35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Masury

“We had the angel hair with meatballs. It was excellent. The food is so good and you can't beat the prices! One of my favorite restaurants. Mike even visited every table. He is the owner and recovering from an accident. One of the best family owned small businesses around.“

“Nickys Pizzeria in Youngstown, Ohio, is a local treasure that consistently delivers on the promise of mouthwatering pizzas and Italian delights. The menu boasts a tempting array of pizza options, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of flavors. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a specialty creation, Nickys excels in taste and quality. What sets this pizzeria apart is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts. The attentive staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring guests feel right at home. Nickys Pizzeria is a must-visit in Youngstown, offering a slice of Italian culinary excellence that will leave you craving for more.“

“Great pizza, great service and the true Italian pizza maker made the experience well worth the stop. I had the New York style pizza and it couldn't have been any better. I am from out of town but make it there a couple times a year and I will be sure to stop again. Thanks "Now that's a pizza"“

“We went to our granddaughter's dance competition in April 2024 at the DeYor Performing Arts Center and had dinner at Avalon afterward. There was a line out the door to be seated on a Saturday night, but the customers waiting in line were friendly and assured us that the line moves fast - this restaurant obviously has a regular following. We sat at the bar and again sat among regulars. I had a Cabernet, and Ray had a beer. Heaven! I can't believe the menu here!!! It reminded me of my ex's Italian family recipes. I had the fried smelts and Brier Hill Pizza (just like my ex-grandmother in-law's homemade)! My husband had wedding soup - with homemade soup breads - another Youngstown staple! I make soup breads at home, but I have never had them at a restaurant. Impressive and delicious! My husband had a meat pizza and loved it. We ordered a potato pizza and cannoli to go. I didn't realize a restaurant still existed that served authentic Italian food. By the end of the evening, my cheeks were sore from smiling! What an experience!“

“One of the top four pizza shops in Youngstown, Liberty Uptown Pizza is delish. Crust is thick, edges crispy but not dry, and they're always generous with the cheese so no "extra cheese" orders necessary. Great for economical lunches (little Joe, salad, and drink + tip for under $10).“

“Me and my Fiancé came here for a date night away from the kids and the atmosphere, drinks and food was absolutely amazing ! My eyes grew so big when I entered the barn. The man at the bar was very welcoming when we came in so confused what to do he greeted us with a smile and helped us along the way! We are strongly thinking about having our wedding here In2025 #Killeenit2025“

“Iconic staple of Farrell and the Shenango Valley. Formerly known as Basilone's but now back to the original name "Farrell Hilltop Tavern." Food is second to none. Owners are wonderful. Can't go wrong with a pizza or the iconic Margie Dog.“

“Traveling through the area and called ahead for a pizza to go on our way through.Absolutely delicious pizza. The traditional pizzas are perfect, handmade to order.I love the option to add on a slice or two when you get there based on what they have available on the counter. They had an extra thick pizza come out when we were there so we added on a slice and what a treat! The crust was light and crispy. We also added breadsticks and sauce. Seating is only available outside right now, which didn’t matter to us too much, as we took it to go.“

“My family has been getting pizza there since 1964. I have been picking it up since 1979 when i got me driver's license lol. My kid are now getting it to. We live 40 mins away , only once in all these yrs have we gotten a bad pie and it was replaced with no problems. Quite possibly the next pizzas out there in my opinion with exception of home made.“

“I love their steak hoagies and pizza pizza!! Everything is homemade, and the freshly baked hoagie buns are absolutely delicious! I have always had great service regardless of me ordering for takeout or delivery. Everything that I have ate at Brothers is delicious! It's a nice atmosphere, and I love that they have a jukebox and also multiple big screen TVs to watch sports.“

“I got take out for lunch. I ordered online. Food is usually ready when you arrive. It is a good plan it you don't have a lot of time. The food is delicious. The service is always good & friendly. I have always been met with a smile & greeting. The atmosphere is good. Other things: Parking is limited out front, handicapped accessible, and they have many options on the menu. A good choice.“

