33 Best Sandwich Shops in Dayton

“I got the Tony and it was excellent. The menu is limited, might want to expand sandwich choices even just using different combinations of the same meats / cheeses and toppings. Sides and salads are limited, again might want to look at expanding. The grocery concept, I get it biggest complaint of downtown residents is lack of a grocery store. There selection is limited and didnt look like they covered the basics. I would either get in or out of thar business and maybe focus on being a sandwich shop.“

“We ordered takeaway for Thanksgiving, and everything was cooked to perfection—the lasagne, brie, and olive cake were outstanding. The flavors were exquisite, and the staff was friendly and very service-oriented. Parking downtown Dayton was easy, and we’ll definitely be back.“

“Good food reasonable prices. Good service. The German potato salad is awesome Good“

“Great friendly service, exxxcellent food and cocktails. Reasonable prices and happy hour! Jake, the manager personally engages and wants to ensure you have a great experience.“

“Always great subs and fast service !! 🙂“

“Hey
I was having an awful day. My life has been unraveling in EVERY way. However the woman that made my #7 made the difference. OMG very polite professional truly a woman of God. She and her crew made the difference. They all deserve 20 days of PTO a raise and promotion

Couldn't end without paying homage to my home town tho...see picture below.

Happy New Year
Happy Sandwich 🥪“

“Enjoyed hanging with friends playing bingo and laughing. Wings were awesome“

“If you like Penn Station's food, this location is almost always on point. You'll wait for the food to be done, but no more than about other PS location. The inside is always clean, staff is kind and efficient. You won't regret stopping here.“

“This is become my new Subway since my old one got bought out and all the workers were replaced with the family of the new owners if you know what I'm saying. I've been right here before and the food is always good they're always fast they're always friendly and it's a great group of workers. So now I have to drive a little more but that's okay.“

“Highly recommend! Great food and service!“

“I love the Godfather’s sub cold but today it fell short of the standard. I ordered as usual with light mayo and oil. It came with mustard and no oil, also quantity of lettuce and tomato were light. Disappointed mustard ruined it!“

“The beauty behind the counter I'd astounding. Sitting here waiting to pick up food and watching yall uplift each other has been the highlight of my year. I love the tough love and the comrade mindset. The food was good too but I know that I'll come back 100x over knowing what's behind making my food. Hardworking love.“

“We go here about once a week and every time its perfect! Subs are amazing and their fries are underrated. Always pleasant people working the counter too!
Probably hard to do so in this economy but the place definitely needs a remodel, but thats about it!“

“This is the only penn station I will eat at . Being a recent agm at another location.. this store really knows how to push food through.. friendly , helping, and clean. Everytime we come in here .. greetings everytime! Today i have been checked on by 5 different workers including mangt. when leaving .. thank you have a great day. These days those values are tossed in the dirt but the management team here . Blue ,maroon and red shirts are all professional. Including the workers . Thank you for being a great place to eat.“

“I gotta say the past few years this location really went downhill and in the past two months the turnaround has been quite impressive. This location couldn’t even remember cheese on a sandwich before. And haven’t had any issue in A Few months now keep up the great work“

“On 9/7/24 after 2pm a female worker that was darkskin and I think she had dreadlocs serviced me. From the very beginning she was polite. She was very professional and patient and made my sandwich perfectly. I must say the location was very clean, fully stocked and organized. By the end of my transaction I was happy to leave a tip. Even the other workers that later came out had smiles on their faces! Very clean great service highly recommended“

“My fiancé and I went on Saturday night and IT WAS AMAZING! I’ve never been to this restaurant before and I will be coming back! The food was fresh and delicious! The staff was super friendly and professional. The restaurant was clean as well, we loved the paintings on the walls and the atmosphere was awesome!“

“I absolutely love Super Subby's and this location has quickly become my favorite. Real nice and polite employees. Conveniently located on the way to a Flyers game. Looking forward to many more subs with kids eat free before seeing great basketball 🏀;)“

“I ordered a 4 cheese, and they brought me a ham and cheese. It was still delicious. I'll be happy when we can get rid of these masks and actually understand each other. I will also be happy when you can put the mayo packets out. I had to wait a long time to get it. Had a received the grilled cheese that I actually ordered, I wouldn't have needed mayo.“

