Sandwich Shops near New Albany

Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
9725 Johnstown Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
Sandwich
Chips

“This Jersey Mikes is fantastic! The people are friendly, prompt, and the food is great!“

4.4 Superb68 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
5183 Hampsted Village Center Way, New Albany

“Ok so rn i am absolutely CRAVING a warmed BLT, so I looked up when y'all open (it's 2 am mind you ) anyway then I looked at the reviews and firstly you guys always make my sandwich so good, the store is clean, the service is nice, and yeah. the negative petty reviews are ridiculous. lol i'm still hungry“

3.2 Average96 Reviews
3

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
5186 New Albany Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie
Cookies

“Subway hadn’t been on my go to list for some time, but this young couple have put the franchise back at the top. I, with my very old mother in tow, now stop by this particular Subway every chance we get. They are friendly and fun, the establishment is clean, the bread and ingredients are fresh, and the finished product is delicious! Very highly recommended! And now, of course, I am starving!“

2.5 Average120 Reviews
Newfangled Kitchen Sandwich Shop • $
2258 E Main St, Bexley - 10.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Georgia Turkey Reuben Sandwich
Low Country Grilled Cheese
Dill Pickle Potato Salad
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Meatloaf Sandwich
Lucifer's Hammer
Hunter S Chicken
Swissshroom Melt
Georgia Reuben
Meatloaf Reuben

“You made me a superfan after my visit yesterday. From the sandwiches to the sides, you are doing something special there in Bexley.“

4.9 Superb91 Reviews
The Sandwich Man Sandwich Shop • $
612 S Yearling Rd, Whitehall - 9.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Sandwich
Jumbo Coney Dog
Beef Coney Dog
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Philly Steak
Hot Dogs
Fries
Sub

“I love a good burger, when done right, it's a treat. My barber told me about her colleague's place a few doors down from the shop. My food was made to order with 10* customer service. I had the BES wings out of curiosity, they are the bomb. The menu has a great selection of sandwiches. This will be my new lunch spot when I'm in the area. We need to sample the whole menu.“

4.7 Superb64 Reviews
Chicken Salad Chick Southern • $
6304 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville - 2.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pimento Cheese Croissant Mac-N-Cheese Grape Salad
Chicken Salad Croissant Meal
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Large Quick Chicks
Loaded Potato Soup
Of Chicken Salads
There Mini Cookie
Chicken Salad blt
Chicken Salad Melt
Jalapeno Holly

“Love this new location! The owners are very nice and kind! The staff is fabulous and the chicken salad phenomenal! They opened a little over a week ago and I’ve gone three times including midnight for the grand opening, met some really nice people waiting in line for that. So if you’re hungry for something other than the usual burger and fries, definitely check this place out, they have 12 flavors of chicken salad made fresh daily, either a sandwich or with crackers you can’t go wrong. Located at 4345 W. Dublin-Granville Road in the Shoppes at River Ridge.“

4.1 Good147 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Hamilton Morse Sandwich Shop • $
4994 N Hamilton Rd Spc B, Columbus - 3.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Firehouse Steak & Cheese Large 11-12 Inch
Pepperoni Pizza Meatball Sub
Spicy Cajun Chicken Combo
Hook and Ladder Sub
Hook & Ladder Combo
New York Steamer
Banana Peppers
Club on a Sub
Firehouse Hero
Mac & Cheese

“Im a regular at this location so much that when I walk in the door, "Its Hi Bryan". Its like your part of their family. All the people there are awesome to deal with. I've been to a couple other stores in town, and no one compares to the North store on Hamilton Rd in the Meijers parking lot.“

4 Good65 Reviews
8

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
2181 E Livingston Ave, Columbus - 11.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baja Turkey with Sliced Avocado Footlong Pro Double Protein
Meatball Marinara
Cold Cut Combo
Potato Chip
Cookies
Wrap

