazing, thank you!“

“Edit: We went back, two weekends in a row. Picked a few different topping combinations and everything was top notch. Upped those stars from 4 to 5.

There isn't a lot of good pizza around Granville. Some friends turned us on to Cristy's. We made the trek down there to try it out and it was great. The crust wasn't too thin, sauce and toppings were tasty. And the bake was perfect.

The only reason this is a 4 and not a 5 is because I need to go back for round two and try a couple different options.“

“Dirko’s provided outstanding assistance providing food for a local family. With a short notice. Their employee’s were extremely helpful and the pizzas were delicious. If you’ve not tried Dirko’s, give them a call. Thanks so much! Kim ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I love their thick crust pep/cheese. The sauce is sweet reminds me of Planks in Columbus, Ohio. I will order pizza and subs the next time!!!“

“Great hometown loving atmosphere of all Licking County Schools and any other sports game on your docket! The bartenders and servers are top notch, A+…..serving any drink of your desire. My personal menu preferences and those I can personally recommend are: the salads! 🥗 I am not a commercial ranch fan, but their homemade ranch is superb. I usually “hate” ranch, but could drink this one straight! The pot roast sub, ham and cheese sub, and the Italian sub are fantastic and always reliable. I’ve also had the fish sandwich and it’s pretty darn tasty too. I know Don & Sue’s Pizza is known for the pizza 🍕….but don’t underestimate the wings. Love them. And the cheesey garlic bread and side of the authentic pizza sauce is my absolute FAVORITE. Can’t ever get away with starting with that! Enjoy!“

“Michael's pizza has been a favorite for over 20 years while this hard-working family has grown their business into something memorable. I tell everyone their Philly steak sandwich is my favorite in the world. Get it toasted well done and you won't forget it!“

“Absolutely love the pizza and salads. our delivery orders always arrive quickly and are piping hot. We even got a surprise upgrade with our order tonight. My family and I highly reccomend.“

“Best pizza in town! I highly recommend the 8 square. I think I could eat this everyday! Employees are always friendly and truly make you feel like they are glad to have you as a customer. I find this rare and very refreshing.Jamison is always so happy and friendly. It is contagious. I can tell he loves his job.“

“Amazing pizza every time for a really good price“

“the food and the people are awesome“

“We were looking for a good place to eat an early dinner on our way home from a trip to the Wilds, and decided to stop here. It looks like the usual hole in the wall from outside, but the food is excellent and the service was great too. I had a taco pizza and my husband had a sausage omelet with a biscuit and gravy on the side. Breakfast for dinner is always a treat, and the gravy was definitely homemade and very, very good! Taco pizza was delicious also. Vibe was chill and a band was playing outside. Would absolutely stop here any time we are in the area.“

“Great pizza, friendly service and very reasonable prices!“

“We have been there three times now and everything has been delicious. The meatballs are delicious and we have had them as an appetizer, on a sub, and on a pizza. The tomato sauce on the pizzas is the best pizza sauce I have had in a long time. Plus the service is amazing! Everyone is so kind and helpful. We will be back soon because I want to try every speciality pizza.“

“Awesome experience tonight all around for a special night with our girls! Tracy and Michelle made things extra special. Service, food and all around environment was great! Thank you“

“Great service indoor ordering“

“Love their chef salads and boneless barbecue wings. And I love the fact they stay open until 4am. When every one else in this town has closed before 11pm, they dear to be different and stay open all night . Thanks for caring enough about us third shifters so we have some where to grab a meal on are way home from work.“

“The best in Newark!“

“Excellent Pizza 🍕 Good fast delivery!YAY I didn't have to cook dinner! With a 50% Off WITH Vip CERTIFICATE... Thanks for the certificate I got in the mail. Two XL pizzas for the one price!🍕“

“The team at the Donatos, under the leadership of Brian, did an incredible job preparing pizzas for our recent large catering order. We could not be more impressed. He was easy, quick and concise with all the communication leading up to the event. When we arrived to pick it up, all the pizzas were ready, fresh and hot, with easy boxes for transporting as well as plates and napkins. We could not recommend them enough, and had an easy Friday night thanks to their hard work.“

“Best burger in Licking county! Do yourself a favor and order the Crossroads burger. This bad boy comes with their amazing homemade sauce that adds a little kick and sets it apart. Pair it up with the fresh cut fries and don't forget to wash all that deliciousness down with an ice cold draft beer. Fantastic staff and family atmosphere one not to miss.“