“This Jimmy John’s location is excellent! The staff is fast, friendly, and always gets the order right. My sandwich was super fresh, well-made, and came out incredibly quick — exactly what you expect from Jimmy John’s at its best. The store is clean and well-organized, and the overall service feels consistently reliable. Definitely one of the better Jimmy John’s locations I’ve visited. Highly recommended!“

“Picture this. I am exhausted after my shift, starved, desperate. I decide to doordash from this Subway establishment. A Subway Club with mayo, garlic aioli, and parmesan vinaigrette. A good sandwich that I trust from Subways. What arrives isn’t a good sandwich, it’s the best sandwich I have ever had in my life !!!! Generous sauces, delish meats, soft and sweet bread. Whoever made that sandwich you made my day, MY YEAR! I hope every single employee gets a raise. Never in my life will I doubt this store. This is the place where happiness is real and true. I love you Subway sandwich maker.“

“This is either a hit or miss, no in between. They absolutely never give me my double chocolate chip cookies, and they never call me to tell me they ran out. The give me some nasty oatmeal crap substitute and that's just not acceptable.“

“I went in there during a shift I had at the Vaporhaus next door, and the staff was incredibly friendly and even had the veggie patties that are so hard to find. Everything was fast, courteous, and tasted great. Will certainly be going back again.“

“After watching an episode of the Foods that Built America that included Blimpie and Subway I wondered if there was still a Blimpie around because I hadn’t had it years. At first I was let down when I saw it was in a gas station but I went anyway and was pleasantly surprised. The station and restaurant look to be family owned and operated and were extremely clean inside. I ordered a sub and the meat and cheese was sliced fresh in front of me. This was actually better than I remembered Blimpie being when I was younger. The bread was thick and fresh and they used to use premade rolls and pre sliced meat. They used to be about like Subway only slightly better. This was far better than any Subway. It was actually right in line with Jersey Mikes. I definitely recommend going here. They aren’t very busy so I fear it will close from lack of traffic but that would be a shame because it’s absolutely delicious.“

“first time eating here , had the tuna sub , & highly recommend it. it was delicious“

“Ordered online for pickup on a Friday at 710 and was given a pickup of 730. Because it was Friday night, I gave it a little buffer (based on my map history I arrived 738p). There was only one car in line and no one inside except workers so figured I'd get served right away, the other car pulled away almost immediately, but it still too until 750. The workers were very friendly, the food came out exactly as ordered, and I didn't have anything to rush for so it wasn't a big deal but it was a bit excessive for the lack of other customers/ business.“

“I am not a local to Dayton so, I haven’t tried super Subbys. Decided to drive through a location with a drive thru. The woman taking the order was very friendly & patient with me. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich & a side salad. The sandwich was delicious, loved the mayonnaise. Side salad was also pretty large & tasted fresh. Prices comparable to chain sub places. #supportlocal.“

“Tried making an order over the phone but they were having difficulties. I decided to just go in. They were very nice and welcoming when I came in. I wish I had got the older guys name because he was very sweet and apologized for the wait. Which I was okay with because they were hit pretty hard at some point with everyone coming in. Thank you for being so nice, definitely made my rough week better!“

“My favorite Freaky Fast place 😍“

“We have come to love Penn station subs this is our closest location so obviously our most visited. Never have we been disappointed, maybe wondered why this time the mayo is in excess or is there hardly any lettuce etc.. consistency could be worked in. Sammich are always good and craveable enough to be back. Like that we can order in a salad to help with keto meals when that’s our goal.
They are always busy and perhaps that’s the why consistency lacks from time to time.“

“The sandwiches were great. The Dagwood and turkey w provolone lettuce,tomatoes, red onions w vinegar, and oil. The fries you must have. ?

Parking: You can have your meal come to you in the parking lot. Please try this place. ?“

“I went on 6/26/25 and it was pouring down rain. There was a puddle of water on the floor with no wet floor sign. I took a while to review the new menu and wanted to an Italian BMT however I wanted to substitute the ham for turkey. I asked the girl and if this was possible and she thought about it and then said she couldn’t do it. Since when was it made to where meats couldn’t be substituted or that I couldn’t customize my sandwich the way I wanted? I couldn’t even do it through the app or remove anything. What if someone is allergic to something? Do they still have to get it or prove the allergy at this point.“

“It is very good. And a good change of pace for lunch. Really fast“