“Two ladies in there one was older lady and one was younger lady the older lady gave me the greatest customer service experience in a long time this lady said that we were her favorite couple of the day very bubbly positive engaging very patient with us because we didn't know what we wanted when we went in here sorry I didn't get your name but I really appreciate your positive attitude and I enjoyed our conversation about ice cream“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
7175 E Broad St, Blacklick - 6.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Original Italian
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Philly Cheesesteak
Club Sub
blt Sub
Mike

“Great. Food and service. Staff is always friendly and great.“

3.9 Good60 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
7639 Farmsbury Dr, Reynoldsburg - 9.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Club Sub

“I love Jersey Mike's there's sandwiches remind me of my childhood growing up in Philadelphia eating hoagies and steak sandwiches
The experience is always good except for ONE occasion but that was straightened out.
I'm happy to say they're still my favorite place to go.“

4.2 Good26 Reviews
Jon Smith Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1119 S Hamilton Rd, Columbus - 9.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Authentic Italian 12
Teriyaki Chicken 12
Giant Deli Subs
Meatball Bomb 6
The Steak Bomb
Cuban Sandwich
Crispy Chicken
Steak Bomb Sub
Turkey Breast
French Fries

“Great sandwiches, fresh veggies and fresh fries. Coca cola fountain drinks . Offered hit subs with a variety of meats as well as cold subs . Worth trying out.“

3.8 Good78 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
By Canes And Smoothie King, 1340 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 3.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak with Peppers and Onion
Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Club Supreme
Chips
blt

“Hello, I am a long time customer and came in today to redeem my birthday reward. After some confusion on my part with, the gm Payton was so lovely and professional and cleared the confusion. Provided excellent customer service. I can tell she runs her store(s) with keeping the customers experience in mind! The workers on the line, Amanda and Joe were awesome as well, great team!“

3.7 Good101 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
5957 S Sunbury Rd, Westerville - 4.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
Jersey Shore's Favorite
Turkey and Provolone
Club Supreme
Club Sub
Chips

“Although it was Superbowl Sunday (busy, busy, busy), the staff was extremely accommodating. Of course, the subs were delicious as usual! Although I normally order from their app which is excellent, I found ordering in the Sunbury Rd store location also extremely easy and pleasant.“

3.8 Good51 Reviews
14

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
5992 Westerville Rd G, Westerville - 6.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Roasted Turkey
The Hotshot Italiano
Italian B M T
Subway Club
Turkey Sub
Steak
Tuna

“Great location! The service was good.They loaded the salad a little weird - I had to deconstruct it to heat the chicken.The dressings were plentiful and prepackaged- overall the quality of the produce was really good.

Vegetarian options: Lots of options for fresh veggies!

Dietary restrictions: Loads of options for most diets

Parking: Make sure to lock your vehicle- this area has had some break ins.

Kid-friendliness: Kids meals and seating available

Wheelchair accessibility: Standard accessibility“

3.8 Good45 Reviews
15

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
7143 E Main St, Reynoldsburg - 8.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vitamin Water xxx
Spicy Italian
Veggie Delite
Cookies

“I had a fantastic experience at the Subway on Main Street in Reynoldsburg! The staff was incredibly friendly and efficient, ensuring my order was prepared exactly the way I wanted. The ingredients were fresh, and the bread was perfectly baked, making for a delicious sandwich. The restaurant was clean, well-maintained, and had a welcoming atmosphere. I also appreciated how quickly they handled the lunch rush without compromising quality. This location stands out as one of the best Subways I’ve visited. Highly recommend for a quick, satisfying meal!“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
331 S Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 5.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Chicken Bacon Ranch
Toasted Roast Beef Cheddar
Toasted Ultimate Italian
Jimmy Cubano
Vito

“Placed a large order for 17 people today. They arrived early and everything was correct! Great Job Jimmy Johns!!!“

3.7 Good49 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
2497 E Main St, Bexley - 10.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy East Coast Italian

“We order from here frequently! Tonight they made a mistake and made my sandwich wrong (which was the first time they had ever done this!) ! I called and just wanted to let them know, didn’t expect much other than to make them aware they screwed up and the manager the sweetest lady, offered to remake my sandwich and deliver it to me or credit my account! They delivered a new sandwich quickly! Truly great customer service!! Happy girl!“

3.7 Good47 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
102 Etna Crest Blvd, Pataskala - 11.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mike's Famous Philly

“Good food, friendly staff, and a nice new location. We love the subs, and it is usually a quick experience for lunch or dinner.