“I enjoyed this restaurant immensely. I had the Chicken Fettucine Alfredo with a salad and a large bread roll I also had an unsweetened iced tea. The server was very attentive and the food was very good. The Chicken Fettucine was good with just about the right amount of white alfredo sauce, not too much or too little. I ordered unsweetened iced tea and when I mentioned I would sweeten it to my taste she asked which sweetener I preferred and provide that to me. She also kept the iced tea topped off for most of the meal. The bread is a well made white bread boule.It is a very nice and cozy restaurant. I was on travel visiting my son who lives in a group home nearby and went in without a reservation and was seated immediately. I have favorite restaurants in cities across the country, to include Washington, DC, Philadelphia, New York, Boston, San Diego, Denver, Los Angeles, Berkeley, San Jose, San Francisco, Phoenix and many other cities. Although, this may not be the most trendy restaurant in any of those cities, the service and the food would place it well within the standard of restaurants in most of those cities.It is an Italian restaurant. They may want to expand their menu to include some non-Italian food choices and include food allergy free food choices such as gluten free and a selection of vegetarian and other food types. This doesn't have to be an extremely large part of the menu. The salad was good but I prefer my lettuce to not be as cut up as it was. The dressing was put on the side which permitted me to put on how much dressing as I desired. I am getting older and eat smaller portions so the server provide me with everything I needed to save the left over Chicken Fettucine Alfredo and the bread.This is likely the best restaurant in the Sharon, Hermitage and Farrell area.“

“My brother grew up eating here weekly. We bought 3 pies on a recent family visit. Kids loved their cheese pizza and we got white cheese with jalapeños, mushrooms and pineapples. They made the pizza in 15 minutes and it was really good. Get some marinara sauce on the side for dipping. You'll "Thank" me later.“

“The service was amazing. Since it was our first time there we asked for advice about what was popular and tried a little bit of everything. The beef and cheese pastelillo was nice and beefy but the chicken and cheese was even better. The relleno was a much better version of a fried mashed potato ball than any other version I have had, with a little beef inside too. We got the slow roasted pork meal as well which was delicious and came with yellow rice which was amazing. The chef even brought out some beans to go with it on the house and they were delicious too. We got to try all their sauces. The mojito sauce was the best but they were all good. We're having the leftovers for dinner right now because we don't want to wait to have more. Give them a try!“

“The best authentic NY style pizza ? I ever tasted. I should know I lived in New York for 69 years. Not even little Italy in Cleveland can make NY style pizza the way Francesco's does. The the owner & workers are all professional courteous and kind. Sincerely, “

“Best pizza in Hubbard Ohio very good service and can hold party's thereVegetarian options: You can get a plain or and veggie pizzaKid-friendliness: There staff is very friendly to kidsParking: There all on the front of side of the building and they have about 20 spots to park“

“AMAZING PIZZA! Called for reservations before the PBR event at the Covelli Center this past weekend and was greeted promptly and taken right to our table. I wish I would have gotten our servers name, she was tremendous! Very attentive and getting our refills quickly! The Moscow mules-DELICIOUS!“

“The best and most affordable food in the Ohio Valley! Cinnamon "rolls" for .50 cents, meal worthy bread sticks $1.50, delicious pepperoni rolls for $3 and then there's the pizza! You can eat lunch everyday, not break the bank and enough options to never get burned out! If that's not enough, the people are great too!“

“Now this is old school pizza!!!! It tasted like Angela T's pizza from Sharpsville back in the day.Staff was polite, crust was perfect, crisp with a little pull. Ratio of toppings was exactly right. This was our first time here but we will definitely be back.“

“The Open/Closed times on Google is WRONG-FYIFriendly barmaid,decent pricesBUT pool tables are not up to par. Had to cut the nite short due to a jammed pool ball inside the table. Barmaid did not have access to opening it, & all other tables were occupied. Pool sticks were in poor condition as well.“

“If you want a taste of pizzas and calzone made Puerto Rican style look no further than this location. Great service and food was awesome. We drove in from Cleveland and the drive was completely worth it. It took a lot of restraint to not devour the pizza and calzone’s before getting back home. Highly recommend Johanzel Pizza….it does not disappoint. Si desea pizzas y calzones al estilo como en Puerto Rican…no miran más allá que está pizzería. El sabor te llevar directamente a nuestra Isla del Encanto. Fuimos desde Cleveland simplemente para compra la pizza y los calzones y el viaje valió la pena….es lo recomiendo en alto. Rey gracias por este gran servicio que le está dando a la comunidad. Bendiciones a usted y su familia.“