On the downside, parking lot is small with too many high traffic businesses in one spot. A little pricey for sandwiches and they could clean the tables more often in between customers.“

4.1 Good16 Reviews
Mr. Hero Sandwich Shop • $
2087 E Livingston Ave, Columbus - 11.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roman Burger and Waffle Fries
Philly Cheese Steak
Sicilian Parm Steak
Breaded Mushrooms
Funnel Cake Fries
Potato Waffers
Cheesesteak
Romanburger
Waffer Fries
Sandwiches

“Got done seeing a nearby event and wanted some food. Felt bad about it but stopped and ordered food with less than half hour before close and they had no issues with it whatsoever. They were also kind enough to let us(me and my girlfriend) use their bathrooms even after they locked up for the night. They were very kinda and thorough with our orders too which is something I personally don't see often in the food industry. The food was delicious as always and would definitely go there again if I go back to Columbus anytime soon! Thank you for reading.“

3.6 Good72 Reviews
Potbelly Sandwich Shop Sandwich Shop • $
782 N State St, Westerville - 7.48 miles
3.8 Good23 Reviews
21

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
8138 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg - 6.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Spicy Italian
Veggie Delite
Subway Club
The Boss
Sandwich
Tuna

“There was this kind lady, Daniel, I believe. I like my sub a certain way and she tried her best. Even asked some other blond lady she was with and the lady didn’t know either so daniel GOOGLED how to do it perfectly for me. I tried tipping her and she told me she wouldn’t accept it 10/10 this girl is awesome!“

3.6 Good37 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
364 Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 5.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philadelphia Cheesesteak
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Fresh-Cut Fries
Chicken Teriyaki
Sub

“Every time I go in here or even the one down on Henderson I feel dirty because the place is dirty. I submitted pictures of trash underneath the cash kiosk broken tables pop machines did not work the only thing I could drink was water or iced tea. But yeah I was still charged $18 for lunch.....“

3.5 Good84 Reviews
Charleys Cheesesteaks Cheesesteaks • $
6975 E Broad St, Columbus - 6.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Cheese \u0026 Bacon Fries
Cheese Steak Sandwich
Boneless Wings Combo
Chicken Philly Combo
Classic Wings Combo
Bacon 3 Cheesesteak
Ultimate Fries
Original Fries
Chicken Wings

“The food is delicious the staff is friendly and the food is delivered quickly to your table, my son loves the fries with cheese and bacon. I recommend this charleys“

3.5 Good68 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2480 E Main St, Columbus - 10.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fan Ous Roast Beef and Provolone
Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
Chocolate Chip Cookie
The Original Italian
Club Supreme
Chips

“Stopped by to pick up dinner. I enjoyed the service I received. The two works were very friendly. Enjoyed the laughs while waiting for my order.“

3.5 Good68 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
7377 OH-3, Westerville - 7.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Club Sub
Sandwich
Chips

“Went in today, 3/15. Was right before close which I didn’t realize. They put the slicer that was freshly cleaned back together to take our order.

The 3 guys in here took great care of us (didn’t catch names) took their time, made sure everything was 100% for us.
The food is Jersey Mikes you can’t really go wrong but the service is what really stood out and was much appreciated.“

3.5 Good65 Reviews
Charleys Cheesesteaks Cheesesteaks • $
4600 International Gateway Ste 245, Columbus - 7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly with Lettuce and Tomato
Philly Cheesesteak Combo

“I usually go here when I get tired of eating everything else in the food court. I usually always see the same three ladies working when I do. They always smile and they're always nice when I order! The owner is always sweet as well when she's there! Chicken is always great as are the sandwiches. Now, with the boneless chicken, I just wish Everytime I order it, I don't have to wait 6 minutes as the bone-in is always ready. I don't mind waiting when I don't really care about my lunch time and that's most times, but imagine if I didn't have time to wait🤷🏿‍♀️🤷🏿‍♀️🤷🏿‍♀️. Overall, I love the staff here and the food is always pretty good!“

3.6 Good29 Reviews
27

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
604 Morrison Rd, Gahanna - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Subway Footlong Cookie
Lay’S Classic
Chocolate Chip
Subway Club
Cookies
Tuna
Poke

“I'm writing this review for the Subway in the StoneRidge Plaza. The service and food are great. The bread is so soft and fresh I can't believe it's a Subway but it is. I've enjoyed Subway my whole life honestly but this location is my favorite.“

3.5 Good41 Reviews
Steak Escape - Westerville Sandwich Shop • $
579 S State St, Westerville - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Totally Loaded Fries
Bourbon \u0026 Bacon
House-Baked Cookies
Philly Cheesesteak
Triple Cheesesteak
Fresh Cut Fries
Italian Hottie
Korean BBQ Bowl
Italian Bowl

“Amazing cheesesteak. Amazing service. Value-wise, this definitely beats Wario's for the best cheesesteak in the city. Sesame seed bun is so fresh and the steak is melty. They shouldn't even offer the Italian hoagie. Sesame seed is that good.“

3.4 Good139 Reviews
29

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
110 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Footlong Pro Double Protein
Turkey Cali Club 6 Inch Regular Sub
Spicy Italian 6 Inch Regular Sub
Cookies

“The protein bowl and footlocker cookie are my new go-to! I've bought it at several different locations, so my experiences vary. Service was always friendly, but a couple of workers were noticeably stressed. They were working alone, part of my order was not available in the store.“

3.5 Good26 Reviews
Firehouse Subs South Gahanna Sandwich Shop • $
406 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket
Smoked Turkey Breast Sub
Firehouse Meatball Sub
Hook and Ladder Sub
Spicy Cajun Chicken
Create Your Own Sub
Turkey Bacon Ranch
New York Steamer
Firehouse Salad
Bottled Water

“I always go to this Firehouse subs because of Alexis. She is a rockstar and always makes my husband and I feel so welcome! Not to mention she always goes above and beyond to make every experience excellent.“

3.4 Good87 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
51 McNaughten Rd, Columbus - 7.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Philly Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Teriyaki
Fresh-Cut Fries
French Fries
Cheesesteak
Italian Sub
Reuben
Pizza

“The staff is amazing and friendly up there, they remember your name, always prompt service, definitely one of the best Penn stations I like going to, also I am able to fit my bobtail semi truck on the side of building while I grab my food, and even with all the construction because of the traffic lights it’s easy to exit location and get back on the road. Keep up the great work you guys are awesome at this Penn station.

BTW
I always get my chicken teriyaki sub, and anyone that hasn’t tried their lemonade is missing out lol it’s delicious… 🤤

Parking: Very easy if you’re about to tell, semi truck to park on side of the building and grab your food, and easy to exit right onto the main street with traffic lights so you can get back on the road.“

3.4 Good74 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
6915 E Broad St, Columbus - 6.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vito

“Jimmy John’s on Broad Street is quite the operation. A well oiled machine. Strong teamwork. Exceptional service. Fresh. Clean. Keeps me coming back. That bread draws me in. #freakyfast.“

3.4 Good26 Reviews
Charleys Cheesesteaks Cheesesteaks • $
3900 Morse Rd, Columbus - 5.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak
Original Fries
French Fries
3.3 Good30 Reviews
Charleys Cheesesteaks Cheesesteaks • $
3849 E Broad St, Whitehall - 8.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken California Cheesesteak Boxed Meal
Regular Cheese Steak Combo Everything
Boneless Chicken Wings and Fries Combo
Philly Cheesesteak & Wing Combo Meal
Watermelon Strawberry Lemonade
Veggie Cheesesteak Boxed Meal
Chicken Philly and Fries
Louisiana Cajun Fries
Old School Cheesesteak
Cheese & Bacon Fries