“Let me tell you about the history with me in this pizza shop, which a lot of you can relate. I played for sharpsville and Hermitage baseball from t-ball up to senior division, at least that's what it was called back then, and every time we had a game my mom and dad or Grandma and grandad would go get plaza Pizza and I thought that was better than ice cream and cake lol. I'm 49 years old and I still think that place is better than ice cream and cake LOL“

“Customer service is amazing!! The guys working there are so nice and friendly. I go there at least 2 to 4 times a week. The slices are great! When they have cookies they are amazing!! Drinks if you need it. Any kind of chicken pizza is my go to.Wheelchair accessibility: No step up or down to get in the door.“

“This location is great, but accessing the drive thru window can be confusing. Also ordering via the app can also be limiting, as it may not show all available options or offers unless you call or order in person. Also don't confuse the app and other food delivery apps as they all have different price points and available items.“

“The chicken and shrimp over rice with the tzaziki sauce is my go to. Flavorful, good portion size, and good value. Owner got me to try a tripe (cow stomach) dish he made for himself. Think I couldn't enjoy it just because I knew what it was.“

“My friend and I are truck & RV transporters, so we travel all over the country. We took a chance on this place - we prefer to eat local rather than always hitting a chain restaurant, but it's always a gamble. We are SO GLAD we chose to order Marchelloni's! Some of the absolute best pizza we have had in awhile. The sauce is delicious, the toppings generous without being ridiculous, pizza was cooked perfectly. Delivery was quick and the driver was friendly. We ordered online and it was pretty straightforward, easy to order half/half toppings. It arrived hot and we both made "oh WOW" sounds on the first bite. Definitely recommend. I wish I had this place back home!“

“Two friends and myself were in today (3-14-24)we each order pizzas. We had about a 25 minute drive home. Rachel gave us an insulated bag to put the pizzas in. She wrote our names in the pizza boxes. Rachel was very friendly, told us the specials and explained the toppings. She deserves a raise, she has great customer service, something we don’t see these days. Pizzas are delicious“

“You have to tell them you would like your pizza cooked a little longer. If not, your pizza won't be firm. And before you say that was a one-time experience, I went there twice in a week, and it was the same way.But the pizzas are great , the fish is great and service us wonderful.“

“Brought the wife here on the way to a high school musical. We both had fish. I had fried, she had baked. Mine was "all you can eat." We also had a garlic-cheese twist appetizer. The appetizer itself was delicious. Baked, served with its oil, with sauce for dipping. Waitress arrived with two large fried fish fillets on my plate. Paired with two sides, the two fillets were all that I could eat. They were nicely coated white fish fillets. This is a Wednesday and Friday deal that I recommend for anyone who enjoys fried fish. My wife got a baked fish that was perfect. We truly enjoyed our meals.“

“A really solid place to grab some food on campus. Sometimes when it's between classes, I just need somewhere to grab something cheap and easy, and their pizza is genuinely very good. I have gone here for years, the staff is very friendly, and the food always comes out quickly. Would definitely recommend. Pictured is their white pizza with ricotta.Vegetarian options: There are pizza options without meat.“

“Hubbard Domino's is probably the best dominos in the area in my opinion. My food is always made correctly, hot when I get it and it is always a quick delivery. So far every delivery driver I've had has been super polite, well spoken, and just all around nice.“

“The website does not give option for extra BBQ to be added to the chicken so I have to call and ask. This time they added it and it was perfect for me. The BBQ bacon chicken is the best. It's all I get but sometimes it is a little dry. But not this “

“manager is an absolute joy! his energy is amazing! he puts in many hours at that store. pizza is always on point and always ready when I get there to pick it up! I hope Papa John's took care of their employees with a Christmas bonus that they definitely deserve especially since they have the funding to donate to many charity's.Parking: employees cars look like they need a pay raise and I know this because some have been there long enough I know thier cars. value good employees so we are able to continue to have a great store to pick up our delicious pies!!“

“Fantastic pizza! I got the poormans style pizza and i don't think a pizza could be made better. And the dining room is reminiscent of pizza shops in the 90s which I love. Very clean too. I didn't expect it to be this good, I may have to stop back again tomorrow for more.“