“Bomb asf ❤️❤️❤️ i love the food the chicken was good“

3.3 Good84 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2500 E Main St, Bexley - 10.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Fresh-Squeezed Lemonade
Snack Size Cheesesteak
Philly Cheese Steak
Fresh-Cut Fries
Reuben
Chips
Pizza
Sub

“Lovely staff very polite, very respectful very helpful being as tho it’s been a very long time since I’ve ate here. Everyone here was bery kind I loved that and the food top notch everything freshly made and freshly weighed yummmmmy I love when I come into an establishment and the ppl love their job. I’ll pick this location any day great job you guys.“

3.3 Good99 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
4018 Morse Crossing, Columbus - 6.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

The J J Gargantuan
Italian Night Club
Veggie Sub

“My lunch was super fast! Thanks. Being in office has been a tad different. By the time I placed my order and received it, it was less than 20 minutes. #freakyfast!! 👌🏼👍🏼👊🏼“

3.2 Average26 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
576 W Schrock Rd, Westerville - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roast Beef and Provolone

“We love ordering from Jimmy John's almost every Sunday! The staff is so friendly—we're practically on a first-name basis—and our order is always ready and delicious. The app is super convenient, letting us order even before the store opens and schedule a pick-up time, something other apps don't offer. Highly recommend!“

3.2 Average54 Reviews
38

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
6994 E Broad St Unit 7, Columbus - 6.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
The Ultimate B M T
Sandwich

“this short kid with glasses made the best sandwiches. good service, give the short kid with glasses a raise, (i think his name was collin i could be wrong) but yeah i reccomend this. only thing is one time i was here and a customer asked for more cucmbers and this random guy added one, so he said it in a scary voice and he added like 2 handfuls of cucmbers so that was weird but again overall great service and place.“

3.1 Average19 Reviews
DiBella's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
4980 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville - 2.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

9 Godfather Sub w Sweet Peopers
Grandma DiBella's Cookies
DiBella's Cheesesteak
DiBella's Pasta Salad
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Philly
DiBella's blt
Uncle Louie

“for the love of all sandwich please open shop in Dansville ny. no good sandwiches in 50 miles any direction. save the stateworkers stomaches! this is no joke. these people need sandwich heros. they need people who care about food. I've read your requirements and I consider how it seems to you that the location is not qualifyable. I'm telling you though those numbers are meaningless along a state highway that holds the crossroads to the center of all directions the hungry deprived people will come. please help this neglected part of New York and revolutionize food for some of the hardest working men and women. it's a travesty what people slap as a sandwich here. a crime against humanity we need a godfather for food!“

3.2 Average77 Reviews
Penn Station East Coast Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2062 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg - 9.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Chicken Philly Small Chicken Philly Large Fry Small Fry Large Lemonade Medium Lemonade
Small Steak Philly with Onions Small Fry Medium Lemonade
Snack Size Cheesesteak
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Philly Cheese Steak
Squeezed Lemonade
Mega Cheesesteak
Pizza Sub & Fries
Fresh-Cut Fries
French Fries

“Went around 7pm they had 3 workers there and they were all very nice and fast and everything was wonderful. It was two guys and a girl not sure of their names but definitely great workers!! And thank you for getting cheese 🧀 sauce it's amazing 👏!!“

3.2 Average94 Reviews
41

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
14 S Williams St, Johnstown - 8.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cold Cut Sub
Sandwich

“I am so glad that we have this subway in our town! The food is always super fresh and very tasty. This is by far the best subway I have ever been to! People are very friendly as well, service is great and food is delicious and affordable. I go here with my husband very often and we never had a bad experience! Glad they are in our town! 🤗“

3.1 Average35 Reviews

Find More Tastes In New Albany

You May Also Like